ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Personal Finance

Collectors might make a mint in coins’ bull market

Did you feel the earth move Sunday night, Jan. 20? It wasn’t an earthquake, but it really did shake up the world of coin collectors.

It was the sale of a Susan B. Anthony dollar coin that shook the world. It shook up a lot of people because of its price. Fifty-seven hundred dollars. That’s $5,700 for a Susie, as they’re called.

Yes, a Susie for fifty-seven hundred bucks. The same kind of Susie that you didn’t want in your pocket, the same kind of Susie that you frowned upon when it came out of a postal service vending machine, the same kind of Susie that you couldn’t find a vending machine to take. That kind of Susie.

This particular SBA dollar was made recently— in 1999. That’s one heck of a return on a two- or three-year investment.

How many $5,700 Susies have you let slip through your fingers?

Before you pull your hair out in amazement and frustration, let me allay your fears: Chances are you never had a $5,700 Susan B. Anthony dollar.

You see, what made this Susie so valuable was its condition. It was pristine with barely a mark or a flaw or a scratch or a nick. And it was certified as being near flawless by the independent coin grading service Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) of Newport Beach.

You see, most new SBA dollars when they come from a bank probably grade as uncirculated— but the $5,700 SBA was a super “gem uncirculated” coin and was graded a 68 out of a possible high score of 70. (Seventy is perfect.) The kind of SBA coins that come out of the bank (if never used in commerce) probably only grade a 64 or a 65 out of a possible score of 70.

In the world of numismatics (coin collecting), a one-point difference can mean big money.

Take, for example, a new New Jersey Statehood quarter issued in 1999. Coins in common, new or uncirculated condition are worth about $2 each. But if you happen to have one in gem condition— and it has been certified as being in gem condition— it can be worth several hundred dollars.

In the world of coin collecting, this is known as “buying the plastic holder” — because these “graded” or “certified” coins are sealed in plastic holders with a label attesting to their grade by the various independent grading companies.

There is the PCGS and others including Numismatic Grading Corp. (NGC) and Independent Grading Corp. (IGC) and Sovereign Entity Grading Service (SEGS) and still another called Accugrade. Each grading company builds its reputation for “getting the grade right.” However, before you buy a coin that has been “slabbed” (sealed in a plastic holder by a grading company) you should know that the numismatic community treats the various grading companies differently.

PCGS is perhaps known as the industry leader and with the grades that best describe the coins in its holders. NGC is also highly regarded. The other grading services also have their devoted followers, but PCGS-graded coins tend to have the best market following and the best prices.

One of the worst experiences for any collector or investor is to buy a graded coin and then be told that the grading service inflated the grade or “overgraded it” and the coin isn’t as good as the label on the holder says it is.

Outside of the plastic holder, one coin might look like another, and some collectors shun so-called “coins in plastic” for this reason. But some collectors covet the plastic holders and the coins they contain for independent third-party certification of the condition of the coin they own.

That $5,700 SBA dollar, by they way, is so valuable for two reasons: First, it was certified as scoring a 68 out of 70 by PCGS; and second, it is the only 1999 SBA ever certified in such a lofty grade.

Some coin collectors are now bidding big bucks in public and online auctions for these “condition rarity” coins, or coins with high grades that have low populations.

In the past week, a 1936 half-dollar sold for more than $27,000 at an auction only because the buyer thought that it was worth a grade of 67 out of 70. The buyer was correct in his assumption: He submitted the coin to PCGS and it received the lofty, and rare grade. But had his new purchase been graded only a 66, he would have had a coin that was valued in the marketplace at only about $4,000 and he would have lost the coin-grading lottery.

There is a lesson in all this: First, do not try to buy or invest in “condition rarity” coins or coins with valuable “grades” unless you have confirmation that the coin you are buying is indeed rare and in pristine condition. The best way to have this determined is to buy a coin that has been graded by a third-party organization such as PCGS.

Second, beware anyone trying to sell you a “condition rarity” coin that has not been graded by a third-party — because unless you are an expert yourself, you might not be able to determine the true condition or rarity of the coin.

Third, shop around. Even if a coin has a high grade and is rare, prices and values will still vary in the marketplace, and the variations can be significant.

Here’s one more example about “grade” and value: A 1964 silver Washington quarter that you might have in your top drawer (kept as a piece of silver) might be worth only 75 cents because of its silver content. But a 1964 quarter that is certified in proof-70 condition— meaning it was specially struck for collectors and is flawless with no scratches or dings— might be worth $300 or more.

And here’s something else to keep in mind: No 1964 quarter in anyone’s top drawer can be worth $300— not unless it is encased in plastic with a certification label from PCGS.

A new bull market?

Coin dealer and expert David Hall of David Hall Rare Coins in Newport Beach is out with a new and interesting newsletter for his clients. In this newsletter he tracks the history of bull markets for coins.

Yes, coins have bull markets just like the stock market has bull markets. Coins and stocks also have bear markets.

Hall reports that the previous big bull markets for coins were 1961-64 , 1971-74 , 1976-80 , and 1983-89 . The last bull market was fueled primarily by the interest of big Wall Street investment firms in “rare coin portfolios.” When Wall Street went away, a long bear market developed for coins. That bear market is now ending and some coin dealers are predicting a new bull market for coins.

The recent sell-off in stocks might also fuel the new bull market as investors seek hard assets for the money they rescued from stocks.

Hall reports that a major factor in the new, stronger coin market is the Statehood quarter series now being produced by the U.S. Mint. The new quarters have brought millions of new collectors into the hobby and have generated intense interest in certain coin series including Washington quarters and Lincoln cents. Prices for these coins have risen as well.

Hall also reports that there is a coin collecting “obsession” now with the PCGS Set Registry. This is a competition among collectors the world over to build the finest-known sets of coins. “The coin collecting renaissance is very real,” Hall writes.

Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.

Image not recoveredmugmendelson_alan.jpg

← Back to 2002

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/business/mendelson/0102/012602a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,284 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 1.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_business
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: Valencia]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Alan Mendelson]
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [2 hits]
Scores
local 6, national 1