My brother from New Jersey came to visit this week, and told me about his new passion: He’s collecting ceramic and porcelain models of famous sports stadiums.
Pretty neat, he told me. He and some friends frequently travel the country to check out new venues as they follow their favorite teams, including the Jets and the Yankees, of course. He is thrilled with how a new line of collectible porcelain stadiums made by the Danbury Mint captures the detail of the stadiums he’s been in.
The conversation quickly centered on the cost of his new hobby, which is clearly higher than saving programs and ticket stubs. With shipping, he told me, the cost of a stadium replica can reach about $60. But my brother Seth told me he was confident that their value would rise.
That’s when I asked him what they were selling for on eBay, the online auction site. Seth didn’t know. He admitted that he had never seen the site nor checked out auction prices.
After dinner we pointed ourselves like a mouse on a mouse pad to my home office where my computer is set up and logged on to eBay. And that’s when my brother got a shock— his porcelain stadiums were selling in completed eBay auctions for about half the retail prices he had paid. In just a few minutes of scanning the completed auctions, eBay had a new customer.
The world of selling
For the next few minutes, we placed several bids on “stadiums” he wants for his collection, and I bid on a few of the stadiums he already has but I think would look nifty in my home.
I remember going to the old Yankee Stadium with my Dad on the day Roger Maris and Mickey Mantle both hit home runs, breaking the single-season home run total of Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, and I recalled how there were walk-in bomb shelters in the back of the stands
I wondered if the models of the old “House That Ruth Built” would show that kind of detail? My brother said no, but we kept bidding anyway.
As we looked over the auctions, we started paying attention to the different ways sellers present their merchandise for sale.
eBay has some 3.7 million lots for sale, and that makes every seller want to find a way to make his lots stand out. After talking to some experienced sellers and eBay users, here are some methods that sellers use to make their items “sell better” and attract bidders:
• Use pictures. My brother wasn’t sure the “stadiums” on eBay were the same as the ones he was buying at retail prices until he saw the pictures on the eBay auction site. The pictures sold him.
Pictures are also vital for selling art, even for selling coins and stamps— even though coins and stamps can be listed as they would appear in a catalogue. The pictures can reveal the actual condition of the coins and stamps.
I checked an auction of 1964 Kennedy half dollars in proof condition (specially minted coins for collectors showing mirror-like surfaces). Out of eleven proof Kennedy halves from 1964 being offered, four had photos, which gave the bidder some assurances about the condition of the coin.
You could use a digital camera to take an image of your collectible, then download the image to your computer, upload it to your “Web space” of your own Internet Service Provider, and finally link it to your eBay auction listing.
Now, if that sounds like science fiction— something like Spock figuring how to violate the time-space continuum to move through Klingon territory— sorry. Just deal with it. This is 2000, ya know.
But you don’t have to buy a pricey ($200 to $350) digital camera to get your pictures on eBay. You could buy a “scanner” for about $50, then scan actual snapshots (yes, the old fashioned kind) and put those on the Net. Ask your kids. They know how.
Watch out for “picture piracy,” where a seller lifts the photo from another eBay auction, or uses the photo of an item that is not his, to illustrate his lot. That’s cheating, if not fraud.
• Put a limit on shipping costs. Most items sold over eBay involve some shipping cost, and if the seller spells out exactly what the shipping costs are in advance, the bidder can be assured that the costs to complete the purchase won’t be ridiculously high.
Watch out for eBay sellers who start auctions with very low prices but tack on huge shipping and handling costs to boost their profit. If you find sellers who ask for a high shipping fee, you can e-mail them in advance to ask if they would ship using a lower-cost method. Most sellers will comply with your wishes, but they may ask you to accept responsibility if you decline to pay for insurance or certified or registered mail.
Some eBay sellers will start auctions at a low price because they have a very high shipping cost— like $50 or more. These sellers know full well that the real shipping cost might only be a couple of dollars, but they want the high shipping fee to keep eBay from grabbing a high commission.
Let me explain this one. Recently a seller was offering a coin with a starting bid of only $1, but with a $50 shipping charge. The seller knew the coin was worth only about $50, and the cost of shipping the coin was only about $5. But the seller also knows that eBay gets a commission on selling prices— and does not collect anything on shipping costs.
So, by jacking up shipping prices— and taking a lower bid price in the actual auction— the seller actually pockets more money when the sale and the commissions are over and done with.
• Justify the price. If you have a pricey item to sell, explain why you are starting your auction at a high price.
Take for example those 1964 JFK half dollars I was looking at. The starting prices ranged from $1 to $29, with the difference being the condition of the half dollars. The coins in better condition commanded higher starting prices.
If you have an item worth more, explain why. Perhaps it’s something you’ve had appraised, or perhaps a similar item just got a high price in another sale.
• Authenticate the item. If the item can be authenticated, provide that information. Explain that copies of appraisals are available. If the coin, or baseball card, comes with a third party authentication be sure that is spelled out.
• Provide e-mail Q&A. Bidders might have questions you didn’t cover in your auction description, so be attentive to e-mail questions that might be sent to you. Invite bidders to send their e-mail questions to you, and answer them promptly.
Remember, bidders are your customers.
• No reserve prices. Reserve prices are secret prices that must be reached before a seller will let go of an item.
Some other experienced sellers say auctions without “reserve” prices are more appealing to bidders. Some bidders will stay away from reserve lots because they don’t want to “play the game” of reserve prices.
I’ve seen bidding increase dramatically for an item without a reserve price, while a similar item with a reserve sits at an even lower price because potential bidders don’t want to “mess” with a reserve.
• Pick your auction’s ending time carefully. Auctions that end on Sunday evenings, and early in the evening on weekdays, tend to get the best last-minute rush of bids. Auctions that end during the workday or in the middle of the night might pass without that last “spurt” that could make prices move sharply higher.
In the end, though, no one can really say what makes an item sell for a lot of money while another similar item doesn’t.
Let’s go back to those 1964 Kennedy proof half dollars for a moment. A few weeks ago several came up for auction in proof-69 condition (almost flawless). The coins were all third-party certified by the Professional Coin Grading Service. In one auction a coin sold for $45, but in another auction the same type of coin sold for an incredible $101.
In the world of numismatics these were identical coins. Why the big difference in prices? It’s hard to say, except that the $101 dollar coin had two bidders ferociously bidding up to the last second, while the $45 coin didn’t.
In auctions, emotion still can be the biggest driver of prices. Good luck.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98. His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com
