What some baseball trading card collectors called the king of baseball cards— the greatest card ever— struck out May 6 in its second auction attempt on eBay, the online auction site.
While 2,956 potential bidders looked at the auction, not one bid was received. The starting bid was $25,000. However, that $25,000 starting bid was less than the $26,000 that the same card received after only a few days in an aborted auction about a week earlier.
The card is an Upper Deck Hall of Famers baseball card that carried authentic “cut” autographs by Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Walter Johnson, Honus Wagner and Christy Mathewson. “Cut” means the autographs were cut from letters, autograph books, canceled checks or whatever, then assembled onto one— and only one— special baseball card issued by the Upper Deck Company of Carlsbad, Calif.
Kevin Coakley, a collector in New Hampshire, “pulled” the card from a pack of cards he purchased through an auction on eBay a few weeks ago. You might recall that he put the card up for auction on eBay, the Internet auction site on April 21 only to stop the auction and cancel it. “I had second thoughts,” he told me.
But Coakley put the card up for auction a second time; only to have no bidders— unlike the first time when the card attracted about three dozen bidders with the bidding soaring to north of $25,000 before Coakley stopped the auction.
Some collectors and dealers predicted the card would fetch between $50,000 and $100,000. But some other industry insiders were fearful that the card would receive no bids the “second time around.” These other experts were correct.
One of those experts warning of “no bids” was a marketing specialist at Upper Deck, the Carlsbad, California company that created the one-of-a-kind autograph card. “Those eBay bidders get angry when someone messes with them,” he told me in a phone call this past week. “I don’t think it will get any bids.” He was right.
The Upper Deck expert warned that eBay members now might fear that Coakley would stop the auction again, or might fail to deliver the card once the auction ends. But Coakley told me he was ready to part with the card, and realized that eBay was the place to sell it because it was faster and would actually cost less than through traditional auction houses.
Coakley balked at using traditional auction companies which would charge him about 15percent of the selling price as their commission, and could take several months to promote the card and bring it to auction. The eBay method on the other hand would cost him about 2 percent of the selling price and would be completed in about a week and would present the card worldwide.
But Coakley’s card didn’t sell on eBay the second time. He now has to reconsider his options. He might go for a private sale this time, or consider the traditional auction-house method now. He also has the option to relist the card on eBay another time, and hope that all is forgiven by the previous bidders who felt slighted.
Overall eBay Bids Lower
Meanwhile, the Internet auction information Web site AuctionBytes.com has released a study showing that eBay sellers are making 25 percent less than they were a year ago. The study found that “typical consumer collectibles are selling for 25 percent less than they were a year ago, with an increase in the number of items for sale.”
David Steiner of AuctionBytes.com said, “I’m not surprised at the results of our study. Sellers have been telling us for some time that while the cost of selling on auction sites like eBay is increasing, they are realizing lower sales prices for their items.”
Steiner says there are several issues contributing to the drop in sales prices. First, the study found the supply of items for sale is up from a year ago. This means more competition for sellers and lower selling prices. Secondly, the study found there are increases in shipping costs that are being passed on to buyers; buyers are adjusting their bids to take the higher shipping costs into account. Steiner also cautions that there is increased media hype about online fraud which is scaring away some bidders. And there is more competition for sellers on the web from other sites including online retailers and other web auction sites.
Steiner reports that eBay has not commented about his company’s findings.
Steiner’s survey compared a sample of “consumer collectibles” and their average selling price a year or more ago with prices in May. “The study confirms that there are a greater number items listed now with an ASP (average selling price) ranging from 9,5 percent to 33.7 percent lower than a year ago.”
Tips for Auction Sellers
With this study in hand, it’s a good time to review some tips for online sellers:
First, know your market. Do not hope for a high selling price, but sell when you think demand would be best. Timing is everything on the Internet. For example, some sellers say bidding is not likely to be strong on certain holidays or at certain times of day or night, or on certain days of the week. Some sellers say the best time to “end” an auction is on a Sunday evening following the second or fourth payday Friday of the month.
Some items don’t sell well on the Internet, period. Know where your market is strongest. A live auction might be best for you where bidders can inspect the item “up close and personal.”
Post photos with your auction whenever possible; sellers report auctions with a photo get better prices.
Sell “certified” or authenticated items over the Internet to give your bidders some sense of safety. For example, there are independent third-party certification companies that will authenticate coins, stamps, baseball cards, comic books and autographs.
And, be willing to answer questions about your auction either through e-mails or over the telephone.
If you have doubts about how high a bid your item might bring, consider using a reserve or minimum bid requirement to protect your investment and from having a valuable item “lost” in an auction for pennies on the dollar.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
