Maybe it's because of the strong economy, with low unemployment, rising incomes and strong consumer confidence? Or maybe it's because of the high flying stock market which has investors looking for other assets, even hard assets, to rise in value as well? Or maybe it's the fear that after years of low inflation, high inflation — public enemy number one — may be coming back and consumers know collectibles can hold their value in an inflationary economy?
Whatever the reason, there seems to be new life for the collectibles market. And it's not just rare and fine collectibles such as investor-grade coins and stamps and art. It's also what you might call "card shop" collectibles — those cute little fuzzy-wuzzy stuffed animals and ceramic landscapes with lighthouses and little tree-lined villages.
They are all selling well, sometimes selling out, and sometimes these pieces go up in value in the resale market.
Take, for example, the line of miniature "Kiddy Car Classics" that Hallmark Cards has been selling for about the last five years. These little cars resemble the push-pedal cars that kids rode around in 40 and 50 years ago. The Hallmark models are only a few inches long and now retail for about $50 each.
Had you bought the original set of five, you'd find it fetching $1,350 to $1,800 in the resale market. Each of the cars, including the new ones, have a production limit — making them collectible.
Of course, the biggest craze among collectors is still for Beanie Babies. And crazy it is. If you thought the craze would burn itself out last year, you were wrong. Kids, parents and grandparents continue to scour stores and kiosks and websites for the newest Beanie Babies, and they are pushing prices up.
Collectors and dealers tell me the Beanies in the shape of Teddy Bears are among the hottest. Their prices can soar from under $10 to about $70.
It's interesting to note that the Ty Company, maker of the Beanie Babies, says its product is designed to be collected by kids and should retail in the range of $5 apiece. Just try to find a retailer selling them for five bucks!
Ty also says it will pull its product from retailers who divert product to the secondary market instead of selling directly to consumers and collectors at lower-than secondary market prices. The company operates a website at www.ty.com.
The next big collectible
The next big collectible could be the little ceramic shoes called "Just The Right Shoe," properly named because each box contains just one miniature shoe — the one for the right foot.
Irene Singerman shows samples of the new "Just The Right Shoe," being grabbed up by collectors at her Hallmark store in Valencia. [Photo by LEON WORDEN / The Signal]
The shoes measure only a couple of inches long, and at retail shops such as Bonnie and Irene's Hallmark in Valencia, shoppers and collectors can't help but "ooh" and "aah" over them.
"Beanie Babies are the hottest thing still going," said retailer Irene Singerman of Bonnie and Irene's, "but I think this Spring, these are going to blow out of the stores."
Irene should know. A couple of weeks ago she put up her first display of the mini shoes in her Palmdale store and they did indeed blow out. This week she unveiled the line of mini shoes at her Valencia store in the Granary Square shopping center on McBean Parkway.
Dealers in Florida also report a run on the tiny shoes that replicate famous designs and styles over the centuries, which retail from $13 to $25. One of the most popular is the wedding gown shoe called "Tying The Knot," retailing for about $16.
This shoe is hard to keep in stock, dealers say, because many shoppers buy it as part of a wedding gift (they slip a check inside the shoe), or use it for place settings at wedding receptions and showers (the inside of the shoe can hold a card with the guest's name).
Already there is speculation they will shoot up in price as the first editions retire. Indeed, that has been the case with Beanie Babies, the Hallmark Kiddy Car Classics and other card shop collectibles.
In fact, the rush for collectibles is so strong that companies that did not previously issue special or limited editions are now joining the collectibles craze. The Russ Company, maker of plush dolls, this summer will release a limited-edition line of stuffed bears in an attempt to cash in.
"There's a market for them," says Steve Friedman, a sales representative for Russ. "People are always collecting and we want special items we want to go higher-end, and we feel that they will be willing to pay the price."
Indeed, put the word "collectible" on a package, and you could demand a higher price in this environment.
Pricing on the Internet
In some ways the Internet has helped feed the collecting frenzy. In other ways it has helped bring some reality to the marketplace.
Dealers such as Irene Singerman regularly check prices at online auction sites such as eBay (www.ebay.com) and other dealer and collector websites. She also checks the Ty Company site for updates on which stuffed dolls are being retired — a tip for knowing which Babies will soon soar in value.
That kind of knowledge can feed the fire, but it can also help a consumer keep from spending too much for a collectible that really isn't collectible at all.
Besides the Internet, newsstands sell magazines and price guides for collectors. Classified ads in newspapers are also a good source of pricing information.
The golden rule of collectibles
Amid the fury for collectibles, remember the golden rule of collecting: Buy it because you like it, and not because you think it will go up in value.
The collectibles market is driven by the "greater fool" theory — that a fool greater than you will come along to pay a higher price.
So buy that collectible because you like it.
These days, too many stories are going around about people who struck it rich with an old Barbie doll or an envelope with a curious postage stamp affixed to it. As a result, there are garages and attics stuffed with "collectibles."
Unfortunately, this also means a big inventory — and when this inventory comes to market it can only put downward pressure on prices.
Truly, the best collectibles for the future are items that are unpopular today but will be in high demand years from now. In other words, today's junk is tomorrow's treasure.
Last week in Long Beach
The big Long Beach Coin and Collectibles Show was held last week. The coin market appeared to be hot, with gold coins and silver dollars continuing to get much of the attention.
What I thought was unusual and interesting is that the make-up of dealer "junk boxes" has definitely changed.
In the past, junk boxes contained low-priced coins, often of low quality, in inexpensive plastic envelopes called "flips" or mounted in cardboard holders with a plastic window. This time around, at least four dealers had junk boxes filled with coins certified by the major independent grading companies, housed in "slabs" (sealed, "tamper-proof" plastic cases) — and these coins were sometimes priced at $50 or more. Obviously not junk.
Slabbed coins in junk boxes may be a sign of the times — even $50 coins can be one man's junk and another man's treasure; and there are so many "certified" coins that they are no longer rare and can be sold in unorganized piles instead of in neat display cases.
Such are the ways the hobby and the business have changed.
* * *
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
