Did you feel the earth move? It happened Wednesday night, July 11, 2001. No, it wasn’t an earthquake— it was the sale of a 1964 quarter that made the earth move. That 1964 quarter sold on eBay, the online auction site, for $537.50.
So that you understand why the earth moved, in numismatic ( coin-collecting ) terms, let me explain how significant the sale of a 1964-quarter for $537.50 is.
This quarter was one of millions minted out of 90-percent silver, but nothing like 1964 silver quarters you might have in a drawer or a jar. This particular coin was more than one out of a million minted that year— in fact, it was one out of tens of millions.
Ordinary 1964 quarters are worth about $1 today because of their silver content; some 1964 quarters that were preserved in “ like-new ” or “uncirculated” condition can be worth $10 each, or even $30 each. There are a few million 1964 quarters that were minted in “proof” condition, meaning they were made with polished dies on specially prepared blanks. Most of these “proof” 1964 quarters are worth a dollar or two each.
The 1964 quarter that went for $537.50 was a special “proof” coin; it was graded as “perfect” by the Professional Coin Grading Service of Newport Beach. PCGS assigned this quarter the grade of 70, on a scale of 1 to 70 with 70 being perfect.
Perfect means— perfect. Not a scratch, not a nick, not a flaw, and minted so well that all of the details of the coin— the hair, the eagle’s feathers, the lettering— is all perfect. To date, only twenty-eight 1964 proof quarters have been graded as “perfect.”
The $537.50 coin was one of those 28 perfect coins. But that’s not the end of the story.
You see, the real reason the earth moved was not that such a coin sold— they have sold on eBay before. The reason the earth moved was that the price for a coin like this had jumped so high, so quickly.
About a year ago, other proof-70 1964 Washington quarters typically changed hands for $125 to $150 each. But in the auction that concluded July 11, the final bid was more than three times the previous high price. What happened?
You can’t say it’s the wealth factor from Wall Street that spilled over into the coin market. Many coin dealers are reporting a softening of the market, and they say it’s because the sell-off in stocks has cut into disposable income for hobbies. The economic slowdown is also having an impact on rare coin prices.
So why did the 1964 proof-70 coin shoot up in value so high?
The seller of the coin, coin dealer Ed Mega, who operates under the eBay seller ID of “EdinMass” from his suburban Boston home, has several ideas.
First, he says, is “the increased interest in Washingtons from the State Quarter campaign.” As you know, this is the third year of the program to mint and circulate quarters honoring each of the 50 states. The U.S. Mint says the 50-State quarters are being collected by 100 million Americans, with many of those new collectors now expanding their interests to include older quarters as well as other coins.
Mega says there is another reason for the ground-moving price of the 1964 proof-70 : the explosion of interest in “collector Registry sets.”
The registry phenomenon
PCGS was the first to promote its Registry— a public announcement of the finest known sets and collections of coins. There are Registry sets for Indian cents, Morgan dollars, $10 Liberty gold coins and Jefferson nickels and of course Washington quarters. Mega believes that the expanding interest in Washington quarter collecting has also increased public interest in owning a “Registry Set,” a collection that would be recognized as the finest or among the finest ever assembled.
“I believed what we witnessed was classic eBay competition for a high-end coin,” Mega told me. He says competition to get the high-end coins that would make up a Registry Set is driving prices to new levels.
It’s not just PCGS that is promoting the Registry concept. Numismatic Guaranty Corp., which is the official grading company for the American Numismatic Association, has also started its own Registry and is inviting collectors to submit their coins for inclusion. Applications and information, including fees, are available at the NGC Web site, NGCCoin.com. PCGS has information about its Registry at its Web site, PCGS.com.
It makes sense that Registry competition will become a driving force in the world of numismatics, and it makes sense that when you combine Registry competition with the exposure made possible by the Internet, that a bidding frenzy for Registry-quality coins will develop.
In fact, several Web sites operated by coin dealers promote their ability to deal in and to sell “ Registry-quality coins.” Among the dealer Web sites are wondercoin.com and RICoins.com and DavidHall.com and IdealRareCoins.com.
There has always been competition among collectors for the best coins and the best sets and collections, but until the Internet came around this competition was played out at coin-club meetings or in parlors where a few collectors would meet. Now, the publication of Registry Sets on the Internet makes the competition open to all— and opens the frenzy and bidding to all.
The 1964 proof-70 coin is not the only example of a coin value that has shot up recently. The same night that the 1964 perfect quarter was sold for more than $500, a 1963 proof quarter that was nearly perfect, with a grade of 69 and with a “deep cameo” appearance, sold for more than $600. This very same coin had changed hands only a few weeks earlier for about $100— one-sixth of the auction price.
The NGC Registry has just started to accept listings; meanwhile PCGS has started to add new categories for more types of coin collections. The result will be the same: more interest, more demand, and likely higher prices for the best— the Registry coins.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
