Here we are in the new millennium, the year 2000. Don’t you wish you had a time machine to go back to get some of those once-in-a-millennium investments before they got so pricey?
For example, don’t you wish you could jump into your time machine and buy stock in Qualcomm just after it went public? Don’t you wish you could go back to the day when the first Beanie Babies were released? Don’t you wish you could go back to the day when the first Mickey Mouse Watch went on sale?
And don’t you wish you could return to the year 1944? (You might even remember 1944?) Because back in 1944 a dime from around the turn of the century— 1899 to be exact— would have been worth as much as 25 cents in new or uncirculated condition.
Of course, in 1944, paying 25 cents for a dime might have seemed exorbitant. But today, in 2000, that same 1899 dime in uncirculated condition could be worth $290 or more.
From the driver’s seat of your time machine you might say, “Gee, had I only been there to cash in on inflation!” Well, from the back seat of your time machine, let me be the back-seat driver to say, “Inflation isn’t the power you think it is.”
The ‘Hard Assets and Inflation’ fairy tale
There is a fairy tale in the world of hard assets: that hard assets such as gold, silver, collectible coins, stamps, art, furniture, even Beanie Babies, gain in value with inflation. The belief, spread by financial analysts and asset dealers, is that these assets are “inflation hedges.”
While they might be inflation hedges, that scenario might be more of a coincidence than a fact of life. Want proof? Just look at gold.
Two decades ago, the price of gold peaked at about $875 an ounce. Since then gold has been on a steady decline— an erosion of its financial luster— and now gold is trading in the range of $290 an ounce, or about one-third of its peak price. Yet during that same 20-year period, inflation continued— albeit not at the ferocious pace of the mid-1970s , when mortgage rates were in the range of 22 percent and President Carter referred to an “agony index” which combined inflation rates and unemployment rates into stunning double-digit figures.
Even if inflation were measured at a modest 2 percent a year during the last two decades, gold failed to match that 40 percent increase. In fact, gold lost about 66 percent.
Right there should be the proof: Gold is not an inflation hedge. And neither is art. Art prices peaked in the early 1980s. Stamp collecting is not an inflation hedge, because today stamp dealers will pay you 10 percent under face value for most unused U.S. stamps printed since the early 1940s. The same can be said for rare coins— not a viable inflation hedge because the market is too susceptible to other pressures including style and tastes and basic supply and demand.
A 2, 000-year-old coin
Here’s a basic example of how these non-inflation factors affect old coins.
Around the time of Christ— 2,000 years ago— a small copper coin circulated in the Middle East called the Widow’s Mite— yes, the coin mentioned in the Bible. Today, that 2, 000-year-old coin is priced at about $10 because the supply from archaeological digs in the Middle East is huge and the demand is relatively low.
In fact, every Christmas season, dealers try to move a seemingly endless inventory of these ancient coins. Further, the price of these coins has dropped by about half in the last few years because more “digs” have uncovered more Mites in huge vases and storage bins.
Discovering these hordes of Mites for us would be like people 2,000 years in our future discovering those 5-gallon water bottles that we have filled with pennies.
Recently, the biggest factor affecting the collectibles market has been the strong economy. We have more money to spend, and more confidence to spend it. Our low unemployment rates, our rising incomes, and our rising purchasing power (which has been helped by low inflation) are more factors making collectibles rise in value.
And then there is the stock market. As it soared to record after record, more of us perceived our personal wealth to be growing as our 401(k) plans and pension plans and mutual funds grew in value.
In fact, the growing wealth of Americans probably has done more to boost collectibles than any storm of inflation. Take, for example, the growth of Beanie Babies: Would any of us parents spend $5 or $6 for these small stuffed animals as an inflation hedge? Of course not. But with extra money in our pockets we are happy to buy them for our kids— and as those purchases grew in number, the value of the Beanies also rose.
Our growing wallets
Now consider the growing wealth and prosperity of American coin collectors since World War II. Sure, there have been some recessions, and coin prices did move lower in those recessions.
Perhaps the biggest drop in coin prices came in the recession years of the early 1980s when Americans had to live with oil shock, sticker shock and interest rate shock in one tidal wave. In the early 1980s it was not uncommon for an uncirculated Morgan Silver Dollar from 1881 which was worth $300 to plunge to less than $40.
But if you omit those wild zigs and zags, the growth of the American wallet has certainly helped the growth of collectibles prices. You certainly can see that with coins by comparing the values of coins just after the Second World War and their value today.
Coin prices since 1944
My thanks to coin collector John Muchow, who researched these prices from the 1944 price catalogue compiled by legendary coin dealer B. Max Mehl. Reading Mehl’s 51st edition of The Star Rare Coin Encyclopedia today certainly makes you wish you could hop into your time machine to pick up some coins in Mehl’s shop.
Mehl’s price book lists uncirculated “new condition only” Indian Head Cents as worth five cents each from the years 1878 to 1908. Today, according to the Internet price guide at Coin-Universe.com, an uncirculated 1878 Indian penny is worth at least $182, while more common coins from other years are worth at least $30 and up.
Mehl’s price guide from 1944 listed 3-cent coins (yes, the government really made 3-cent coins) from 1865 to 1876 as worth as much as 15 cents each. Today they are listed on the Internet from $9 for worn, circulated coins, to as much as $1,300 for pristine, uncirculated examples.
And here’s a price swing that certainly beats any kind of inflation average. The 1944 price guide lists an 1895 Morgan Silver Dollar from the Philadelphia Mint in “proof” condition as worth $2. The value today is as much as $65,500.
If home prices had the same kind of inflation as that coin, a house that sold for $2,000 at the end of World War II today would be worth 65 1/2 million dollars. I don’t know of any such house showing that kind of appreciation— do you?
Supply and demand, tastes and styles, and the perception of wealth: They are the true engines of the collectibles market and the hard assets. And that brings us back to that laggard of hard assets: gold.
Gold is still getting swamped by the constant sales of the reserves of nations world-wide , which means that supply is vastly greater than demand. But the economies of Asia are working their way out of recession, and shoppers in Asia are finding they have more yen and rupees to spend, so demand for gold is starting to increase. And while we celebrate our New Year, the Chinese are getting ready for their New Year’s celebration in a few weeks— and gold jewelry is a coveted gift which could also help gold prices to rise.
But inflation is not the magic bullet for gold or other hard assets. Never really was. It was a fairy tale. The reality of demand, and the available money to buy hard assets, is the true driving force of the hard assets market.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98. His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com
