Now that the stock market is running into profit taking, and some of the averages have suffered a short-term correction of 7 to 10 percent, the hottest place to score a profit these days is not your broker’s office but your local coin collecting shop. Because at coin dealers, you could have put your money into short-term investments that could have returned big profits.
You could even make 10 times your money with pocket change.
The oddest thing is, you didn’t have to buy anything rare, like a 1943 cent that was made out of copper instead of steel, or one of the few 1913 nickels known to exist, or even a rare “ultra cameo” high-grade Franklin half dollar from 1958. All you had to buy were some of those new 5-State quarters that the mint started making about a year ago.
Some of those early quarters are selling for as much as $2 each at coin shops and at coin shows and over the Internet.
Crazy? Maybe, because they were all available at face value— and even below face value— as they were issued by the mint. Unfortunately for new collectors now, they were “new issues” for only about 10 weeks before the mint moved on to produce the next state design.
Last year’s first issue was the Delaware quarter. It is selling today for $1.50 to $2 each at local coin shops in the Santa Clarita and San Fernando valleys. The second coin, for Pennsylvania, also is selling in that price range. The third quarter was New Jersey, and it’s selling for about $1, while the Georgia and Connecticut coins are selling for about 50 cents each in uncirculated condition. The lower price reflects the mint’s larger production of these coins.
Clearly, as each new coin is released, more people decide to collect them and want to buy the other coins they did not grab earlier. Those new collectors are pushing the prices up for the early quarters.
The Delaware quarter also got a lift in its price early-on because of reported errors in the minting process. Those errors had speculators buying up bags of coins ($25 to $1,000 per bag), hoping to find some of the major errors that were worth several hundred dollars per coin.
Major errors are considered to be coins that were struck (stamped) twice or struck off-center by about half-way .
The U.S. Mint now estimates that 120 million Americans are saving some of the new quarters, and several companies are publishing albums for collectors. It’s quarter mania— not to be confused with the quarter-mania slot machines in Las Vegas. Yet, this quarter mania can also yield big profits.
Take for example that first Delaware quarter now selling for $1.50 to $2. At $2, you’re getting eight times your original money. But if you were lucky enough to stop by Valley View Coins at 15626 Ventura Boulevard in Encino about a year ago, you could have bought one for just 19 cents. That would be a gain of more than 10 times on your money. Valley View dealer Tom Lenk has been selling the new quarters as they are released for 19 cents each as a promotion to stir interest in the coins and the albums he has for them.
You would have been even luckier buying that first coin for just 15 cents at Coins Plus at 23332 Lyons Avenue in Newhall, where dealer Jeff Butler had a similar promotion— one new quarter for each new customer at 15 cents. Both Coins Plus and Valley View now have the promotions in place for the Massachusetts coin now being released.
On the eBay Internet auction site, $10 rolls of the new Massachusetts quarters are selling for about $15 to $16 each, a gain of 50 to 60 percent.
Of course, there is no guarantee that these prices and values will continue to rise. In fact, there is a good chance that some speculators who are sitting with several $1,000 bags of these coins will want to sell them, and that prices will collapse as a result. But in the meantime, prices continue to spiral higher.
Some collectors are speculating that when the Texas, New York and California quarters are released in the coming years, prices will really go through the roof. These collectors speculate that the large populations of Texas, New York and California will mean many more new collectors.
Collectors also note that there has been a lot of cross-over collecting, with collectors from other hobbies adding the quarters to their collections. The reason for the cross-over interest is the designs that the quarters have. Each is unique.
Designs spark different interests
The new Massachusetts coin shows a statue of a Minute Man over an outline of the state. This will appeal to collectors of military memorabilia.
The next coin to be issued will be for Maryland. It will show a view of the State House dome with oak leaf clusters. This could appeal to collectors of architecture, and gardeners.
The third coin to be issued this year will be for South Carolina. This one could have broad appeal because of its various images, including a Wren for bird watchers, a Palmetto tree for gardeners, and a Yellow Jasmine Flower.
The fourth coin to be issued this year will be for New Hampshire. It will show a rock formation called the Old Man of the Mountain, which might appeal to mountain climbers, hikers, and people who like... uh... rocks.
Virginia’s quarter could be highly sought after because it will show three tall sailing ships— a very popular theme among collectors.
* * *
What about California’s design?
It’s almost time for California to start thinking about its design. Other states have opened their design selection to the public, and some states have held contests to pick the best design.
Perhaps California would like to follow some of the trends that other states have developed and go one step better (take these with a sense of humor, please):
Instead of a Minute Man statue, like Massachusetts has, we could have a barrister at Starbucks. Like Maryland, we could show our State Capitol building, but we could show it surrounded by a wreath of medicinal-use marijuana. Like South Carolina, we could have multiple examples of flora and fauna including a condor, a palm tree and a Bird of Paradise. And we here in California have a better rock formation than New Hampshire— we have the Malibu cliffs. We could add a house teetering on the edge. While Virginia might show three tall ships, we could portray three luxury sports cars or limos on our quarter.
California’s quarter will be released in 2005. That gives us plenty of time to pick the best design. Of course, only one design can win, so how about a Ford Bronco on the 405 Freeway with police cruisers in pursuit?
Or, a coin with the San Andreas Fault down the middle, and with pressure on the deep cut in the coin, the coin can be split in two, creating the first 12 1/ 2-cent piece. This will help taxpayers deal with those pesky sales taxes nationwide. It could be our public service, and once again, California ingenuity would spread nationwide.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98. His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com
