“Is this conversation privileged?” In other words, if I say something to you, are you going to tell someone else? Are you required to tell someone else?
It’s a question that all too often goes unasked, and sometimes to the discloser’s chagrin. People typically, and erroneously, rely on assumptions rooted in folklore, rather than asking about
their rights of privacy. This is a consequence that goes well beyond the realm of the lawyer-client relationship.
Years ago, in the course of a homicide investigation, I had the opportunity to talk to several Catholic priests. We believed that the perpetrator had confessed to the killing. The accommodating clergyman surprised me when he declared his readiness to reveal— if only the perp had not been in a confessional setting.
The father went on to explain that he had reported several child abusers and spousal batterers who blabbed outside the ambit of the confessional. Consistent with the religious canons, secular law says the penitential communication must be “made in confidence, in the presence of no third persons.” It appears that group confessions are out.
Now that you’ve probably filed your tax return, it’s a great time for me to tell you there is no such thing as accountant-client privilege. Any verbal or written disclosure to your accountant is subject to discovery, subpoena or compelled testimony.
This is starkly unfair to the accounting industry and the public, as most accountants are clearly knowledgeable about undeclared income and the consequences of not reporting. On the other hand, you can hire a tax lawyer for considerably more money, and not only disclose your unreported income but tell him where the bodies are hidden. Ask before you blab.
You may remember two fellows named
Erik and Lyle Menendez. Their claim to fame was the disposal of their parents with twin shotguns. The plan unraveled when the “boys
in blue” kicked in the door of the Menendez psychotherapist, recovering audio tapes of
the otherwise confidential and privileged communications.
Erik and Lyle’s conversations about their plan to kill were revealed to the jury under the “dangerous patient” (or legalese, “Tarasoff”) exception.
In 1969, when Prosenjit Poddar disclosed to his therapist his intent to kill Tatiana Tarasoff— and then did kill Tatiana Tarasoff— the Supreme Court crafted an exception to the patient-therapist privilege and, in some cases, a duty of disclosure.
Private communications between a patient and a therapist, psychologist or psychiatrist are not subject to disclosure unless there is a reasonable belief that you are about to hurt someone, or yourself. The patient-physician privilege largely follows the patient-therapist model.
Marriage is the biggest source of privileged communications. The law states that pillow talk between husband and wife is not to be the subject of investigation. However, there is no such privilege in the case of divorce and domestic violence proceedings. So, unless you take a swing at your spouse, there’s no need to ask, “ Hunny-bunny , is this privileged?”
Your privileged communications are subject to investigation if you sue the doctor, therapist or lawyer to whom you made the statement. Also, if you claim a personal injury by a third party (i.e., car accident), the proof of your injuries via medical and mental health treatment is subject to discovery.
As for me, the lawyer, you can pretty much tell me anything. Lawyers have about the most stringent rule of privilege. You can tell me that you intend to lie, cheat and steal. However, don’t tell me that you have a plan and means for killing or maiming someone. In theory, there is no privilege in the case of harm.
In reality, the lawyer runs the risk of severe admonishing by the court or being sued. Lawyers have a superior duty to protect client secrets at every peril, and this creates a serious dilemma at times.
But, when a child-abusing client enlisted my services for the purpose of continued abuse of her teen girl, it was my turn to blab. The kid finally got help. But of course, I was admonished by an otherwise apathetic judge for making my child-abusing client look bad.
Too bad I wasn’t her accountant.
Anthony D. Zinnanti is a practicing attorney in the Santa Clarita and San Fernando valleys. He can be reached via e-mail at [email protected] .
