The coin collecting hobby— numismatics— is going through one of its best periods ever. The coin market is red hot, dealers will tell you. So will the U.S. Mint tell you that coin collecting is booming now thanks to the new series of quarters honoring the 50 states. In fact, the mint estimates that at least 100 million Americans are collecting the new quarters and many coin dealers will tell you that those same new collectors are now branching out to collect other coins as well.
“They’re coming in for Buffalo nickels and Mercury dimes and the older quarters too,” Jeff Butler, owner of Coins Plus in Newhall, told me recently. Butler says business has never been better and he credits the new quarter collectors for starting a surge in collecting.
The numismatic publications including Coin World and Coinage are repeating the same thing: that business is hot and demand is way up for all sorts of coin series.
Even the general media is catching on, reporting about the new quarters, the new currency that is also being printed now, and there are special reports about finding “a fortune in your pocket” and reports about the error coins that have been discovered lately.
In many ways, finding one of these unusual error coins is like hitting the lottery. Among the recent finds: coins with two denominations such as a quarter minted on one side of a coin blank and a dollar minted on the other side. Other spectacular error coins include coins with one side rotated or even “ upside-down .” Now, be careful about this one, because the front of a coin is in fact reversed from the back of the coin— so an upside-down coin has the images of both the front and the back facing the same way.
If you are interested in this red-hot hobby, make sure you don’t get burned. The Federal Trade Commission has issued several warnings about cheating dealers in the industry.
Among the tips from the FTC:
• Use common sense when evaluating any investment claims and do not rush into buying. Remember, anything that sounds too good to be true usually is not true.
• Make sure you know your dealer’s reputation and reliability before you send money or authorize a credit-card transaction. If you can, find out how long the company has been in business. Don’t rely just on what a dealer’s representative tells you on the phone. For example, if a dealer claims to be a member of a professional organization, call the organization and make sure that the claim is true. If you cannot confirm the reliability of the dealer, consider investing with another firm.
• Do not be taken in by promises that the dealer will buy back your coins at or for more than the price you paid or that grading is guaranteed unless you are confident that the dealer has the financial resources to stand behind these promises. Many of the coin sellers prosecuted by the Federal Trade Commission in the last several years have not been able to meet guarantees and other obligations to their customers.
• It is wise to get a second opinion from another source about grade and value as soon as you receive your coins. So, before you buy, find out what remedies you will have if the second opinion differs. For example, some companies offer a 30-day return period if you are not satisfied with your purchase. Check the information that you are given. Will the full purchase price be refunded or will you be given a credit to be used for the purchase of other coins? If a dealer promises to buy back the coins at the same grade at which they were sold, does that mean at the price you paid or at some discounted amount?
• Check the grades of any coins you buy with an independent source. Be cautious about grading certificates and “slabs,” especially those furnished by coin dealers. Many of the third-party grading services encapsulate or “slab” a coin in an acrylic holder with a grading number. This can protect the coin from further damage and reduce the chances of having a coin of a lesser grade substituted for one of a higher grade. If you use a grading certificate or slab as a second opinion, be sure you understand what they represent.
Grading is not an exact science, and a certificate or slab represents no more than the opinion of the certification or grading service. Find out if the grading service is indeed independent of the dealer, what grading standards the service used, and what is the service’s reputation in the industry. Also because grading standards vary, coins certified by different services will be worth more or less than other coins of the same grade. Weekly periodicals or sight-unseen trading networks list prices for coins that have been certified by various services. Check the prices for those coins you are considering.
(Note from Alan: check eBay for how coins prices vary with the “slabs” or the certification services. For example, a 1964 proof Washington quarter certified as Proof 69 by the Professional Coin Grading Service might not have the same value as a coin graded by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation. Both are regarded as quality certification services, but among dealers and collectors, coins graded by PCGS are considered to be worth slightly more than coins graded by NGC even when both coins have the same grade or score.)
• Comparison-shop . You need to be concerned not only with grades, but with prices as well. Consult several dealers before buying. Check prices in leading coin publications or sight-unseen trading network lists to make sure you are not being overcharged. Sight-unseen coin trading networks offer only the lowest-priced bids being offered for coins.
Several publications list representative wholesale values for fine coins of various issues and grades. These values generally are higher than the prices consumers can expect to receive if they were to immediately sell their coins, and lower than the retail prices consumers may be charged to buy the coins. Consult such publications prior to trusting dealers’ representations about the current value of coins. If a dealer’s advertised price is much lower than the price listed in these publications, then the dealer may be misrepresenting the quality or grade of the coin.
(Note from Alan: Check the following Web sites for some estimates of prices... eBay, pcgs.com, bowersandmerena.com and heritagecoin.com. It’s also a good idea to visit coin shows in your area to see coins upfront and personal so you can appreciate what a “grade” means for a coin; coin shows are another way to price comparison. For a list of coin shows in your area go to the Web site coinshows.com and consult the ads in your local newspaper.)
• Take possession of any coins you purchase to ensure they exist and to be sure that they are properly stored.
• As with any consumer purchase, be wary about giving your credit card number to strangers, especially over the telephone.
It’s a great hobby, and it’s one that will give you enjoyment for years— and maybe some profits too.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
