For years now we've been warned of the dangers of population booms — overcrowded schools, snarled freeways and urban sprawl are just some of them. Well, here's another danger of population booms that you might not have thought of before: falling values of collectibles.
Collecting is now very sophisticated. Collector magazines and Internet sites have helped spread sophisticated knowledge about collectibles, including their values and populations. In the world of collectibles, "population" means the number of pieces or examples in existence in various grades or conditions.
For instance, it is well known among coin collectors that there are only five Liberty Head nickels dated 1913, and only 15 silver dollars dated 1804. In the art world, populations can vary significantly: there is only one Mona Lisa painting, but Alexander Calder, the famous American sculptor and graphic artist, used lithographic printing and hand-signed 50 examples of his Fiesta print on rice paper — and even more on arches paper.
In the world of collectible figurines, certain figures may have populations of several dozen or several thousand. What makes original Mickey Mouse watches so valuable now is that while hundreds or thousands may have been manufactured and sold decades ago, few survive today — fewer still in excellent condition.
As all collectors know, population affects value. What makes an 1804 silver dollar worth $1 million or more is the fact that only 15 exist. In contrast, since there are probably thousands of 1904 silver dollars around, one of those coins might be valued at $50 or less.
Even Hollywood has followed the population theory in movie plots. I remember an old black-and-white movie about a stamp collector who stole a rare stamp from a rival collector. It seems there were only two of these stamps in the world, and the thief didn't steal his rival's example of that rare stamp to keep it — oh, no. He stole it to burn it, to make his lone, surviving example of that rare stamp that much more valuable!
Recently there has been a big push to sell and collect rare, low-population coins. Last week, for example, a proof (specially minted from polished dies) 1956 Franklin half dollar sold in an Internet auction for $5,300. The Coin Universe auction (www.coin-universe.com) listed the coin as "proof-69 deep cameo" as certified by the Professional Coin Grading Service.
Indeed, that is a very rare and high-grade coin. In the world of numismatics, a perfect coin with no marks or wear can grade only as high as 70, and the designation of "deep cameo" means the coin was one of the very first struck by the dies at the mint, resulting in deep, mirrored backgrounds and crisp, white features of Benjamin Franklin, the Liberty Bell and other designs on the coin.
The auction listing said, "PCGS has examined and graded over 50,000 Proof Franklins (this includes all dates). Of those, only 37 have earned the proof-67 deep cameo designation and not a single coin has been graded finer."
Therefore, one could believe, this coin is the best of the best, and no wonder it was bid up to $5,300, while other 1956 Franklin Half Dollars of lesser quality may be worth as little as $3. Certainly, the belief that this "proof-69 deep cameo" is the only one of its kind impressed bidders and contributed to its value.
But is that "proof-69 deep cameo" 1956 Franklin the only one? Perhaps not, and if not, does its value get sliced in half if a second one is discovered? Will its value be sliced by tenths if nine more are discovered?
Unfortunately for coin collectors, especially for collectors of more modern coins such as Franklin half dollars, there can be more high-grade coins that haven't yet been submitted to certification outfits such as PCGS or the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation. Therefore, there is a big risk in buying a coin that you think is unique or rare for its high grade.
Here is a recent example. Two weeks ago, in another Coin Universe auction, a 1960 Washington quarter graded proof-69 by PCGS came up for bid. The PCGS population report of January indicated that only one such proof-69 coin existed, and that there were no proof-70 examples. The auction listing stated, "only one of these in this incredible grade." It's no surprise then that the bidding was active, and the coin sold on March 9th for $43.
Now, $43 doesn't seem like a high price, but in the world of proof quarters from the 1960s, it is substantial.
Just one week later, that $43 price for the "one of the kind" 1960 quarter proved way too high. Because just one week later, another Coin Universe auction listed another 1960 proof-69 Washington.
How could that be, when the auction listing of the week before said only one existed? Well, sure enough, it seems another high-grade proof Washington had been certified by PCGS. In fact, not one more, but 24 more. Plus, PCGS reported that it had now certified four proof-70 quarters from 1960. And in that next auction that closed on March 19th, the price of a proof-69 Washington from 1960 plunged to $20 — less than half the price of the week before.
As more proof-69 quarters and the proof-70 quarters come to market, the prices could drop even more unless there are enough new collectors to buy up the inventory. Such is the world of supply and demand.
On the Internet, in some of the coin collecting chat rooms and bulletin boards, collectors and dealers complain that the coins for sale on popular auction sites such as eBay (www.ebay.com) have become so plentiful that many coins are not getting bids over their reserve prices, when they get bids at all, and therefore are not selling. It seems the population of some coins is high, while the population of collectors willing to buy them is low.
Beware the lure of buying low-population coins, because they may not be low-population coins months, weeks or even days later. Even PCGS warns: "The populations reported for these coins may be artificially low, and not representative of the actual number of these coins available in the marketplace."
So you've got to wonder. Did the bidder who got the $5,300 Franklin half — the one purported to be the finest known — really get the deal of a lifetime? Or did he buy a ticking bomb that will go off, blowing up his investment, if additional examples of the high-grade Franklin proofs show up?
A population boom can be dangerous. It can make parking at the mall difficult, and force you to lay head-to-someone-else's-toes at the beach. And it can destroy the value of your collectibles if you bought them thinking you had the "only one" or the "best of the best."
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
