Depending on what you collect, cleaning your collectibles can make them good, bad or even ugly.
The rules are different for all sorts of collectibles and for different hobbyists and investors.
Every few years, or decades, artists carefully restore the artwork adorning the walls and ceilings of medieval mansions and palaces. After 100 years, artists might work to restore artifacts such as the first flag of the United States. Skilled restorers have patched up the Declaration of Independence. Famous paintings have had a touch-up now and then. But never, never, never should rare coins be cleaned, polished or “restored.”
The coin-collecting hobby, when it comes to restoration, is far different from the collecting of antiques, art and even furniture. It is strictly forbidden to fix up rare coins. To do so, in the eyes and value guides of the hobby, is to destroy their value.
Only in the hobby of numismatics— coin collecting— does age help a coin’s value, and restoration to “ like-new ” condition only serves to destroy a coin’s value.
Three of the coin collecting industry’s leaders have published a free booklet laying out the rules about cleaning and conservation of coins. Knowing the rules of conservation is vital for anyone collecting— and certainly anyone interested in investing— in rare coins.
“The 12-page booklet, The Conservation Of Coins, is a direct result of Summit 2000, a two-day conference organized by the Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG) and the Industry Council for Tangible Assets (ICTA), and conducted in Scottsdale, Ariz., last December,” the industry leaders report.
“The booklet points out that numismatics is nearly the only field in which the ‘cleaning’ of objects is still perceived as taboo. However, restoration of art works, antique furniture and other items is viewed by the collecting and museum community as not only natural but quite desirable.”
Generally the industry believes that cleaning that removes tone, also tends to harm the finish of coins. Harsh cleaning that brightens a silver coin, for example, might also leave tiny marks on the surface of a coin. These marks are abrasions which in the future will cause a coin to show damage and lose its luster or reflectivity to light.
Some minor cleaning is allowed in the hobby. For instance, if you were to find chocolate syrup poured onto a 100-year-old silver dollar in your kitchen cabinet, it would be OK to gently wash the chocolate off the coin using warm water. But you would not want to scrub the chocolate off using a brush or cloth that would damage the coin’s surface.
Recently the hobby was ripped apart by a controversial “conservation” of gold coins that were salvaged from the ocean. The method involved removing sand that was encrusted on the gold coins. Some experts testified that the procedure never harmed the surface of the coins; critics complained that the coins were in fact “cleaned.”
If you purchase coins either for your collection or for an investment, you must be aware of the danger of purchasing cleaned coins. Coins might be cleaned to make them appear to be in better condition than they really are. Coins might even be polished to appear “new” or “uncirculated.” In reality, such coins have been damaged, and a trained eye can see signs of cleaning, abrasion and unnatural toning or color.
Some independent grading services will not certify coins (encapsulate them in plastic cases called “slabs”) if they have been cleaned. Other grading services might certify the coins but mark them as having been cleaned or altered.
The value of a cleaned coin and the value of a naturally “clean” coin can mean a difference of thousands of dollars in some cases.
Free copies of the booklet are available by writing to any of the following:
• Professional Numismatists Guild, 3950 Concordia Lane, Fallbrook, CA 92028.
• Industry Council for Tangible Assets, P.O. Box 1365, Severna Park, MD 21146.
• Independent Coin Grading Co., 7901 East Belleview Ave., Suite 50, Englewood, CO 80111.
• Numismatic Guaranty Corp. of America, P.O. Box 1776, Parsippany, NJ 07054.
• Professional Coin Grading Service, P.O. Box 9458, Newport Beach, CA 92658.
New Survivor cards
The Upper Deck trading-card company of Carlsbad has released its new edition of Survivor trading cards. These cards are used in a competitive game, and the card sets also feature some cards that have been autographed by some of the contestants of the “Survivor” TV show.
I just got a look at some samples of the Survivor cards for the Australian Outback game. While I never saw the TV show, and while I had no interest in the game, I found the cards interesting because they featured some “survival tips.”
Granted, you’ll never need these tips unless you’re out in the outback, but they are fun reading nonetheless.
Among the tips: “ She-oak leaves and apples can be chewed to quench thirst,” and “Australian snakes, except the taipan snake, are not predatory toward humans.”
There are nine cards per pack and they retail at about $3 a pack. I’m expecting to see the collectible “autograph” cards to show up on eBay any day now.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
