Here is more evidence of a slowdown in numismatics: attendance and prices at the Michael Aron Rare Coins auction on May 20 in Van Nuys were both down.
First, an observation about the attendance: Instead of nearly all of the seats filled in the Masonic Hall (as they usually are), only about one-fifth of the seats were occupied. Ironically, it was one of Michael Aron’s largest auctions yet.
Second, about the prices. Many of the lots were sold “to the book,” meaning that they either didn’t meet a minimum selling price or were bought back by the consignors, or in some cases were sold to mail bidders. It’s hard to tell exactly what happened, but there were few bids from the floor.
What was obvious is that the prices at which some coins were sold were lower than what similar collectible coins were selling for just a few months ago.
In fact, at this auction, there were several coins up for sale that had been bought just a few months ago at Michael Aron’s last auction. In the case of these coins, the buyer from a few months ago decided to sell the coins now because he lost interest in them. The coins in question were “half cents” from the 1800s. The collector told several of the auction-goers that he had bought the six coins with a bid of $225 and he paid a 10 percent buyer’s premium on top of that. But at the auction, the same coins received a top bid of only $70.
In another case of coins coming back to auction quickly, an 1851 “large cent” that sold a few months ago at $75 was resold in Sunday’s auction fetching a top bid of only $20.
There are other cases of falling coin prices: several gem, uncirculated Morgan silver dollars from the late 1800s brought prices of only $62 each; these are coins that a year or two ago would typically sell for about $85 each.
Needless to say, there are several reasons for a selloff in the coin collecting business now: there is the threat of recession, the selloff in the stock market, and the worries of rising gasoline and energy prices. All of these factors impact non-essential spending which includes hobbies such as coins and stamps and art.
Internet news discussion groups have been buzzing with talk that the increase in gasoline pump prices could impact attendance at coin shows— keeping some collectors from hopping in the car to drive to distant shows.
Actually, the coin-collecting business still has not recovered to its glory days of 1980 when high inflation pushed gold to $875 an ounce and common date gem uncirculated Morgan silver dollars to $1,000 each— the same coins that sold at Michael Aron’s auction for $62 each.
Few of the coins in the Aron auction reached bids that were even close to the pre-auction estimates listed in the auction catalogue. Many coins reached only 75 percent of the auction estimates. And most coins sold at prices that were 10 to 15 percent of the “record high” prices that coins sold for in the 1980s.
For example, a 1936 commemorative half-dollar issued to honor the state of Wisconsin sold at the Aron auction for $160. The auction catalogue pointed out that a coin of this type and condition (grade) fetched $1,350 at the 1989-market peak. And a nickel from 1881 that was worth $3,200 in 1980 sold at the auction for only $330 - just 10 percent of its peak value.
My heart went out to the consignor of an 1889 Indian Head Cent who must have paid a “pretty penny” for his coin that is valued at $2,150 in some published price guides today, but only brought $310 at the auction.
The bottom line is to remember that coin collecting, stamp collecting and sports card collecting - any hobby for that matter - is risking business. “Buy it because you like it, not because you expect to make a profit,” is the best advice to follow.
On the other hand, you might say that some buyers got some pretty good bargains on Sunday, and saved a pretty penny on those pretty pennies, nickels, dimes and more.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
