Unexpectedly, I spent the better portion of the week trying a criminal jury trial. The matter was unspectacular; my client’s alleged theft of a $119 jacket from a Target store.
The pre-trial judge warned me against trying the case. I was assured by the judge that the smattering of “mall people” comprising the jury would quickly condemn my client. “Around here,” he said, “they simply don’t care. They’re very apathetic.”
On the other hand, the prosecution left my client with the option of pleading to the charge or being convicted of the charge. The hard line stance made my choice a no brainer. Try the case.
For two days, counsel and I beat each other up on the record. My client sat and literally wept at the prospect of conviction.
Challenges, objections and accusations flew. Witnesses turned various shades of crimson on the witness stand. Finally, the messy “sausage making” of trial was over. Counsel argued their points and the matter was submitted.
Then, something amazing happened: the jury deliberated. I paced in the hallway, marking my steps on the banal gray tile. And, the jury deliberated.
I killed some time with a phone call. And, the jury deliberated. I chatted with the court staff. And, the jury deliberated. Since the outset of the case, an issue lurked in the background. My client was Arabic. Specifically, he was Iranian; from one of the member states of the so-called “Axis of Evil.”
I wondered if this would mean doom for the defense. My client, taking the stand in his defense, testified in Farsi through a translator. There was no hiding the fact of his ethnicity.
Conversely, I couldn’t risk offending the jury with questions on their ability to be fair on this issue. I had no choice but to have faith in fairness and faith in the people that served on the jury.
The jury deliberated through the afternoon.
Finally, the judge recessed the twelve. They returned in the morning to resume their debate. The clock ticked away. Several questions came in. We conferenced with the foreperson. Her face displayed obvious concern. It was her duty to oversee fairness in the deliberations.
There was a read-back of some testimony. Well into their second day of deliberations, the jury resumed deliberations.
An hour later, the buzzer sounded. A verdict had been reached. The jury filed into the courtroom. The paper unfolded in the hands of the clerk.
“We the jury in the above entitled action find the defendant GUILTY of the crime of petty theft.”
Simultaneously, there was the disappointment of defeat, but the overwhelming urge to run over and hug these people.
Sure, their verdict had something to do with the fact that my client bolted through the store exit with the goods in hand.
But, the disappointment was eclipsed by the pride I had for the jury’s commitment to justice. These people had spent a substantial amount of their time— by their own free will— carefully deliberating the fate of my client.
I’m a loser. But, I’m elated. I’m elated because it was a loss to the defense, but a victory for the system.
The jury didn’t deliberate the fate of my client, the obviously guilty, or my client, the Iranian national. The jury deliberated the fate of my client, the accused.
Here, the lawyers lawyered, the jurors deliberated, and our system worked. In subsequent conversation with the jurors, I would learn that it wasn’t about a lousy $119 jacket, petty theft or political preconception, but the prospect of unjustly convicting a person of a crime.
These twelve jurors should be very proud of their service. The contrast between the nominal charge and the extent of consideration shows that people do care.
The people that served elevated the system above prejudice and apathy and rendered a rational decision on the basis of the evidence. This possibility of justice means much more than winning - in the humble observation of this elated loser.
Anthony D. Zinnanti, Esq., of Saugus, practices law in the Santa Clarita and San Fernando Valley.
