April was not a good month. The stock market got clobbered. And so did some online auctions.
If you’re an eBay online auction bidder, you may have picked up some wonderful bargains during April.
But if you were a seller during the month, you may have been very disappointed by the low bids.
While there are no statistics on the differences in selling prices during April, the differences in auction results have been widely discussed in Internet chats. Here are some conclusions that were reached:
Their first is that disposable income— the money people have to spend— was low last month because of taxes.
“People have to pay those tax bills,” one online newsgroup member told me.
People were writing checks to the IRS and their state tax collectors, and that left less money for online bidding.
In fact, that same reason may have led to some of the Wall Street selling in early April as investors sold stocks to raise money to pay the tax bills on their 1999 profits.
Internet newsgroup members are divided on whether the sell-off on Wall Street also led to a drop in prices on eBay for collectibles. But in an unofficial survey on the coin collecting newsgroup, rec.collecting.coins, few members said the sell-off in stocks hurt the coin market. In fact, many believed that the sell-off in Wall Street probably helped the hard assets, including collectibles as investors sought another, safer place for their money.
How to improve prices
On Wall Street, analysts are now talking about what stocks should be getting higher prices. The analysts are looking for the technology stocks to make a rebound, and they are saying that companies with solid and growing earnings are the most likely to improve in price.
But in online auctions, the reasons for higher prices are different.
Tim Fitzsenry, who is a member (participant) in the coin collecting newsgroup rec.collecting.coins and uses the screen name of Dobac, has some ideas on ways to improve bids.
First, don’t have auctions in April. Tim says June is one of the best months of the year for selling things online. That may make sense if you believe consumers are short of money in April because by June most tax refunds have been received. About three-quarters of taxpayers get a refund, and the IRS says this year the average refund is $1,624, which is about 5.3 percent more than last year.
Tim says that his newsgroup performed some test studies over a two-month period, and here are some of their other conclusions:
• Use a credit card payment system such as PayPal or Billpoint— systems that will let sellers accept credit card payments at a lower cost than setting up a credit card account with a bank.
• Write the title of your auction carefully. Avoid generic titles such as “Family Heirlooms,” and use specifics that will attract certain specific buyers such as “Rare Tiffany silver bracelet with rubies circa 1940.”
• Make your auction a 5-day auction or a 7-day auction. The newsgroup found that three-day auctions were too short and 10-day auctions were too long. However, another study by the Internet newsletter and website Auctionbytes.com found that ten-day auctions are best, especially when the auction starts on a Thursday or Friday and ends 10 days later on a Sunday or Monday. Auctionbytes.com found that such auctions, with two weekends, will get the most exposure to bidders who frequent auction websites mostly on weekends.
• Have your auction end between 7 p.m. and 8 p.m. West Coast time which is between 10 p.m. and 11 p.m. East Coast time— this is the peak time for online activity— notes the newsgroup researchers. Makes sense.
However, Jeff Butler of Coins Plus in Newhall who is a frequent eBay participant, prefers to have his auctions end weekdays during working hours.
“People are bidding online from work using their computers,” he says.
It’s an interesting thought, and there are companies now cracking down on unauthorized Internet use by workers using company computers on company time.
• The newsgroup also found that consumers have more disposable income around the 15th and the 30th of the month. This also makes sense because of all the workers who are now paid twice a month.
But the newsgroup suggests that your auction should end on the 15th or the 30th of the month. Instead, the group suggests that your auction end on the Friday night or Saturday night following the 15th or the 30th because the group also found that bidding is most ferocious on Friday and Saturday nights.
• If you have several items up for bids, spread out the times that the auctions end. If you have several auctions ending around the same time, you could compete against yourself, so while bidders are concentrating on one auction, they might not be able to watch and participate in another.
The newsgroup researchers found that many bidders are “snipers,” meaning that they make active final bids in the last few seconds of an auction, and you must give the snipers time to move on to the next auction. Sniping can create several last-minute bids.
• Another strategy is to tell your potential bidders that you, the seller, will pay the shipping costs. Many sellers list their auctions with shipping charges extra, and some list high shipping charges which can turn off bidders.
Newsgroup member Dobac suggests that by offering to pay all shipping charges, sellers don’t have to worry that a shipping charge of $4 or $5 will put off another bid.
• On low-cost items, the newsgroup also suggests that you risk selling an item with no reserve, or no minimum bid. A reserve is a secret minimum bid that is needed before you agree to sell an item.
Many bidders will steer clear of reserve auctions because they don’t want to play games with sellers. By the same token, bidders avoid auctions with minimums because they feel they’re not getting a deal.
This is a gamble because you run the risk of selling something for less than your cost. Also, without a reserve price or a minimum price listed, bidders must decide what is a fair price, and sometimes they guess too high, says Dobac.
• Now, I’m going to add two more tips of my own: Don’t rig your auction with shill bids. The online auction community is very sophisticated and can quickly tell if there are shills involved in your auction. Among the tip-offs : The same bidder showing up in one particular seller’s auctions but not in others.
• My final tip: Be honest with your listings and with your business practices. The online community will quickly get to know if you are a prompt seller and shipper, and an honest one.
Good luck.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on We dnesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
