The Professional Numismatists Guild, a trade group of coin dealers, is warning coin collectors that Uncle Sam could soon start to confiscate— or legally steal— your rare coins from your collection.
PNG issued this warning as part of a campaign to force the federal government to return a $20 gold coin that was confiscated from a collector. The coin in question, a 1933 Double Eagle, was never legally issued to the public. The government seized the coin in 1996 because it was “assumed by the government to have been stolen,” according to PNG.
The government is now being sued in court for the return of the coin, and PNG is warning in a legal brief “that if the court upholds the seizure, it would put in jeopardy private ownership” of many of the rare and unique coins in collections today.
Many of the coins in jeopardy include the various examples of the famed 1804 silver dollar. In reality, it has now been learned that the 1804 dollar was minted in 1834 as presentation pieces for foreign and government officials, and was never intended to be released to the public.
Also in jeopardy are the famous 1943 copper cents. You’ll recall that cents in 1943 were made out of steel, but a few were accidentally— or intentionally— minted by employees. These coins were never intended for circulation.
There are also thousands of “pattern” coins that have found their way into collector hands— coins that were made as examples for mint officials or treasury examples to examine.
Recently, there has been discussion about the possible existence of some modern pattern coins that might have escaped from the mint and found their way into private hands. Among the modern patterns might be a 1964 Peace silver dollar (supposedly all were melted), and cents made out of aluminum in the early 1980s, and the new Sacagawea dollar made out of test metals.
PNG maintains that “throughout its history, the U.S. has manufactured literally thousands of special or unusual coins which from a numismatic standpoint are rarities and, in some cases, one-of-a-kind items.”
For example, one of the 20 or so 1943 copper cents, according to my sources, was minted by a mint employee, then secreted out of the mint and held in a safe deposit box until the employee’s death. It was discovered a few years ago by the mint employee’s heirs, and was since sold. So far, no one from the government has tried to seize the coin, but that coin could be affected by the outcome of this lawsuit.
I’ll keep you posted.
In the meantime, if you have a coin that shouldn’t be— don’t invite your Uncle Sam over to see it. Uncle might have sticky fingers.
A new eBay bidding scam?
Some funny things are happening with the bidding on auctions on eBay, the online auction site.
It seems that some collectibles are getting many bids— perhaps too many bids— and the bids are going up to ridiculously high prices.
But this is not a case of a seller who is using shills to increase the bids for the items he is selling. No, this is a case of bidders creating their own shills to scare away legitimate competing bidders.
The scam works this way:
One legitimate bidder finds an item he wants to bid and buy, and he places a legitimate single bid on the item. Then, using other bidding identities, he enters many more bids that not only outbid his one legitimate bid but also outbids all other bidders including the bids of the phony bidders he has created.
In one instance, the legitimate bid for an item might stop at $10, but the phony bids could reach $50 or $70. Those super-high phony bids have the effect of scaring way other legitimate bidders— but in the last seconds of the auction, the phony bids are all retracted, leaving the low legitimate bid to win the item.
One Internet newsgroup member identified as John told other Internet newsgroup members how he recognized one such scam:
“Just the other day, I was talking to my wife and trying to explain how a couple of fraudulent bidders (or one bidder with multiple IDs) could bid up a coin so high that the legitimate competition (other bidders) would take one look at the auction and then pass it by without bidding. Then at the last minute,” he wrote, “the scam artist could withdraw his high bid(s), leaving his second or third account the new highest bidder, but with a much smaller amount to win the auction.”
His advice is that if you want to enter a legitimate bid, do so, and your high bid might be reinstated if it turns out higher bids were fraudulent.
But with the eBay system and other Internet bidding systems, that might not be possible because the Internet computers will only recognize a new higher bid, and will not let you enter a bid that is lower than one that already appears for the auction item.
Watch out for this scam.
It’s not funny money, but it gets funny looks
Several months ago, I pointed out that some bankers were concerned about the new program of minting special quarters to honor each of the 50 states. Bankers were concerned that so many new designs— five a year for 10 years— would open the door for counterfeit coins that could pass in circulation; and that even game room tokens could pass as quarters.
So far, we haven’t seen any reports about phony quarters getting passed as the new 50-States quarters, but some other non-funny money has gotten some funny looks.
You may have heard that Wal-Mart has been distributing the new Sacagawea golden dollar. The Wal-Mart in Stevenson Ranch, by the way, says it sold out of its allotment in less than two weeks.
When I stopped by Wal-Mart for a purchase, hoping to get a new golden dollar as change, I paid for my purchase with a Kennedy half dollar that I had picked up in change earlier at a Stevenson Ranch restaurant. I figured, why not? If Wal-Mart clerks knew about the new golden dollar, certainly they would accept a JFK half.
To my surprise, the clerk— about 21 years old, I figure— gave it a long, hard look before accepting it.
But that’s nothing.
On an Internet newsgroup for coin collectors, a soldier in the Army reported how he tried to make a purchase at his Post Exchange with one of the new golden dollars. The clerk and the manager both refused to accept it. They didn’t know what it was, even though the traditional legends and motto on U.S. coins were also on the new golden dollar.
The soldier warns this is one coin not everyone will salute and accept.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98. His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com
