This author last month successfully handled an interesting case that illuminated and crystallized an issue regarding past-due child support. The case was Fogarty vs. Rasbeary and was published in March in the legal journals.
The facts involved a couple that divorced in 1967. They had one daughter from their marriage. When the child was less than a year old, the maternal grandparents took physical custody of her, and the child was raised by the grandparents even after she turned 18 years old.
Emanating from the divorce was a physical custody order and child support order. Mom was awarded physical custody and Dad was ordered to pay $150 a month in child support.
Attempts were made by Mom to collect past-due child support in the late 1970s, as Dad was often late, paid the grandparents directly, or did not make payments as required.
In 1981, the grandparents told Dad not to make any child support payments. Instead, an agreement was reached whereby Dad would build a tack cabin for the child’s horse gear, pay for other extracurricular activities, pay for trips and give the child spending money directly. Dad always lived in the same area and maintained contact with his child, although sporadically at times. Mom never disclosed her whereabouts to Dad and moved from place to place.
In 1997, Mom obtained a summary renewal of the judgment for child support. Dad opposed the renewal, claiming the statute of limitations expired. He also raised an equitable defense called “laches,” meaning an unreasonable delay occurred and prejudice resulted.
The trial court ruled in favor of Dad and denied the renewal of judgment. The court opined that the renewal was a transparent attempt by Mom to obtain money for herself. The court also held that Mom really did not raise the child herself, nor did she contribute to her financial support. The court further stated that the delay in seeking enforcement of the judgment was an unreasonable delay and Dad was prejudiced.
Mom filed an appeal and the appellate court also found in favor of Dad and provided a complete analysis of the applicable laws germane to the issue.
By way of background, in 1992 and 1993 two California statutes were enacted that provided that judgments for child support are exempt from renewal, and that they are enforceable until paid in full.
However, laches is an equitable defense to the enforcement of stale claims. It may be applied where the complaining party has unreasonably delayed in the enforcement of a right, and where the party has acquiesced in the adverse party’s conduct or where the adverse party has suffered prejudice that makes the granting of relief unfair or inequitable.
Since family law courts are courts of equity, a family court has the authority and inherent power to apply this equitable defense.
The court further opined that although a statute of limitations defense has been eliminated through statute and case law, regarding both spousal and child support, the defense of laches still exists under the appropriate circumstances. It appears that the legislative intent was to keep intact this defense as discussed in an Assembly bill, and by the creation of newer statutes.
On balance, the appellate court’s decision was bolstered by the overall equity of a result that allows a trial court to do what is fair under the unique factual circumstances of each case.
Of course, this does not mean that if you fail to pay child support you are free from enforcement of the judgment. However, under the proper factual situation, and laches can be proven, you stand a chance of raising these issues in your individual case. In fact, just one week later, a different appellate court ruled that even if a child support order is dormant, it is not entirely extinguishable, and hence collectable.
In the final analysis, each case must stand on its own merits, but a thorough analysis must be made regarding the facts and the conduct of the parties in determining your rights.
Gary M. Weinstein practices family law in Newhall and Culver City. He can be reached at 291-1903 . “Legal Forum” appears Fridays and rotates among SCV attorneys. Information should not be interpreted as specific legal advice.
