If you’ve been a coin collector or coin investor for a long time you either love or hate the year 1989.
You love 1989 if that was the year you decided to sell your coins, because that was the year coin market prices peaked.
What a peak it was, too. An 1879 Morgan Silver Dollar in gem uncirculated condition had a market price of more than $5,125, according to David Hall’s North American Trading, a respected coin dealer in Santa Ana. It was also the year that an 1827-dated dime in gem uncirculated condition sold for $94,500.
Why so much? Well, 1989 was the year that the big Wall Street investment companies took note of the rare coin market and started to publish reports of the big profits in rare coins and tried to organize investor syndicates for rare coin portfolios— much like mutual funds in the stock market. Many of the big stock brokerage firms were looking for new places to put their clients’ money— and after the stock market crash of 1987 the coin market looked like a safe place with a good bet.
But then, you might hate 1989 if that was the year you bought coins. That 1879 Morgan Silver Dollar that cost $5,125 in 1989 is nowhere near that price now. David Hall now sells the coin for $995, or less than 20 percent of its old price. And that 1827 dime that was worth $94,500 back then is now worth $16,500— a drop of about 83 percent.
Eleven years later
Now, almost midway through the year 2000, the coin collecting hobby and market still has its ups and downs. But it’s starting to look like there are more downs than ups coming.
The stock market sell-off is now being blamed for lower prices and a drop off in buying and interest in the coin market.
“Through March we had very strong demand,” rare coin dealer Ted Koopman told me last week at a coin collecting show in Van Nuys. “But in the last 30 days we’ve seen a very strong downturn in expensive coins.”
Koopman blames the stock market for robbing potential coin buyers of money— “if not from their pockets, then from their minds,” he said, pointing to his brain and winking.
Consumer confidence and investor confidence and hobby confidence all seem to go together.
Several coin dealers at that Van Nuys coin show told me that when they attended a similar coin show in Silicon Valley a few weeks ago they could see a change. They told me how collectors who were employed in the computer and Internet industries who a few months before would not blink at buying a $1,000 coin were now shaking their heads “no” at the sight of $100 coins for sale. It is that bad.
“These guys probably lost millions on paper, in their stock options, and now their option for coins is cut,” another dealer told me.
A drop in gold prices
Lower prices in the gold market are also leading to lower prices for gold coins and other collectible coins. In the last few months of 1999 gold prices rose as speculators bought the yellow metal as a hedge against Y2K computer problems. But when those problems did not appear, gold was sold and prices fell. After reaching a high of about $340 an ounce a few months ago, gold is now trading around $275 an ounce, and many gold coins have also dropped in value.
Prices on gold bullion coins such as the American Gold Eagle, containing one ounce of silver, have also dropped significantly. Before New Year’s these coins were selling with a markup of $12 over the value of the gold content. But today, Koopman says these coins are being bought at four dollars less than their gold content or the “spot” price of gold.
“People are dumping them,” Koopman said.
People also seem to be dumping U.S. Silver Dollars for the same reason. Common-date dollars from 1878 to 1904 that are in circulated condition and not especially attractive to collectors are falling in value. In late 1999 these “commons,” as they are called, were worth about $12 each, and now that are around $7 each. Each dollar has about three-quarters ounce of silver, and silver is about $5 an ounce now.
Smaller silver coins minted until 1964 are also losing value. These coins— dimes, quarters and half-dollars — are called “junk silver” and are 90-percent silver. A bag of junk silver with $1,000 face value sold for as much as $5,800 in late 1999 but today sells for about $3,500.
What investors are buying
But investors are still buying certain coins, hoping that the current downturn will be short and mild.
The new George Washington quarters honoring the 50 states continue to be hot and in demand. A $10 roll of quarters from Delaware or Pennsylvania can still fetch $40 or more, and dealers believe these quarters will continue to rise in value as more 50-state quarters are issued and more Americans decide to collect the series. Quarters honoring some of the most populous states including Florida, Texas, New York and California still have not been released.
Investors also seem to be buying 1995 Proof Sets issued by the U.S. Mint. Proof Sets are made up of specially struck coins to show a mirrored finish. 1995 proof sets that sold for $12 a year ago now sell for $70. “Somebody is hoarding them,” Koopman told me.
Some collectors are still paying higher prices for early Lincoln cents minted between 1909 and 1930 that are in red, uncirculated condition. The “red” means they have not yet “toned” or discolored due to exposure to the air.
The stock market factor
While some coin dealers point to the sell-off in the stock market for less interest in coins, other coin dealers take a different view. These other coin dealers expect that the coin market will pick up once disenchanted stock investors look for a different and better place for their money. They feel rare coins will be the place.
You know, the same thing happened in 1989— less than two years after the great crash of 1987. But as we know, that “peak” in the coin market just didn’t last.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
