The crash of an Air France Concorde on Tuesday morning threatens the supersonic fleet and the concept of supersonic commercial planes.
Aviation disaster attorney Paul Hedlund of Baum Hedlund, Aristei, Guilford & Downey in West Los Angeles says the photographs of the fireball, before the plane crashed, point to catastrophic engine failure, with parts of the engine breaking apart and causing an explosion of fuel.
Hedlund says the blades inside the engine may have broken apart.
“If you lose a piece of those blades,” he told me, “any piece, the rotating assembly becomes unbalanced and disintegrates. Once that happens the fuel is flowing in... and then the fuel is just pouring in to a big tube.”
Hedlund said, “The entire assembly will probably disintegrate in a second.”
American companies never built commercial supersonic planes, although they wanted to; and they may never build them in the future because of the economics of making super-fast planes that are quiet and don’t pollute.
As noisy as our cities are today, the supersonic transports built 20 and 30 years ago are too noisy for us now. They also pollute too much. The reality is they may never be built again, or ever be allowed to fly over land.
Boeing, the world’s biggest plane maker, gave up on building a supersonic passenger jet more than 30 years ago after the U.S. Congress failed to pump money into the project for a Boeing supersonic plane that was dubbed the “2707.”
While Boeing is a leader in military aircraft, Boeing and the plane and technology companies of Japan, Canada, Britain and France and Russia failed to develop the technology to make supersonic planes that would meet environmental standards.
“The pollution and sound problems are not solvable,” a Boeing spokesman told me.
With this disaster, supersonic flying might be closer to ending than expanding.
The goal for airlines now is to have bigger planes that lower the cost of flying each passenger. So the next generation of planes will include the A3XX of Airbus, the European plane maker, that will carry 550 passengers— about 130 more than Boeing’s 747 jumbo jets carry now. Boeing has also rolled out a new 737-900 jet that will be the largest of the fleet of 737 aircraft that are the workhorses of the commercial airline industry.
Boeing is also considering a stretch version of its 747 jets to compete with the super-jumbo A3XX. But no airlines are considering super-fast . Super-big is the buzz word.
Boeing is also pushing its smaller 717 model because it believes there is a market for smaller planes for short-haul and mid-haul “targeted” routes.
The Concorde facts
Flying on the Concorde offers some of the best and worst of air travel.
The best includes speed and a flight at an altitude almost 11 miles high that lets you see the curvature of the earth below, and when you look up, you see black sky and stars even when it’s high noon on the ground below.
The worst part of air travel includes very small seats, tiny windows (to keep the plane’s air resistance low) and cramped aisles.
I know. I flew on the Concorde twice on test runs to the Miami International Airport in the early 1980s.
Some notes about the Concorde:
• There were 13 in service at British Airways and Air France before Tuesday’s Air France crash in Paris.
• Air France operated six of the supersonic planes. The first Air France Concorde went into service in March 1969. That’s 31 years ago.
• Daily Concorde service between Paris and New York started 23 years ago.
• The plane can reach speeds of 1,370 mph and cruise at 59,000 feet. It made the Paris-to-New York run in 3 hours, 45 minutes.
• The plane is unique for its flexible body, which actually stretches at supersonic speeds.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Tuesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
