These days, one of the biggest problems facing all collectors is buying authentic merchandise. There are so many concerns. Is it the grade or condition the seller says it is? Is it really signed by that athlete? Is it really an original work by that artist? Is it really a coin or stamp produced by that government?
For many collectors and dealers, independent third party authentication services have become vital because of the large number of fraudulent items now being bought and sold.
Coin authentication services
In the world of numismatics, there are several third party authentication services, including the Professional Coin Grading Service and Numismatic Guaranty Service. There are others. Unfortunately for the collector, all third party services are not the same.
There are allegations that one service grades coins more strictly than another, and in the market place, the coins that are graded by one service over another may command a slightly higher price because of each service's reputation.
The coin collecting industry is very much split on the value of "graded" coins. Some say the grading services are essential, especially in trading coins sight-unseen, such as over the Internet and in mail order and online auctions.
Others, however, say that because the grading services are not "perfect" in their grading standards, the collector must still inspect the coins personally. There have also been allegations that grading standards have changed over time, making coins previously graded worth less than coins graded more recently. The arguments go on.
But the basic reason for using a grading service is to give some level of security and confidence in a transaction.
New authentication techniques
In recent years, third party grading services expanded to include sports trading cards. Now there are holograms to help authenticate sports memorabilia and the certificates that come with them — the thought being that a counterfeiter would have to duplicate the ball and the signature on it, as well as the hologram on the ball and its certificate of authenticity.
Here's a new development in the authentication business: Professional Sports Authenticator of Newport Beach, California, now uses a DNA trace liquid to guarantee that the item is what the seller says it is.
"The authentication program, which will be known as PSA/DNA Guaranteed Authentic, combines the resources of the largest and most reputable company in sports card grading with the world's leading anti-counterfeiting technology company," says PSA. "Each item authenticated will bear a tamper-evident label displaying a unique certification number as well as the logo of the service. Additionally, all of the items certified will be tagged with a DNA trace liquid unique to PSA/DNA Guaranteed Authentic.
"The combination of these two technologies will present an insurmountable obstacle to would-be counterfeiters and an unprecedented level of confidence to the buyer of autographed items," says the firm.
A hand-held detector is used to read the DNA "fingerprint" that is added. The company says it currently places the DNA fingerprint on items it observes being autographed at special signings, though efforts are being made to enable the DNA fingerprint to be added with security and accuracy to previously signed memorabilia.
Right now, the service focuses primarily on modern autographs signed in the presence of PSA/DNA representatives.
The company is a division of the PCGS Professional Coin Grading Service.
Other ways to authenticate
Of course adding a DNA tracer won't work with rare coins or stamps because adding chemicals or fluids could damage the value of these collectibles.
So until now, collectors put their faith in the holders that rare coins, for example, are placed in. PCGS, NGC and others traditionally seal coins in hard plastic cases, or "slabs," which cannot be opened unless the case is broken and made useless. However, some collectors don't like to keep their coins in such plastic cases and would rather break them out for display in an album or another case. This is a personal choice.
My advice is, unless you know what you're doing, buy the "certified coins" in the slabs. Then keep the coins in them, where they will be safe from mishandling and the elements and will be easier to sell one day.
Y2K silver production expands
Continental Coin and Jewelry, a Van Nuys company that operates a private mint at a secret location here in California, is expanding its production of one-quarter-ounce silver "rounds," which it calls Y2K Silver.
The private mint's location is kept secret because of the valuable gold and silver stored there and used to mint coins and bullion rounds.
The quarter-ounce Y2K silver pieces are minted for consumers who believe Y2K may cause an economic crisis, and they want silver to barter with. Continental's private mint resumed production of the silver pieces this week and is shipping them to dealers around the country.
Earlier in the week with the price of silver at about $1.40 per quarter ounce, the retail price for the quarter-ounce rounds ranged from $1.95 to $2.10 each. Generally, expect to pay a premium of 75 cents over the price of silver for each one-quarter-ounce round.
Demand for silver is up
Dealers tell me that many consumers have started to buy private mint coins such as Continental's Y2K silver because demand has pushed the price of other silver coins and pieces to very high levels.
Some dealers report a shortage of pre-1965 U.S. silver dimes, quarters and half dollars (called "junk silver" because they are often worn and scratched and lack numismatic value). In the last couple of weeks, junk silver has sold for as much as 5.6 times face value.
There has also been a shortage of one-ounce Silver Eagles minted by the U.S. government. That shortage has led to a sharp premium in the market price of Silver Eagles. These are "bullion coins" minted for the commodity trade, and not intended for general circulation.
Dealer Jeff Butler of Coins Plus in Newhall told me he quickly sold out of his quarter-ounce Y2K silver and was expecting another shipment. He also has had a big increase in business for Silver Eagles and other silver bullion, mostly from consumers who want "barter material."
Consumers who buy silver for barter are trying to buy smaller silver pieces such as one-quarter-ounce rounds or junk silver dimes and quarters because it would be difficult to make change for larger silver bars and rounds. Besides, if there is a crisis in the year 2000, the silver price is likely to skyrocket. The record high for silver was $50 an ounce in 1980, and if that record price is reached again, the quarter-ounce silver rounds would be worth about $13 each, including the premium for fabrication.
Private silver rounds aren't a perfect solution for Y2K worriers. If there is a crisis, some businesses or consumers might balk at privately minted silver pieces, worried that they are not genuine or are truly silver. Government coins and silver, on the other hand, might give consumers more confidence — especially since counterfeiting of U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars is rare.
Words of caution
Spokesmen for area banks tell me consumers have no reason to fear the year 2000 and that banks are well on their way to correcting their computers so that ATMs and all bank accounts will operate accurately in the new millennium.
Also remember that when you keep gold and silver, your coins, rounds and bullion pieces do not earn interest or pay dividends on your money, and they are susceptible to loss or theft. In fact, if you are robbed, you could lose it all even before the new year.
* * *
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
