Bob is a smart man. He’s a businessman here in the Santa Clarita Valley who makes savvy deals, sometimes in the millions of dollars. But when it came to his coin collecting hobby he was cheated, defrauded, fooled and didn’t even know he was being robbed until it was too late.
I’m going to tell you Bob’s story hoping that you won’t make the same mistakes.
Bob— not his real name— was a proud collector of Indian Head Cents. Like many collectors he wanted to assemble the best possible collection with the highest-graded coins he could get for his money.
Bob frequented local coin shops in Santa Clarita and in the San Fernando Valley and carefully bought what he thought were quality coins. Indeed, many were. He also attended the major coin shows where quality coins were also available, and he attended coin auctions run by nationally known coin retailers.
He thought the coins sold by one particular nationally known firm would be safe to buy, because the dealer would honestly grade the coins. And he thought their modest prices at auction were a deal— the icing on the cake.
Boy, was he wrong.
In the coin industry, values are determined by several factors including the rarity of the date, and the rarity of the coin in a particular grade or condition.
Coins can vary from a low grade of 1 to a grade of 70 for a perfect example with no flaws— not even a hairline scratch when examined under a high-powered microscope.
Coins that grade 60 and higher are called “uncirculated.” They are highly sought by collectors. The higher the uncirculated grade (60 to 70), the more valuable they are.
For example, an 1881 Morgan silver dollar from the San Francisco Mint in very worn condition (an 8 on the grading scale) might be worth only $8. But a coin in uncirculated condition, graded 60, might be worth $20, and the same coin with a grade of 63 might be worth $30.
A silver dollar of that year and mint, grading uncirculated-65 , is relatively rare and might be worth $65. But with a grade of 67, the coin would be worth $800 or more.
In the coin business, a slight difference in the grade can mean a big difference in the price.
Among copper coins such as Indian Head cents, there is another factor: the color of the coins.
Brown coins— those that have darkened with age and use— are worth considerably less than coins that are red and brown and still have a bit of their original “ just-made ” color. Coins that are all red, like coins newly minted, are worth exceptionally more, especially when they are cents more than 100 years old.
My friend Bob wanted those “red” coins in high grades for his collection, so he bid on them at several of those auctions.
A couple of weeks ago, Bob got the shock of his collecting life. A few days later, he got the second big shock. A few days after that, he was pretty much numb when he received what should have been the third shock.
It seems those Indian Cents he though were high-grade and red in color were not. They had in fact been altered in an attempt to deceive the buyers.
Bob got the bad news from several of the independent third-party grading services that evaluate coins for collectors. Bob made three separate shipments to different coin grading services to evaluate 20 of the coins he had bought at auction, and the results were bad. Really bad.
Of the 20 coins he sent in, 12 graded lower what the auction company claimed they were. That’s 60 percent that came back as below grade. Seven, or 35 percent, of the coins came back as the auction company described. Only one coin came back as better than described.
It was not what a collector wanted to hear— not a collector who put his faith in the appraisal of the expert coin dealer and auctioneer.
The situation grew even worse when Bob realized how far off the coins were from the advertised grades.
An 1880 cent that he bought for $170 because it was advertised as a “gem uncirculated red” coin with a grade of 65 came back from one of the grading services as an “almost uncirculated” coin with a grade of 50. It that was probably worth no more than $41.
A 1909 Indian cent that was auctioned as a “proof” (a special collector coin with a mirrored finish) in a grade of 63 came back as a 50 because it showed signs of wear. What Bob paid $180 for was probably worth no more than $18, and what’s more, someone had deliberately used a tool to carve lines and features into the coin to make it appear it was in better condition. The coin was also “ re-colored ,” meaning someone had used a chemical process to change its brown hue to red. Experts can identify “tooling” and “recoloring.”
An 1859 Indian cent that was supposed to be in uncirculated-62 condition came back as a circulated coin with a grade of 30. Bob paid $90; it was worth probably no more than $30. This coin, according to the grading service, showed evidence of being “whizzed” — a process that involves polishing the coin to remove signs of wear and scratches. The polishing leaves tell-tale microscopic marks that experts can detect.
Clearly Bob had been had.
Bob contacts the dealer
After receiving three shipments from the independent grading services, Bob contacted the dealer to demand an explanation and a refund. He maintained he had been fooled, tricked, scammed, defrauded. The dealer denied the charges and then attacked the grading services, claiming that they could easily be wrong in their assessments.
In fact, the dealer’s argument would hold up very well in court, if not in the court of public opinion.
You see, there are no official grading standards for the coin industry. One dealer can claim he has his own unique grading system that is no less valid or accurate than someone else’s grading system.
The only time there might be a legal challenge is when a dealer claims to follow one of the publicized grading systems but does not. For example, the American Numismatic Association has published a grading system, and if a dealer claims to follow those standards, he had better do it.
Unfortunately for Bob, the dealer in question made no such claims. In fact, the dealer warned in the auction catalogue that his grading standards might not meet those of the independent grading services.
Normally that would be “case closed” and the buyer would be out of luck. But Bob had something else on his side: his wallet. The dealer recognized that Bob was a valued customer who spent thousands of dollars a year at his auctions, and he didn’t want to risk losing his business. So as a compromise, the dealer agreed to issue credit for the coins as long as Bob promised to bid only on coins that had been third-party graded so there would be no future disputes. Both sides shook hands on the deal.
You might not have the wallet and the bidding history Bob had— so you might not have the luck Bob had in settling his dispute.
So remember the lesson: Grades count, and not everyone grades coins the same way. Some will cheat to create a coin that looks like it deserves a higher grade. It’s a treacherous hobby.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98. His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com
