My, how the collectibles business has changed. There was a time when coins and stamps and figurines and plates were sold only in shops, and by mail order, and at collector shows, and flea markets. Now, the business has gone high-tech on the Internet.
While the Internet has opened collectibles to more buyers and sellers, it has also opened the door to cons, frauds, and trouble.
Here's a look at what's going on — the good and the bad:
Despite the threat of investigations and allegations of counterfeit merchandise being sold on the Internet at www.ebay.com , that Internet auction company is seeing the best of times. eBay's stock soared, closing above $300 a share as it announced a stock split after reporting stronger than expected earnings.
But eBay is getting a lot of competition in the auction business. Coin collectors will also find auctions at Coin Universe, an Orange County company at www.coin-universe.com , and at the site operated by San Francisco-based Numismatists Online — www.numismatists.com — and at a relatively new online auction site, www.numismedia.com , run by a Torrance outfit.
Unfortunately, there aren't as many items up for auction at Numismedia, but at the same time, there aren't that many bidders, so auction-goers might actually be able to score a deal or two at this site.
One problem with Numismedia is that unlike the sites at Numismatists Online and Coin Universe, Numismedia does not have an system that will automatically raise your bid to an authorized limit. With Numismedia you must enter your top bid, then return to the site to place a higher bid if necessary.
Most of these online auction sites do have e-mail systems that will notify you when you've been outbid — so it pays to check your e-mail regularly and even to be online just minutes before an auction closes.
Another new auction site
Another new auction site is from the company ecom ecom.com which, thank goodness, has a less confusing URL at www.usas.com .
"Unlike other auction sites such as eBay," says the company, "ecom ecom does not charge for listing items to be auctioned and does not charge a percentage of the value of items sold. Instead an annual membership in the Trading Club is available for $36, and a six-month membership costs $24. This entitles the seller to unlimited use of the site." The company says a free 30-day trial is available to first-time users.
In addition to the auction format, the Trading Club at ecom ecom will also be adding a bargain outlet and a swap shop. The bargain outlet has fixed-price sales, while the swap shop is for trading.
And yes, you can also reach this site at the more confusing URL of www.ecomecom.com .
Localized auctions on the Web
There is another new auction site at www.cityauction.com which says it offers regional auction listings.
Like eBay, it offers person-to-person auctions, but it also divides the auctions into local categories, worldwide categories and national categories.
That can be a good idea when you want to close the deal face-to-face with the buyer (or seller) and are concerned about the cost and safety of shipping delicate items. Plus, when dealing with a local buyer or seller you might feel more secure about the transaction.
eBay responds to investigation
Over the last several days, word has leaked out that eBay's auction site is under investigation for allegedly having bogus and counterfeit collectibles up for sale — primarily forged autographs on baseballs. An investigation has started in New York.
Now, eBay says it "is eager to work with law enforcement regarding fraudulent items sold on the site. We have zero tolerance for fraud. We invite the New York Department of Consumer Affairs to share with us any and all information in this alleged case."
eBay says that less than 1/100 of 1 percent of the millions of transactions have generated a fraud complaint, yet it takes every one seriously.
Actually, eBay may not be at fault. The website company is more of a common carrier, like a telephone company or even a newspaper, and might not be responsible if its auction members who are not related to the company use the site to defraud others.
Sure, it would be wonderful if eBay could police all of the auctions, but that would be like a telephone company listening in on every consumer's phone call to be sure no callers were discussing a plot to defraud someone, or no callers were talking about a drug deal.
Recently there have been court decisions to support websites and Internet service providers as being common carriers who cannot be held responsible for libelous messages posted on their message boards, so there is some legal basis for eBay not being responsible for policing all of the auctions it carries.
But eBay is taking action to protect consumers. Recently eBay announced new plans to make its auctions more secure, including an escrow service for buyers and sellers and a registration service that would link sellers to a credit reporting agency with their social security numbers as proof of registration. This registration presumably would reassure bidders that their money will not vanish with some con artist when they win an auction, and that there is a real person to ship the item.
The company's website is at www.ebay.com .
Even if you don't bid on the auctions, you should look at the site to see what prices some items are fetching; this research can help you arrive at a fair price for something you plan to buy or sell even in the old-fashioned world of shops, shows and flea markets.
Remember, your best protection is to deal with merchandise you know, and sellers you know to have a good reputation. Don't be afraid to request an independent appraisal.
eBay has announced new policies to stop shill bidding (bids that the sellers engineer to raise prices on their lots) and to stop deadbeat bidders.
It's a whole new world out there. Shop carefully.
There's one good thing about online auctions: You never have to worry that scratching your nose will be considered a bid.
* * *
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
