If you were a collector and had unlimited cash resources and could create a time machine, what would you bring back from the past?
Would you return to the days of the first Barbie dolls and bring back the original Barbies still in their factory-sealed boxes? Or, would you return to the days when the first Mickey Mouse watches were put on sale?
If you were a stamp collector, perhaps you’d return to the days when the Graf Zeppelin stamps were issued and you’d buy a sheet? If you were a coin collector, you’d think about going back to the year 1857 and you’d grab some of the freshly minted $20 gold coins from the San Francisco mint.
Indeed, those 1857 double eagles, as they were called, would have been quite a deal back then in pristine, gem uncirculated condition. Because as recently as three years ago, they were worth about $85,000 each, and during the peak of gold coin collecting in 1990 they were priced at $150,000 and up.
They were worth so much because there were so few in gem condition. In fact, in 1997 only four “gem uncirculated” $20 gold pieces from 1850 to 1866 had been certified by the Professional Coin Grading Service of Newport Beach. Only four.
That low population and high value would certainly make a gold coin from that era a target for your time-machine crew.
Well, here’s a wake-up call.
There was a time machine and it brought back not one, not 10, but maybe several hundred of these rare, pricey coins.
Brace yourself, because the crew of that time machine may have even recovered 5,000 of those coins. Science fiction? No, fact.
The time machine is not the product of Jules Verne, Rod Serling, or any of the other great sci-fi writers we have come to know. It is the adventure of Thomas “Tommy” Thompson, who found and recovered the wreck of the S.S. Central America, which sank off the coast of North Carolina in 1857, along with its shipment of gold coins and gold bars from California. The gold was found in 1987 and is now coming to market.
Today and tomorrow you can see a sample of this gold at the Coin and Collectibles Expo at the Long Beach Convention Center. Some of the gold coins will be offered for sale.
“It is the greatest numismatic find of our lifetime,” Van Simmons of the Professional Coin Grading Service told me. “It is the horde of a lifetime, and a horde for the history books.”
Indeed. The gold was being rushed from the mint in San Francisco to help ease a financial panic in 1857 that had gripped banks in the northeast. But when the shipment sank, taking more than 400 souls with it, the panic swelled and banks fell like dominoes.
Because of the hard times of the era, few $20 gold pieces were kept by collectors, which is why, up until now, so few coins in pristine condition survived.
Now, things are so different— and the coin collecting market has certainly taken note and taken an ax to prices.
The value of an 1857 $20 gold piece from San Francisco in gem uncirculated, or mint state-65 , condition (on a scale of 70) has fallen from $85,000 three years ago to $14,950 now.
An 1857-S in a slightly lower grade, mint state-64 , is now priced at $9,450. This is a coin that three years ago sold for as much as $50,000.
What surprises many collectors is that so many of the salvaged coins are in pristine condition.
The coin dealer Bowers and Merena Galleries of Wolfeboro, New Hampshire, is telling its clients that the frigid, deep water where the ship came to rest is responsible for their preservation.
“It is said that the water at the 8, 000-foot level is about 37 degrees Fahrenheit,” the firm wrote in a special publication this week. “This coldness, plus the great pressure, combined to preserve the gold coins in far-above average condition, free of the ‘sea water etching’ so often seen on salvaged pieces.”
Thompson, our leader of the time-traveling rescue expedition, also brought back more than rare and valuable coins, said Simmons of PCGS. He brought back artifacts that attest to the struggle of America’s industrial revolution, and the important part that California played in providing the gold that financed part of that revolution.
Too bad, however, that this particular shipment was lost and so many lives were lost with it.
Of course, if there were someone today with a real “time machine,” you’d hope that their first mission would have been not to discover the gold on the ocean floor, but to have warned the ship that it was sailing into the eye of a hurricane.
By the way, the Coin and Collectibles Expo is open to the public. There is a $4 admission fee. And if you have some of your own cherished and old coins, bring them to the Expo, where free appraisals are available from many of the hundreds of dealers. And for non-coin collectors there are also displays, exhibits and sales of stamps, cigar boxes, gambling chips and other keepsakes.
The impact of cybertage
This past week, the world of the Internet was struck by hackers who sabotaged many prominent Web sites including those run by E*Trade Group (the online stock trading company) and eBay’s online auction site.
I call the online sabotage “cybertage.”
By some estimates, e-commerce suffered losses approaching $1 billion. It wasn’t just big companies that lost; it was also individual collectors who suffered as the items they had up for sale in online auctions sold for less than what one would consider a fair price.
The cybertage this past week crowded Internet sites with “phantom customers,” preventing legitimate customers from actually bidding.
The losses were substantial for customers of Causey Coins of Ft. Worth, Tex., which placed on eBay many coins on consignment from its customers who wanted to sell them.
“We had several thousand dollars in rare coins on eBay closing Tuesday early evening,” a company spokesperson told me. “We start everything at no minimum, and usually the price goes way up the last hour before the auction closes. Due to the hackers disrupting eBay, many expensive coins sold for a fraction of their wholesale value.”
The company continues to say that its “consignors are mad as us because their coins brought so little. Bidders who wanted to pay much more for the coins but did not get a chance are mad at us.”
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98. His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com
