Part of my education as a business writer took place about 18 months ago, shortly before The Newhall Land and Farming Co. broke out its frequently used gold-plated shovel and ceremoniously started work on the Hyatt Valencia and Santa Clarita Conference Center.
Was this a blow to the existing hotels and motels in the area? Were they going to suffer because this glorious new four-star Hyatt hotel, or one with more stars than the Hampton Inn or the Ranch House Inn, was coming in and would syphon off some of the long-existing places' business?
I asked some of the managers of these hotels, and the answers were no, and no. A full-service Hyatt hotel and the conference facilities, with all the amenities, would draw hundreds of businessmen a week to Santa Clarita. But while they'll be coming up for meetings and conventions, they won't all be able, for reasons of space availability and because of economic considerations, to stay at the Hyatt. So they'll attend their business functions there but bunk overnight at one of the six or eight somewhat less luxurious accommodations around town. It was my first lesson about spillover.
To much of Southern California, Santa Clarita is still known as "the town close to Magic Mountain." When Six Flags California will become "the theme park next to Santa Clarita" is anyone's guess, but the Hyatt is probably the second attraction that will make the SCV a destination. The hotel's sales staff now has a daunting task — to convince organizations that have been holding their regional sales meetings at the Burbank Hilton or the Los Angeles Convention Center or the Anaheim Convention Center that the Santa Clarita Valley and the Hyatt is a better deal.
I don't know who's offering what kind of financial considerations to whom when it comes to attracting convention dollars. I can report that, having driven through Orange County, I'd much rather come over Newhall Pass and into the SCV.
The city sank a sizable chunk of change into this project, much of it for infrastructure improvements. There was a little complaining at the time these commitments were made. Corporate welfare was the term bandied about. But lots of those conventioneers and other Hyatt visitors are going to stroll across McBean Parkway and into the mall, where they will spend money that generates tax dollars. The estimate is $1 million a year, which should help Santa Clarita recoup its investment soon enough.
Clyde Smyth, the city's former mayor, showed up at many ground breakings and ribbon cuttings and often delivered a speech that varied little from occasion to occasion. No William Jennings Bryan, Smyth would remind the audience that "the city has to generate tax dollars to fix its streets, pay for recreational programs, et al. This new (fill in the blank) will help us accomplish that. Thank you very much."
Spillover apparently also works in the restaurant business as well. One of the most interesting start-ups in the last two years is Gallagher's Old Town Restaurant in Newhall, because Joe and Maryanne Gallagher basically tossed away their old careers (including Mrs. Gallagher's as the inventor of kids' modeling clay with fragrance) and gambled that people in the SCV would eventually want to come to Newhall, the least modern community in the valley, and enjoy a dinner that costs a little more than the "family restaurant" chains.
After one year I checked with the Gallagher's and it was interesting to find out that the chains that opened on The Old Road, in the shadow of the new Wal-Mart and the other superstar retailers, had not hurt Gallagher's. In fact, all those restaurants, very visible from the freeway, had gotten a lot of people in the SCV into an "eat out" frame of mind. It eventually spilled over to Gallagher's, which has been doing fairly well for the last 10 months or so.
Still, it's an unfortunate truth that owning a restaurant is one of the biggest gambles a small businessman can make. Accountants will shake their heads and warn that a staggering percentage, maybe as many as half, don't survive a year. Last week I spoke with the owners of one of those who may not make it, Juggles on Cinema Drive, who lamented that the chain eateries on the Old Road are in plain sight near Interstate 5. They are also at shopping meccas and draw people who come to shop, suddenly become hungry, and stop in at one of the chains because a) they're already there and b) they know what to expect. Not too many people visit a restaurant because they're willing to be challenged by new foods.
I don't rate or review restaurants because it's not my job or my forte. I know that some chains are really good and I would recommend them to anyone who asked, some are just OK, and some I visit only because it's after midnight and nothing else is open. The owners of Juggles sank $1 million into building the themed restaurant from the ground up (it would have been more but one of the owners used to work in television and knew how to get a lot of the wacky visual stuff on the cheap), and now the place needs fresh capital to survive and is temporarily closed down.
I hope they make it because they had an idea and ran with it. In our free enterprise society that is something to be respected. And themed restaurants do pretty well in major centers, even though the hamburgers at the Hard Rock Cafe are no better than the ones I make in my own kitchen and the odds of actually spotting Mick Jagger at the next booth are infinitesimal in the extreme.
But Juggles is not in a major center. It's on Cinema Drive, a street must Santa Claritans drive on only for specific purposes. Usually that purpose is not to go to Juggles. There are other hazards that those of us that have never run a business can only imagine. When I visited the place this week, the air conditioning had not been switched on. The owners were willing to sit there and sweat because cooling off a room that size costs $200 a day, a cost that can stagger a business quickly.
But if you can hang on and cut a few corners without letting levels deteriorate, maybe you can make it. This is the SCV. It's a place where apparently people like to eat out. And, if the Hyatt has some success, it's a place to which people will visit and do more than ride a roller coaster.
* * *
Jack Katzanek is the Signal's business editor. His column appears Sundays. He can be reached at 805-259-1234, extension 237.
