One of the most important decisions an employer makes on any given day is whether to terminate an employee.
It sounds like a simple task for an employer; however, in today’s litigious climate, it is not so simple or cheap. Most of the ease or hardship associated with firing an employee depends on whether the employer has insured that the employer has created an “ at-will ” employment relationship with the employee from the beginning.
If the employee signed a form (or employment manual) acknowledging that he was an at-will employee, and that document was unambiguous about that fact, the employer could terminate the employee with the need for cause or advance notice. Similarly, if the employment relationship is at-will , then the employee may quit or resign without advance notice.
If the acknowledgment of at-will employment or the employee manual does not unambiguously state that employment is at-will , or the employer has made statements to the contrary, then the employee may have expectations of employment for a set term or that they will be terminated only for cause. It is this situation, where the nature of the relationship is unclear or has been made unclear by the employer’s statements and conduct that leads to the vast majority of employment lawsuits in California.
Although California courts assume all employment in California is “at will” unless otherwise stated, statements made between the employer (written and oral), the employer’s agents, and the employee can rapidly alter that assumption. Already you can see that good administrative documents— the employee manual or employment guidelines and forms— are invaluable to any business, no matter the size, if they have employees.
Middle management employees and human resource personnel— or your one and only office worker or office manager— especially need to be trained to handle situations on a daily basis where the ordinary at-will employee may be transformed into something more. Although it is often difficult for an employee to overcome the hurdle of at-will employment, it happens often enough that many lawsuits in California and mediated matters center solely on that issue.
Setting out the terms of the employment prior to hiring an employee is the best way to ensure an environment for good communication between employer and employee. Good communication in turn helps to avoid the misinterpretation of words and deeds which cause the vast majority of employment-related lawsuits. If you are an employer in today’s world, get it straight from the beginning and get it in writing.
Michele Mann is the owner of Mann & Associates, a Santa Clarita law firm specializing in estate planning, wills, trusts, probate and business representation. She can be reached at (800) 546-0606 or on the Web at www.californiawills.com . “Legal Forum” appears Fridays and rotates among SCV attorneys. Information should not be interpreted as specific legal advice.
