It’s everyone’s dream to go to a garage sale and find an old painting in a frame with a price tag of $1, and then after buying it discovering that under the painting in the old frame is another painting that turns out to be a multi-million dollar Rembrandt. That’s everyone’s dream.
Well, this past week on eBay— which some consider the world’s biggest online garage sale— some people were getting a glimpse of that “Rembrandt dream” with an auction in the category for U.S. silver dollars.
Someone posted, in that auction category, an “1804 Dollar” for sale with a starting bid of only $1.
If authentic, an 1804 U.S. silver dollar would be worth at least $1 million. So it’s no surprise that within only a couple of hours of the start in the seven-day auction, more than 35 bids were placed on the coin.
But then reality started to wave through the cyberspace auction: Was this an authentic 1804 U.S. silver dollar?
I asked Safe Harbor, the eBay consumer protection department, to investigate the authenticity of the coin. It declined, saying that was up to buyers and sellers to establish the authenticity of an item. Some eBay users said that made them angry— and eBay does have a responsibility to assure its auction customers of the authenticity of items.
E-mails were sent to the seller asking for authentication, even a scan or picture on the eBay web site to show the coin. Well, after a couple of days, scans of the coin were posted and the dream of a garage-sale million-dollar find evaporated. Within minutes, many of the bidders canceled their bids.
Some of the reasons for the cancellation were funny, and they certainly covered a wide range.
One bidder wrote, “I do not collect fake coins.” Another wrote, “Obvious fake.” Another wrote, “I only collect real counterfeits; is ‘copy’ scratched on it?” Copies of rare coins must carry the word “copy” on the coin in order to be sold legally.
Another bidder showed his sense of humor when he canceled his bid with the comment: “Thought coin was 1904 dollar. Already have 1804.” A 1904 silver dollar is worth about $20.
As of Friday, the mysterious “1804 dollar” on eBay had a high bid of $57— about $17 over what other “official copies” of 1804 dollars typically sell for. The auction ends late Sunday night.
I don’t know if the remaining bidders know that this 1804 dollar is a fake, or if they are holding out hope that it is a Rembrandt waiting to be discovered. It may just be that for less than $100, they are willing to take a gamble, even though it looks like a losing bet.
The bottom line is, unless you have money to throw away on a losing bet, stick with buying collectibles that you know are real, authentic and even guaranteed.
Of course, betting on an old picture in an old frame in a garage sale for a dollar is still fun.
More craziness with quarters
Prices exploded again for some of the new quarters being minted to honor the 50 states. In the past couple of months, prices have shot up for rolls of the new quarters in “uncirculated” condition. But now, prices are shooting up for special “proof” coins that were made for collectors out of silver.
The coins that are shooting up are the silver proofs that have been certified by the Professional Coin Grading Service of Newport Beach, and carry a “grade” of Proof 69 Deep Cameo, meaning they are near perfect. A perfect coin has a grade of 70.
Sets of the five 1999 proof quarters in PCGS PR69 DCAM (the shorthand for the certification and grade) shot up last week from $150 each to $256 in online auctions. Individual quarters from the set are selling for as much as $50 each in certain online sales.
Cameo Coins, a firm in Ohio, has been actively marketing these high-grade proof coins to collectors. Robert Abbey, president of the firm, says he now expects bigger dealers and telemarketers to start selling the coins.
“People are clamoring to get the product for a number of reasons,” Abbey said, “including curiosity, souvenirs, gifts, collectibles, and they want the product and price is not an issue.”
The coins are considered special because they take the normal proof coins issued by the U.S. Mint and grade and certify them. Not all coins attain the high grade of Proof 69, though some collectors say they see little difference between a proof 69 coin and one getting a lower grade of proof 68 or even proof 67. In reality, the differences are minute.
Check those golden dollars
Are you checking your Sacagawea golden dollars for that rare error? Two have been found with a major error, and there could be more. The error coins were struck with the front of the Washington quarter and the back of the golden dollar coin, on the blank or planchet for a golden dollar. Coin experts believe there are more— somewhere.
But until more are found, the “Sac” with the “George Face” may be the most valuable error coin ever found. We’ll know for certain in the next couple of weeks. There is now a one-week auction for one of the error coins on eBay. A second auction will be run next month by the Bowers & Merena auction house of Collectors Universe, based in Newport Beach.
I guess you could call this coin the first $1. 25-piece , because it has the basic features of a dollar plus the added 25-cents of Washington’s face.
By the way, news of the upcoming auction— by Internet and through live bids— helped the stock of Collectors Universe recover a bit on the Nasdaq Stock Market, where it is traded under the symbol CLCT.
Recently, the stock was hit hard by “insider selling” as company executives and others close to the firm sold stock on the open market. Many of the sales were linked to the end of a “holding period” after an initial public offering to outside investors. It seems that when the insiders could sell, they did.
The stock of CLCT dropped from a high of about $8 since its IPO, to a low of $2.50 in the past couple of weeks. The drop in price is not an encouraging sign for investors.
News of the upcoming auction sent the stock back up to $3.50, which was a nice gain for anyone buying shares at $2.50.
Most expensive error coin
As of now, the most expensive error coin minted by the United States is the 1943 penny in copper.
Yes, pennies are generally in copper, but in 1943, because of a shortage of copper for the war effort, steel was used instead for making cents. Somehow, some 18 pieces were struck with copper, the most valuable among them selling recently for $115,000.
If you have a 1943 cent that appears to be in copper, don’t buy a Mercedes and plan a European vacation until you have the coin checked out. There are many counterfeits and many “steelies” that were plated with copper.
One test you can perform at home is this: See if your copper cent is attracted to a magnet— and if it is, sorry, you have a copper-plated steel cent. If the cent does not stick, you could be rich.
Steel pennies from 1943 are worth about 15 cents in circulated condition, and they are worth a couple of dollars if in bright, uncirculated condition.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
