If you’re interested in collecting coins, or if you’re a shopper at Wal-Mart , chances are you’ve gotten a glimpse of the new golden dollar coins.
Just in case you haven’t, the new “golden” dollars, as they are being called, are the new $1 coins being minted to replace the Susan B. Anthony dollar coins. They’re called “golden” because the metal is colored gold— but there is no real gold in them. They also have some other design changes featuring a portrait of the Indian guide Sacagawea holding her infant son.
Sacagawea is the guide who helped Lewis and Clark discover the Pacific Northwest. I like to think of the coin as the first in history honoring a working mother.
The coin is colored gold so it will not be confused with a quarter— which was one of the major complaints of the SBA coin. The new dollar coin also has a smooth edge, unlike the reeded edge of the SBA coin, in another effort to keep it from being confused with a quarter.
The U.S. Mint is already calling the coin a success with the public, in part because Wal-Mart has been giving them out as change in its stores, and it has been selling rolls of the coins (25 are in a roll) to customers at face value. Clerks at the Wal-Mart in Stevenson Ranch tell me that they’ve gone through several shipments of coins, and they quickly are snapped up by customers.
The vending machine industry, mass transit companies and game room operators are among those who join the mint in wanting the dollar coin to succeed. They want the new coin to succeed because coins are easier and cheaper than bills to count and sort, and coin machines work better and break less frequently than paper bill devices on vending machines and in buses.
While paper bills cost only a couple of cents to print, they typically wear out after 18 months. The coins cost 12 cents to produce but could have a life of 30 years. Economics is on the side of the coins.
But what about public opinion? The Susan B. Anthony failed to capture the public’s fancy; will the new golden dollar?
I haven’t gotten any of the new coins in circulation, and when I shopped at Wal-Mart a few times there weren’t any to be had. So I can’t say exactly if a new dollar coin in my pocket will be easy to carry and use. Instead I decided to experience the old SBA dollar again.
This “experience” wasn’t intentional; actually it happened by accident when I put a $20 bill into a vending machine at the post office on Creekside Road, and out came 10 of the coins as change. Since they’re the same size as the new dollar coins (though a different color), I thought the experiment would be valid.
Unfortunately, the coins were not comfortable at all; 10 one-dollar coins in my pocket were too heavy, too bulky, and I couldn’t wait to use them to pay the next unsuspecting clerk. I ended up spending them at Wal-Mart and felt I got revenge for the store not having any golden dollars for me.
While using a dollar coin ranks somewhere between having a cavity filled and going through an IRS audit, there are some collectors and consumers who can’t wait for them to flow through commerce.
There was an active discussion of the new dollar coin on the Internet group rec.collecting.coins, and group member Bill Havanas offered 12 reasons why dollar coins are better than paper dollars. Here are his reasons:
1. Easier to count. Coins can be counted with one hand; bills take two.
2. Coins work better in vending machines. Most bills have to be reinserted several times.
3. You can throw a coin to a hot dog vendor at a ball game easier than a paper dollar.
4. People don’t deface coins the way they do paper, so they’ll stay cleaner.
5. Bill’s grandson likes the coin better than paper.
6. Coins don’t blow away in the wind.
7. Coins will fall out of clothes before they get into the washing machine. Paper bills get washed.
8. Wet dollar coins are easier to dry than paper dollars.
9. Dollar coins are less likely to fall out of your shirt pocket than paper dollars.
10. You can’t tear a dollar coin the way you can easily tear a paper dollar. This will save scotch tape.
11. Dollar coins are easier to grab out of the coin holder in your car. There is no slot for dollar bills.
12. If you get lost in the woods you can use dollar coins to mark your path or reflect sunlight to signal for help.
“See how much superior the dollar coin is over the paper dollar?” Havanas asked.
You know, after studying his logic, I wonder why the SBA dollar failed?
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
