Have you got your stash of gold and silver ready for the Y2K economic meltdown? I don't believe for one second that the world economy will crash at 12 a.m. on January 1, 2000, but there are plenty of people who fear a worldwide calamity because of the Y2K computer problem.
Y2K gloom-and-doomers see the world coming apart when too many computers won't be able to recognize the difference between the years 1900 and 2000, causing everything from ATMs to checking accounts to elevators to the nation's air traffic control system to grind to a halt.
To deal with the crisis, these Y2K gloom-and-doomers say you must stash a supply of gold and silver to barter for groceries, gasoline, medicine and other necessities of life. Like I said, I don't believe for one second any of that will happen or that you should have a stash just in case.
But if you do want to have a stash, what's the best barter material to have? Gold has universal value and appeal, but the problem with gold is that it is pricey now — and if there is economic chaos it could be much too pricey to barter with.
Today, a one-ounce gold American Eagle bullion coin fetches about $300. But in a worldwide crisis, couldn't we expect gold prices to soar, perhaps back to the record high of $850 an ounce — a price not seen in about two decades? If that were to happen, trying to barter a one-ounce Eagle for a tank of gas or a shopping cart of groceries might be difficult if not impossible. How would one make change?
There are smaller bullion pieces, such as the one-tenth-ounce American Eagles. But a few days ago, when gold was selling at about $286 an ounce and the one-ounce Eagles were selling for $302.30 each, the one-tenth-ounce Eagles were priced at $33.55 — the equivalent of $335.50 per ounce of gold.
That's a premium of about $50 over the value of gold. And while one-tenth-ounce gold bullion pieces might make more sense in a barter economy, another medium of exchange such as silver might be better and more economical.
Choices of silver for barter
Like gold, silver comes in four basic forms for barter. There are the minted government legal tender coins; government bullion pieces, also known as Eagles; private-issue silver bullion; and silver jewelry. Let me spell out the advantages and disadvantages of each.
With silver jewelry, there is an immediate problem of acceptance. How much does the jewelry weigh, and is it really sterling, or just marked sterling? In some cases, the workmanship is worth more than the metal content.
With private-issue silver bullion, acceptance can also be a problem. Was it assayed and coined correctly? Is there truly an ounce of silver in a one-ounce round or wafer? The advantage of private silver is that the premium, or markup, can be less than one would pay for government-issued silver.
Government bullion coins can be universally accepted, and traders know there are few reports of counterfeit bullion pieces. Traders have the advantage of knowing the coins are correctly assayed and fabricated, but the premium on these pieces can be significant — a dollar or more per ounce over the premium of private-issue silver bullion pieces.
Minted silver coins, which are legal tender, offer the most advantages for barter. These coins, basically pre-1965 dimes, quarters and half dollars, are 90 percent silver and readily accepted as authentic.
Advantages of legal tender
For barter, trade in your so-called "junk silver" — coins that are not rare and do not have numismatic value. When silver was priced at $4.89 an ounce recently, a bag of junk silver with $1,000 face value was priced at $4,550, or about $4.55 for each dollar of face value.
An advantage of owning junk silver is that it will always be worth face value even if the silver market drops to zero. Junk silver coins are also small enough that they can easily be used in a barter economy, and "change" can easily be made for purchases.
Another type of silver legal tender is the 40 percent silver half dollars minted by the U.S. government from 1965 to 1970. In a barter economy during a crisis, some traders might not recognize these as silver, so they could pose a problem.
There is yet another type of silver legal tender: United States silver dollars minted before 1936. The Peace dollar, minted from 1921 to 1935, in worn condition can fetch about $9.50 at current silver price levels. The Morgan dollar, minted from 1878 to 1921, currently sells for about $10.50 in worn, circulated condition. Shop around, because prices on these silver dollars vary.
The problem with trading these silver coins is that they also may have numismatic value, and you could be trading away a lot of value if you don't know what your particular coins are worth. However, if the Y2K crisis does not develop, these silver dollars give you some security that silver bullion does not offer: Their price will be supported by numismatic value, and they'll always be worth at least a dollar.
One more note about investing in precious metals: Even conservative financial planners say it's OK to invest five percent of your money in gold and silver, as an insurance policy. You buy car insurance even though you hope you never have a car accident; perhaps you want to buy gold or silver as insurance, even though you hope you'll never have to barter with it.
* * *
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
