Father's Day is coming up. What better gift can there be for Dad than a $3 bill?
No kidding. Up until the time around the Civil War, paper money was printed by various banks around the country, and some banks printed $3 bills. Today, these can be fine collectibles, and valuable ones too— since paper money is less likely to survive than coins.
Three-dollar bills were printed by institutions such as the Planters Bank of Georgia. The printing can be as interesting as the denomination. For example, Planters Bank obviously didn't want to spend too much money on its money, so its $3 were printed only on the front. If you look at the back, the lettering of the word "Three" will appear, but no illustrations or fine printing.
Three-dollar bills are just some of the paper money collectibles sold at the Moneyman Gallery at The Block, a new shopping mall in Orange. The gallery used to be in Newport Beach, and it has a unique method for marketing old money: Each note is framed in a special holder for maximum viewing pleasure.
The notes are first sealed in a container, then placed under special glass so light will not harm the paper (it may already be 140 years old). Then the frame has viewing glass in the front and back so both sides of the bill are visible when you hold the frame in your hand. The shop will frame single bills or entire sheets of 16, sold by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing.
A single, framed bill can cost $100, but expect to pay more for special notes that are preserved in better condition. Some of the better sellers include $3 bills from the Civil War era, at about $225 each; "Black Eagle" bills, named for the large black eagle on the front, at $205; and "horse blanket" notes from 1923— the last of the large-size bills— starting at $135.
Paper money tells a story, the same way postage stamps and coins do. But some of the stories with paper money are even better.
Take, for example, the Black Eagle bills, which are the only ones to carry the portraits of two presidents: Grant and Lincoln. They were printed in 1899 and are now 100 years old. Among paper money collectors, they are the closest thing to a "century" or "millennium note."
The currency last printed in 1923 is interesting because of its larger size— hence the name, horse blankets. They're big enough to cover a horse. It makes an interesting display to put a horse blanket note next to a contemporary note, so you can really see how your money has shrunk! You might want to mount a 1923 horse blanket bill next to a 1928 Monopoly bill— the name given to currency of 1928, with a back side resembling the money that comes with the Parker Brothers game.
In the past year, the collector value of certain paper money has increased about 20 percent because of its rarity and demand. Rarity is a major issue because, as Moneyman Gallery owner John Fitzgerald told me, "Paper didn't survive like metal, gold and silver."
Condition affects value as well. You should shop around to know what is meant by "fine," "very fine" and "crisp uncirculated" conditions.
There's a good reason why old bills were not salted away the way hordes of Morgan silver dollars were. A hundred years ago, consumers generally could not afford to hold on to a dollar bill or a $5 bill; therefore few were kept out of circulation.
With silver dollars, however, the U.S. Treasury did much of the safekeeping— which is why there are so many dollars from old hordes today.
1999 Susan B. Anthonys?
Right now, the U.S. Mint has no plans to make 1999 Susan B. Anthony dollar coins.
The mint intends to exhaust the stockpile of SBAs that have been sitting in vaults for nearly two decades, and once that stockpile is exhausted, it plans to start minting the new gold-colored dollar coins next year with a 2000 date.
But oh, the best laid plans! Now there is word that the stockpile of SBA dollars is being depleted faster than predicted, and the Mint may need to produce a small supply— 20 or 30 million or so— of the SBAs to fill the gap.
Many consumers shun SBA dollars because they can be confused for a quarter, resulting in a 75-cent loss. The U.S. Postal Service and some mass transit systems use SBA coins and distribute them in vending machines.
Coin dealers and speculators are betting that the mint will have to make 1999 SBA coins and of course, they will bear a 1999 date. But will they get into circulation? Don't bet on it, I'm told, as collectors and speculators will grab them and sock them away, hoping they will be a low-mintage collectible— and a valuable one at that.
Better still, if SBAs are made for general circulation, the mint might make special coins for collectors, called "proofs," which might also be minted in small quantities, making them instantly valuable among collectors.
Watch for developments.
Tuesday's dollar auction
Here's a follow up report on Tuesday night's silver dollar auction at Coins Plus in Newhall. To sum it up, prices were, in a word, "pricey."
"As many as 10 (rare coin) dealers showed up at the auction," store owner Jeff Butler said, and their bidding "pushed up prices for some of the key coins."
Among those, an 1889 dollar from the Carson City mint in extra fine condition sold for $1,150. Before the auction, Butler estimated it would sell for $850. An uncirculated 1892 dollar from Carson City sold for $725— more than twice the price Butler thought it would bring. A low-mintage , uncirculated 1894 dollar from the San Francisco mint sold for $525, which was about $175 more than the pre-auction estimate.
When the bidding was over, Butler said, dealers had purchased about two-thirds of the nearly 100 silver dollar lots.
"Collectors complained that others paid too much," said Butler. "But this shows the real prices in the market, especially for Carson City and key-date coins."
Butler said better-date coins were selling for more than catalogue value, and this also disappointed some customers.
He said the large number of dealers changed the range of typical bidding, as more of these dealers had "deep pockets.
It was a real "deep pocket crowd," he said of the 40 to 45 who attended the sale— about double the number of regular weekly auction-goers .
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the Money Reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. He is developing a new website at www.moredeals.com . His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays.
