Are rare coins a good investment? It depends on time— how much time you’ve held the coins and when you bought them.
If you bought Morgan silver dollars in 1980 you are probably still losing money on them, because that was the year that silver peaked at $50 an ounce— and common-date Morgans (meaning those that are not especially rare) were selling for $40 and up. Today, with silver priced around $5 an ounce, those same Morgan dollars are worth maybe $10 each.
25 years later
Historians often look at 25-year intervals. I thought it would be interesting to see what happened to selling prices on coins over the last quarter-century . A copy of a sales brochure from a well-known coin dealer at the time shows what prices were like then.
The dealer was called Foothill Coins; today the original owners of Foothill operate Valley View Coins in Encino.
Tom Lenk, who used to work for Foothill and is now one of the owners at Valley View, took a look at the old prices and today’s prices and said the bottom line is that “scarcer coins go up better.”
Lenk is not surprised that a rare coin such as a 1909 Lincoln cent from the San Francisco mint, with the designer’s initials “VDB” on the back of the coin, tripled in value in the past 25 years, even in “good” condition. That 1909S-VDB cent (as it is known in collector parlance) is a rare coin and will keep going up. “But a common date Franklin half dollar is up only 80 cents in a quarter-century because it’s common,” he told me.
A look at the price changes
Here is a look at some “collector coin” prices from 1975 and how they compare with prices today:
An 1877 Indian Head Cent in “fair” condition (meaning it is very worn) sold for $57 in 1975. Today it is priced at $230 at Valley View. It is considered the “key,” or the rarest coin in the Indian Head series.
The 1909S-VDB cent in “good” condition (meaning it is well circulated) was $112 a quarter century ago and now is $379.
A 1916 Mercury dime in “almost good” condition was 50 cents in 1975; today this coin sells for $1.49. There are many examples of this coin in collections and in coin shops, and it is not rare despite its age.
A Walking Liberty half dollar from 1916, the first year it was minted, was $7 in “almost good” condition in 1975. Today it sells for $29. One “rare” coin even in 1975 was the 1932 Washington quarter made at the Denver mint. A quarter-century ago that coin in “uncirculated” condition (meaning new with no damage from wear) was priced at $350. Today the same coin sells for a minimum of $488, and perhaps hundreds of dollars more depending on how well it has been kept during the years.
There is disappointment for “collectors” of the Kennedy half dollar, especially those minted in 1964, their first year of issue.
Probably every family in America put away one or more Kennedy half dollars in 1964, and some families saved whole rolls of 20 coins still in their bank coin wrappers. Even in 1975 they weren’t worth much— just $2.25 in “brilliant uncirculated” condition. Today that same coin is worth maybe $4 or $5.
The price of silver
The price of silver has had a big impact on the value of “silver” coins, including Morgan silver dollars, Kennedy half dollars and common-date Franklin half dollars. There have been several times in the past quarter century when these coins became more valuable for their precious metal content than for their rarity or collector value.
Take a 1963 Franklin half dollar, for example— the last of the Franklin halves first minted in 1948. In 1975 an average circulated Franklin dated 1963 was selling for $2.15 at Foothill Coins. Today at Valley View that coin is $2.95. But when the price of silver peaked in 1980, that same coin was selling for about 38 times face value, or about $20.
Future prices
What about the future? What coins are worth “investing” in today, and what will prices be like 25 years from now? I put the questions to Lenk.
”Buy the better-date coins,” he told me. “They are the ones that are tougher to find now and will be even tougher to find in the future.
Among the coins he likes today are the same “tough” coins a quarter century ago, including the 1909S-VDB cent and an 1877 Indian cent. Lenk also likes the 1916 Mercury dime from the Denver mint, which is rare and should not be confused with the 1916 dime from the Philadelphia mint, which is common and cheap today.
Washington quarters are also moving up in value because of the huge number of new collectors who have started collecting the new 50-State quarters. The U.S. Mint estimates that 120 million Americans are now collecting the new 50-State quarters.
”These could move,” Lenk said of the 50-State quarters.
At his shop now, the first of the 50-State quarters honoring Delaware sells for $2.
“In 25 years that could be a $10 coin,” Lenk said. “The quarters are so widely spread,” he said, “there are so many collectors, and that will keep their values going up.”
He said that even the now-common Franklin half dollars are likely to double in the next quarter-century because there is only a finite number of them and more collectors are entering the hobby.
The Sacagawea dollar
One more new coin is boosting the number of new collectors— and that’s the Sacagawea “golden dollar.” The coin has been available for circulation for more than a month now, but hardly any reach circulation because of apparent hoarding by consumers and new collectors.
In some coin stores, the new dollar coin is selling for $1.25 to $1.50 each. But Lenk doubts the coin will catch on as a collectible.
How much with the “Sac” be worth 25 years from now?
“One dollar,” Lenk said.
Keep this article. We’ll compare notes in 2025.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
