Now that the Postal Service has raised the cost of a first class letter to 33 cents, does that make 32-cent stamps valuable? Should you collect them?
Stamp dealers tell me your best choice for the 32-cent stamps is to use them — and use them before they lose value on the resale market.
Lose value. Is that possible? It sure is.
Go to any stamp dealer, or better yet, visit any stamp show and you'll find dealers selling old postage stamps — even stamps from the 1930s and 1940s — at face value. You might even find a dealer selling stamps at less than face value. Why? Because, for the most part, there are so many old stamps in the hands of collectors that they have not appreciated in value.
Lee Green, owner of World Wide Stamp and Coin Company in North Hollywood, routinely puts old postage stamps from the 1930s, '40s and '50s on his letters.
"It improves business and interest in stamp collecting," he told me. But he isn't throwing away money. Most of the old stamps are worth only face value, he said. "They're postage and not rare collectibles."
Green said collectors and people who have inherited stamp collections are often disappointed when he makes a seemingly low offer.
"I pay 30 percent under face (value)," he said. "And I can sell (the stamp) to another dealer for ten percent under face."
The problem is that many stamps, even unused or "mint" stamps, were printed in large numbers and then saved in large numbers, so there is no price hike caused by rarity. With rare or unusual stamps, prices are often cut by their poor condition. Old stamps that are off-center or lack good perforations or vibrant colors are of less value to a collector.
Yes, there are old stamps that are worth more than face value, and you would be foolish to put those stamps on a letter. But they are few in the universe of stamps. So it pays to research the hobby and check the value of old stamps before you lick 'em and stick 'em.
Green showed me 1-cent stamps from the 1930s that he uses today for postage, but he also showed me a 1-cent stamp from 1904 that is worth $15 today, and a stamp honoring the Columbian Exposition from 1892 that is worth nearly $1,200 to collectors.
Odd combinations for 33 cents
Here are some of the odd combinations of old stamps that Green is using to mail first-class letters at the new 33-cent rate.
He is putting three of the 10-cent Monticello stamps from the 1960s together with a 3-cent Whistler's Mother stamp from the 1930s. He is also using five of the 6-cent Eisenhower stamps from the 1960s, along with a 3-cent stamp from the 1930s. In another odd combination, he is using 13-centers from the 1970s, 5-centers from the 1940s and 2-centers from the 1930s.
When I was a youngster collecting stamps, I paid a premium for the 8-cent Champion of Liberty stamp from the late 1960s. Well, you guessed it: Now it's postage on Green's letters. He is using four of those plus a 1-cent Washington from the 1930s.
Stamp collector Don Regis told me he regularly uses old postage. "I have lots of stamps from the '30s and '40s that you can buy at stamp shows for face value," he said.
Regis told me he mailed this past season's Christmas cards with commemorative Christmas stamps from the last decade — all worth no more than face value, he said.
Trouble with plate blocks
Back in the 1960s, when stamp collecting was perhaps the number-one hobby in the world, many collectors bought and saved "plate blocks" — usually four stamps with a code number in the margin.
There were special albums for collecting plate blocks. Collecting them was popular in the 1950s and '60s, but when the price of a first-class stamp moved higher than a dime, interest in plate blocks slipped. In the 1990s, with a plate block costing more than a dollar, plate block collecting has fallen hard — and now it can't get up.
What about those old 1, 2, 3 and 5-cent commemoratives honoring FDR in the late 1940s?
"They're postage," Green told me. Use them on your mail.
In fact, in Green's box of old postage is a plate block of the 4-cent stamp honoring the nation's space program. It's destined to go out on a letter as regular postage now.
There are a few exceptions — for example, a $5 Hamilton stamp issued in the 1960s. Not many stamps were printed in that denomination, and few collectors could afford to save them, so today the plate blocks can be worth $450 or more.
But unfortunately, collectors would have been better off putting their $20 into an investment returning 10 percent a year — such as stocks — than into a Hamilton plate block. Had you put your money into a mutual fund returning an average of 10 percent a year back in 1965, that $20 would have grown to about $511.
What's even more amazing is if you had put $20 into 4- and 5-cent commemorative stamps around 1965. Today, Lee Green would pay you $14 for that $20 in stamps. In a bank account paying only 4 percent interest, your $20 would have grown to about $78 today.
The lesson here is that stamp collecting should be thought of as a hobby, not necessarily as an investment that will pay dividends in cash or profits. The dividends of stamp collecting include knowledge, pleasure and a sense of accomplishment as you fill the pages of an album.
If you happen to turn a profit when you sell, you're that much ahead of the game.
* * *
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
