Some air travelers tell me they have questioned their airlines about what type of plane they have reservations on. In the case of MD-80 flights, some of these passengers told me that when they asked for a refund or a change of flight (without penalty), the airlines have complied.
But a representative of American Airlines— the largest operator of MD-80 planes— said the refunds or changes without penalty are made on a case-by-case basis.
* * *
What about the MD-80 inspections?
The Federal Aviation Administration says it has collected some reports from airlines about its order to inspect MD-80-class planes for possible corrosion that could lead to problems or failure of the rear stabilizers. This is a suspected cause of the Alaska Airlines crash. But keep in mind that no definitive report on the crash has yet been issued.
The preliminary findings, according to my sources at the FAA, are that only very few of the MD-80 planes have been inspected as yet, and of those, only a small percentage have had problems with their stabilizers.
The airlines have until November to complete their inspections. Alaska Airlines has revealed that the plane that crashed was not inspected.
The preliminary report was due late Wednesday, then early Thursday, then late Thursday— but on Friday afternoon (Washington time) my source at the FAA said the report would not be revealed until this next week at the earliest.
What’s the problem?
I’m told that there are technicians and engineers inside the FAA who are questioning the numbers that have been collected. I asked what that means and was not given a meaningful answer. But the reason for the delay in making the report public is that so few planes may have been inspected.
Remember that the FAA gave the airlines 18 months to make this inspection, and the 18-month period doesn’t expire until this coming November.
In the meantime, the FAA says there is absolutely no discussion or reason to ground this class of planes, and such a decision “would not be reached lightly.”
Another source at the FAA said that if the inspections made so far reveal that at least 10 to 15 percent of the planes have the defect in the stabilizers, then the inspection timetable would be stepped up.
The bottom line: There is no evidence now to warrant, or even to consider, grounding these planes. Meanwhile, airlines still have until November to meet the compliance rules of inspecting these planes for any problems. The 18-month window for the inspections, according to the FAA, indicates there is “no emergency.”
Now, some background information:
Just a couple of hours after the reported crash of the Alaska Airlines jet near Los Angeles, I was tipped off by a source at Boeing to check the FAA’s Web site for data about an “airworthiness directive” concerning the class of planes that included the Alaska plane that crashed.
That AD, as it is called, reported last Spring— in May, to be exact— that there is a problem with the stabilizer with this class of plane, and this is a problem which can lead to “reduced structural integrity of the airplane.”
Specifically, there are reports of corrosion of the “vertical to horizontal stabilizer.”
You’ll note that according to reports, the pilots of the doomed jetliner reported a problem with the stabilizer and requested an emergency landing at Los Angeles International.
Last May, the FAA ordered that within 18 months, the airlines operating this class of plane should inspect for this corrosion problem. Tuesday night we found out the inspection was not made on this plane. But even though the inspection was not made, the airline was still operating within the limits of the AD. An Alaska Airlines spokesman was quoted saying the inspection would have been made this coming June, about 13 months from the time of the FAA order.
The FAA notes in its AD that the inspection would involve 117 hours of work and would cost about $7,000 per aircraft.
We do not know if the corrosion problem was the cause or contributed to the crash, and that will probably be part of the investigation. Not only will the flight recorders have to be recovered from the Pacific, but parts of the plane will also have to be recovered for examination— and this might be impossible.
In fact, a Boeing spokesperson told me that linking the crash to the AD problem would be very speculative at this time.
What you should know is that in all there are 706 of this class of MD-80 planes that are operated by U.S. airlines, and 1,059 planes worldwide, that must be inspected to meet the FAA directive.
* * *
What some experts say now
Several experts in different areas of the aviation industry gave me their guidance about what to expect. Aviation attorney Paul Hedlund of Baum, Hedlund, Aristei, Guilford and Downey in Los Angeles told me that the inspection is not only “a must do,” but that airlines will be quick to reveal their positive results to boost consumer confidence in the wake of the crash.
Hedlund also had a copy of the actual operating records of the plane that crashed and it showed a plane with minor— even inconsequential— maintenance problems. Problems included such minor events as light bulbs that blew out in the passenger cabin.
Aviation expert Barry Schiff told me the MD-80 class of planes “has an outstanding safety record. It has fewer fatal accidents per thousand hours of flying time than almost any other airline.”
* * *
What to look for now
In the next few days, look for the airlines to boost consumer confidence with reports about their planes and mandated inspections. Also look for special airfare deals as an incentive to win back customers who might have been shaken by the Alaska Airlines disaster.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98. His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com
