Jennifer called me, crying and frustrated. “We’re gonna lose our deposit,” she sputtered— “all that money we saved over the years!”
I learned that Jennifer and her husband had committed to buy a home but couldn’t close the deal.
The young couple had been “ pre-approved ” for a loan and was promised financing for their dream on very favorable terms: 6. 5-percent fixed interest on a 30-year loan with no points or origination fee. With these terms and a modest down payment, they’d start their life together with a place on the map. Contracts were signed and Jennifer’s life savings were put at risk as a good-faith deposit.
At this critical time, the once-friendly mortgage broker stopped returning telephone calls. Relations chilled. The clock ticked toward closing. Finally, an unfamiliar voice called and reported, “The best we can do is 8.75 percent with another $5,000 in origination fees.” The pre-approval went up in smoke and the deal was soon to follow.
Jennifer failed to understand that “ pre-approval ” has virtually no meaning when it comes to closing a deal on a home.
A pre-approval is a preliminary “OK” for a possible loan on given terms. The pre-approval is largely based upon your credit history, the amount you seek to borrow, and the size of the down payment you are able to provide.
A pre-approval is not a commitment to loan money. Only the execution of loan documents and actual funding of the loan mean anything with regard to closing the deal.
Jennifer’s case took a wrong turn because the mortgage broker made the pre-approval sound like a loan guarantee. She was a first-time home buyer with little experience in such matters. The mortgage broker led her to believe that she would be financed on the pre-approval terms for a house at a certain price.
The majority of brokers and real-estate agents are ethical and hard working. However, Jennifer’s case is one of several I have seen where a crooked mortgage broker hooked up with a real estate agent, both knowing that the possibility of any loan is unlikely, but willing to put their client at risk in hopes of making a buck.
Because Jennifer relied on certain terms, she had no ability to make a higher down payment or pay a loan origination fee. She grew desperate. The sellers grew desperate and angry with Jennifer. Her desperation was compounded by other factors: The loan wasn’t large enough to be profitable for the broker and it became too much work. The broker had no incentive to see the matter through, and simply stopped work on the file. The clock ticked and the deal failed to close on time. The seller demanded that Jennifer forfeit her deposit— her life savings.
Fortunately, Jennifer’s story has a happy ending. The mortgage broker had been so deceptive that proof of fraud was likely. A finding of fraud would have been the end of his brokerage license. He decided to trade that for the originally promised terms. Jennifer got her loan and got her house. But she also got lucky.
If a mortgage broker gives you a pre-approval , ask the hard questions: What will I need to get the deal funded on these terms? Will I have to pay a loan origination fee? Do I have to show reserve savings in the bank? How much? Do my reserves have to be seasoned (more than 60 days in the bank)? What is the very minimum down payment? Will closing costs be rolled into the loan?
I guarantee that disappointing answers are better than a disappointing lawsuit. So, as the saying goes, let the pre-approved buyer beware.
Anthony D. Zinnanti of Saugus is a practicing attorney in the San Fernando and Santa Clarita Valleys.
