There's a great treasure hunt on now — and you can take part. Every day, check your pocket change for copper pennies from 1943 because if you find one, a real one, it could be worth $10,000 or more. And you might want to start buying packs of baseball cards printed by the Upper Deck Company, because if you find a pack with a tiny sliver of wood in it you could be $2,500 richer.
1943 copper pennies
It seems the entire nation is looking for them now — U.S. cents minted in 1943 that were made from copper.
In 1943 because of the war and the critical shortage of copper, the government made pennies out of steel. But a few copper pennies were minted by mistake — and by renegade mint employees — and they can be very, very valuable if found.
A few weeks ago, a couple in Idaho reported that they had a 1943 copper penny and spent it by mistake. Some coin dealers doubt their story, while others hope it's true because it means there is a penny out there that could really put you "in the money." Some reports put the value of that copper penny, if real, at a half-million dollars. But since then, experts in the coin collecting industry have reported that the value of the coin, if real, might be closer to $50,000 or perhaps as low as $10,000. But even ten grand is a nice prize for the right penny from heaven.
Superior Stamp and Coin Company in Beverly Hills says the value of a circulated 1943 copper penny would be in the range of $10,000 to $20,000. Superior, a couple of years ago, handled the sale of an uncirculated copper cent at a price of $82,500 — a high price because it was the only one known from the Denver mint.
Mark Goldberg of Superior estimates that there are about 40 verified, authentic 1943 copper cents, but more could be out there. If you think you have a 1943 copper cent, give it the magnet test: A real copper coin will not be attracted to a magnet, while a steel cent that has been plated or dipped in copper will still be attracted to the magnet.
Coin dealers would use more sophisticated tests to determine if a 1943 copper cent is genuine, including weight, measurement and specific gravity tests.
Too many bogus coins
The problem for penny treasure hunters is that there are thousands and thousands of counterfeit 1943 copper coins circulating, including coins that were plated with copper.
"They plate them, they cast them," Goldberg, president of Superior, told me of the counterfeiters. "In the 1950s when people were eagerly searching for these coins there were thousands of them plated."
Goldberg has many examples of these bogus 1943 copper cents that were dipped or plated with copper. He also showed me a legitimate one from 1943 that was minted in San Francisco.
Still, there may be more out there to find, because no one knows exactly how many were minted by accident and by employees who thought it might be fun to use copper planchets from 1942 in the presses that were loaded with 1943 dies.
So, go ahead and look to your heart's content. Just remember, there were about 1 billion steel cents minted, and if only forty or even fifty 1943 copper cents were made, you'd have a better chance of winning a state lottery than finding one of those elusive copper cents. And while you're at it, keep an eye out for 1944 cents made out of steel, supposedly struck from leftover steel planchets that were intended only for 1943 cents. In 1944 the mint returned to "copper" cents.
What about those 1943 steelies, as they are called? If you find one, you didn't win the lotto — in fact, you didn't even win lunch. You see, in circulated condition the 1943 steel cents typically sell for 10 or 15 cents each. (Repeat: cents.) Never seen one? Then stop by Coins Plus at 23332 Lyons Avenue in Newhall, where dealer Jeff Butler will give you one for free — while supplies last — hoping you'll become a collector of other old and odd coins.
Another great find: Wood
The Upper Deck Company has done it again, raising the stakes for buying a pack of baseball cards. Longtime collectors will recall that decades ago, packs of cards included a slice of chewing gum. Today, a few packs of cards will include a slice of a home run king's baseball bat. No kidding.
Upper Deck, based in Carlsbad, Calif., has been buying game-used baseball bats belonging to members of the 500 club — players who have hit 500 or more homers in a career.
Babe Ruth's game-used bat, for example, was purchased for $23,000 last summer by Upper Deck. The company has been slicing those bats into as many as 400 slivers and placing them in special trading cards inserted in random packs. The Babe Ruth "bat cards" are already out, and while the shelf price is $3 per pack, in the aftermarket the Ruth bat card is fetching $2,500.
The next bat card will include a sliver of Mickey Mantle's bat; there will also be bat cards for Eddie Murray and Frank Robinson. As many as 15 different bat cards are likely to be released this year.
"Our mission is to always give collectors a great value and something they can't find anywhere else," said Tim Murret, director of new product development at Upper Deck.
Other so-called "insert cards" have included swatches of game jerseys and pieces of game-used balls. And now, a sliver of wood from a bat.
So here's a tip for moms and dads: If your kid, or even your spouse, asks you to buy him or her a pack of cards, it might be worth your while to watch them open the pack and sort through the cards. If you see a funny card with a piece of wood attached to it (it resembles a sample of wood tile that a flooring company might give out), grab it! That's one trading card you don't want traded away — unless it's for a lot of green cash.
* * *
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
