Premises liability claims cost California business millions, if not billions, every years.
When I walk into your business, I see your business in terms of jury instructions, jury verdicts and claims settlements. Personally, I find it amazing what someone who has invested a considerable sum of money in their business will permit to occur on their premises.
Not too long ago I was shopping at one of the “mega” office supply stores. I walked by a shelving unit where an employee had diligently stacked reams of paper.
The paper was stacked high and wobbled over head. Each tightly wrapped package weighed about seven pounds and teetered at least eight feet high. It was an accident waiting to happen.
Because I practice law, I happen to know that a child with a broken neck and permanent injury comes with a $5 million to $20 million price tag. So, I decided to be a Good Samaritan and say something (for the kids’ sake).
The gentle but unequivocal warning was met only by the sheepish grin of the young girl behind the register. The manager was never notified. The problem was never corrected. The paper steadfastly remained in place awaiting to clobber some future unsuspecting shopper and create one heck of a claim.
I was surprised that the warning generated little more than a chuckle. Hadn’t this employee been taught to observe for and report potential disasters?
Whether your operation is small or occupies thousands of square feet, your employees are your first line of defense against injury claims on the premises. You must teach them to be observant and immediately report any possibility of disaster. Develop and implement a regular routine of floor checks.
For example, large supermarkets and retail operations do this with “sweep sheets,” a written record of regular floor checks and cleaning. In the event you get sued, your version of sweep sheets may go a long way in minimizing the claim against you.
A premises liability case is fairly easy to prove. You essentially need to prove that the defendant establishment either created a hazardous condition, or knew of— or should have known of— the hazardous condition existing on the premises.
Upon proof that the hazardous condition caused the injury to the patron, the rest is all about the extent of damage. Here are a few premises liability verdicts and settlements to which I have found noteworthy:
• Clothing rack falls upon patron, $7,500;
• “Jarred arm” (not even a sprain) from falling forward on sandy stairs, $11,000;
• Patron hit in face by employee truck driver (no broken bones or scars), $12,000;
• Broken arm from slipping on plastic hanger, $175,000;
• Broken arm and nose in bar fight, requiring surgery, $525,000.
It’s a gold mine out there.
Depending on your deductible, such claims can be the cause of serious expense. Further, claims arise in a myriad of ways.
The hazardous condition may be even be your employee’s negligence. For example, the speedy pizza delivery drivers can get you very sued. You might try to call them “independent contractors,” but an accident is going to get you and your franchise corporation sued. In such cases your should make the employee’s provision of a Department of Motor Vehicle abstract a requirement of the application process and reprimand anyone who drives dangerously.
Further, the scope of your liability goes well beyond your front door and extends to people who are not even invited on the property. Specifically, injury on any area conceivably under your control and maintenance may render you liable. Parking lots and walkways are the most common examples of areas to which you must extend a duty of care.
The California Supreme Court has long done away with the distinction between those invited, permitted or purely trespassing. The law has evolved, but conceivably even a trespasser— unless engaged in one of 25 enumerated felonies— may bring a suit against you for injury on your premises. The “attractive nuisance” — a circumstance that might attract someone to trespass and thereby be injured— is the biggest form of trespasser-based suits. Get rid of anything kids might climb upon and get injured.
The legalities and legalese go on and on.
The point is, make your employees your first line of defense against injury. They are your eyes and ears and the face that greets your clientele. They are privy to your operation in your absence.
I promise that a little vigilance on this front line will go a long way in avoiding potentially costly claims.
Anthony D. Zinnanti is a practicing attorney and resident of Saugus. His office can be reached at (818) 501-8909 or by e-mail at [email protected] .
