Amazon.com is now in the online auction business, going after the business now dominated by eBay ( www.ebay.com ) and other online auction houses including ubid.com and Collectors Universe and Hobby Markets, which operate a host of sites for collectors of everything from coins and stamps to sports cards and antiques.
Soon, Sotheby's, the big New York auction gallery, will be getting into the online auction business as well, but it remains to be seen if that site will have garage-sale specialties that are the bread and butter of eBay, or if it will bring Picasso and Rembrandt to desktops world-wide.
Amazon's pitch
You might consider it unusual that Amazon would be going into the auction business since it made its mark first as a book seller and then a retailer of audio and music. But Amazon has seen the light, and heard the sound of the auctioneer's gavel, and realizes there is big money to be made with e-auctions.
After all, an online auction company merely is a bulletin board for listings, and uses its computers to match bidders with sellers; it doesn't handle the merchandise, nor does it get involved in shipping.
Amazon.com is now sending e-mail to its customers explaining its new online auctions.
The new auction listings will let consumers buy from other consumers. The e-mail says, "Now, with auctions, our community of almost 8 million customers can sell anything they want to. ... You'll find rare books and signed first editions, rare music, vintage toys, antiques, sports memorabilia, collectibles of all kinds, etc., etc."
Amazon is also doing something to boost consumer confidence in the online auction process. You've heard the allegations that counterfeit merchandise has been sold on eBay, and you've also heard about the problems with the online bidding and consignment process — shills jacking up bids, and consignors not delivering the goods after an auction is completed and disappearing with the money sent in by the bidders.
So Amazon is doing something similar to what eBay announced recently: It is providing a fraud protection plan to protect bidders.
The Amazon plan protects bidders up to $250. Amazon says they'll "take your word for it if you're ever the victim of fraud."
"There are some restrictions," the company is saying in its e-mail. "For example, the guarantee doesn't apply to purchases above $250." Amazon notes that the vast majority of items sell for significantly less than that.
Buyers are protected if they paid for an item and didn't receive it, and if they received the item but it was "materially different from the seller's description of it."
Some examples of material differences: if items listed as "new" are actually used; if items listed as "genuine" are counterfeit; and if items listed as "rare" are not rare at all.
"Rare" could be a point of dispute. One seller listed a 1955 Franklin half dollar as "rare." While you won't be able to find one in change every day, it's far from rare.
At Coins Plus in Newhall, for example, 1955 Franklin half dollars are frequently available on the store's "bid board," a silent auction that closes each Tuesday evening. A 1955 half dollar retails for $5 to $10 in uncirculated condition. If you bought this "rare" coin through Amazon and later found another one for sale at Coins Plus, would Amazon refund your money? Here, the definition of "rare" would be at issue.
I found it easy to sign up for the Amazon auctions. I bid on an 1884 silver dollar from the Carson City mint, certified by PCGS as mint state-64 condition. I placed a bid for $91 with a maximum of $93.
Most online auction sites use "bidding robots" that raise your bid to the highest level you authorize to out-bid competitors. In my case, I authorized a top bid of $93 because if I won the lot, I would also be responsible for the shipping charges.
Keep shipping charges, buyers' fees and sales tax in mind before you bid, and figure these additional charges into the amount you are willing to pay.
From the start, I did great in the Amazon auction — because on the same auction page, David Lawrence, a nationally known dealer, was also selling an 1884 -CC silver dollar, certified by PCGS as MS-64 with a starting bid of $115.
I immediately checked David Lawrence's web page at www.davidlawrence.com and found that he was selling the same coin for $115 on his website — and that was a fixed price, not an auction. When the auction closed last Sunday, I got the coin at my first bid of $91 — a virtual steal. There were no other bids, so my maximum of $93 was not placed by the "robot."
Of course, Amazon's website is at www.amazon.com .
Big trouble with online auctions
The California Attorney General's Office reports that online auctions are now the number one source of complaints from consumers — mostly from buyers who have paid for but never received the merchandise they won.
Here are some tips:
Try to pay with a credit card. Many online sellers will let you use credit cards, and if you don't get the merchandise you can challenge the charges with your credit card issuer. If you can't use a credit card, ask about an escrow service; eBay offers escrow services, and there is a fee for them.
Ask about return policies in case you are not satisfied with the item. Even collectibles that are "graded" and "certified" by independent third party services such as PCGS and NGC can disappoint collectors. Coin collecting auction sites such as Coin-Universe.com and Numismatists.com have liberal return policies even though most of their online items are certified.
The Attorney General's office is now investigating several of the online auction sites for what it describes as "lottery auctions," in which an item is put up for auction, but the consignor withdraws the item from the auction when it appears that the bidding will not get high enough.
Some of the online auction companies including Numismatists.com, owned by Hobby Markets of San Francisco, actually allow dealer-sellers to withdraw auction items at the last moment — and this can leave high bidders both disappointed and without the "deal" they thought they were going to get through the auction process.
There is one more pitfall about online auctions. Longtime auction goers will tell you the best auctions are those in the middle of a blizzard, when no one else can show up. The problem with the Internet is that blizzards don't matter anymore — now everyone can show up just by logging on from home.
Cyber-auctions may have killed the days of the bargain lots — while creating more profits for online sellers. No wonder Amazon, the book seller, is now in the auction business. Any of its economics books explaining supply and demand would have told the Amazon chiefs to get in on this hot new business.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
More "It's Your Money" Columns
