Marital Agreements between spouses are subject to attack from third party creditors.
In 1992, the State Board of Equalization found “James” owed a debt in excess of $37,000. James had operated a restaurant and had unpaid sales taxes. In early 1995 the State Board of Equalization learned that James’ wife, “Doreen,” was a bank employee earning approximately $500,000 per year. In July 1995, the State Board notified Doreen that it would be seeking an Earnings Withholding Order against her to pay James’ debt.
On Nov. 5, 1995, James and Doreen entered into a Marital Agreement transmuting their future earnings to separate property. The state law allows spouses to enter into such agreements both before and after their marriage date.
In July of 1999 the State Board filed an Application for an Earnings Withholding Order, arguing that the November 1995 Marital Agreement did not bar garnishment of the wages because the agreement was fraudulent and unenforceable. Doreen argued that the agreement did not constitute a fraudulent transfer because her future earnings were a mere expectancy, and James had no property interest in her potential future earnings.
The Court of Appeal in the matter of State Board of Equalization v. Doreen (H.Y.) Woo found that Doreen’s argument lacked merit. James had a present interest in Doreen’s future earnings at the time they signed the marital agreement. Earnings of husband and wife acquired during the marriage are community property. Doreen’s attempt to transmute the community property earnings to her separate property constituted a fraudulent transfer.
Transmutation agreements entered into during the marriage are controlled by Family Code Section 851, which provides that the agreements are subject to the fraudulent transfer law. A transfer is fraudulent to a creditor if it is made with actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud any creditor of a debtor. Since the community estate is liable for a debt incurred by either spouse before or during marriage, and the fact that Doreen knew the bank would seek to garnish her wages prior to the transmutation agreement, it was sufficient to find the transfer to be fraudulent.
If James and Doreen had entered into a premarital agreement setting forth that their respective earnings would continue to be sole and separate property, a different result may have been achieved even if James already, at that time of entering into the premarital agreement, had owed the taxes.
Questions about this topic should be directed to an experienced family law attorney.
James P. Reape practices family law in Valencia. He can be reached at 288-1000 or JPRLawcorp.com. “Legal Forum” appears Fridays and rotates among SCV attorneys. Information should not be interpreted as specific legal advice.
