Hold your hula hoops! Put the sleeve back on those Elvis 45s! Box up those Lionel trains! Pokéman cards may have pooped out as a collectible. That’s the observation of several Pokéman card dealers in the region.
At Perfect Game, in Saugus, retail prices have dropped. The new edition called Gym Heroes sells for $2.75 a pack. The Japanese packs of Pokéman cards sell for $6.50 now— and a year ago they sold for as much as $10.
The prices of single collectible cards have plunged. In many cases, the prices have dropped in half.
At Perfect Game, a holographic Zapdos— a yellow bird with a hologram on the card— is now priced at $7. A year ago it was $15. A Nine Tails card that was $12 a year ago is now $6.
Perfect Game used to have trading nights when the store was jammed with dozens of kids. Now, “maybe five kids show up,” the owners tell me. Some of the kids are now collecting “Magic Cards,” which are another type of collectible card.
“The kids are Poké man-ed out,” said Larry Peck of Super Kids in Encino. “The second movie has been out for awhile and kids are occupied with other things.”
Peck also sells The Razor, the hot aluminum scooter that kids are zipping around on these days.
“I get three to four kids a day coming in with Pokéman cards to sell to get money to buy the scooters. Interest has completely waned. But foreigners are still buying the Pokéman cards,” said Peck, who reports that his store is visited by tourists from Europe who are still on the hunt for Pokéman cards and collectibles.
There were two versions of the Pokéman cards, the American and Japanese versions. The Japanese version of the “Fossil” Series of Pokéman cards used to sell for $15 a pack, and now they are retailing for $4.99 a pack. Peck also reports that wholesale prices on these cards have plunged.
“The price for a box of 60 packs was $550, and now it’s readily available at $170 a box,” he said.
The American version has also dumped.
“I used to do $3,000 or $4,000 a day in Pokéman cards,” said Peck, “and now I’m doing barely $100 a week. The American version prices have dropped from a peak of $9 a pack for first-edition cards to $3.99 a pack.”
The resale market doesn’t exist, says Peck.
“It’s gone. The people who made millions are losing millions. The merchants I sold to in Europe are stuck, period.” The most sought-after card coming out of a pack was the Charizard ,which was “about $55 at its peak, and now it’s $15 in my store,” said Peck.
There were also “promo cards” that were made for certain events such as movies that once sold for $500 to $700 dollars each.
“One card distributed by ANA Airlines to passengers was once selling for $700 and now it’s about $75 to $100,” said Peck. “It was over-merchandised ,” he said. “People were spending a fortune, kids clamored and then interest waned— and all of a sudden the kids were finished and prices dumped.”
“Kids are coming in every day to sell their Pokéman cards,” Jeff Butler of Coins Plus in Newhall told me. Butler said he did not promote Pokéman cards during their “craze” because he doubted they would survive as a collectible.
Peck, meanwhile, has an active business selling The Razor and the other scooters that are popular.
“They are on fire,” he said, adding that he recently cut his selling price to $89.99, about $10 below the current retail price at many stores.
Will they go up in value in the future?
“Absolutely not,” he said, “because there are so many around. Everybody’s got them. The production is being increased all the time. They are absolutely not a collectible.”
Time is money
Watches and timepieces are time-honored collectibles, but it takes time to make these collectibles gain value.
For new watches, sold to the consumer market, watches are like new cars: They drop in value as soon as they leave the showroom.
If you’re looking for a future collectible, you want to buy a fine watch and keep it in pristine condition.
If you’re looking for a deal on a fine consumer watch to use (and not bury in a safe deposit box), then consider buying a resale watch.
The Valencia Time Center in the Valencia Town Center mall deals in used collectible watches. Breitling Chronomats that are just one year old are priced at $2,000— and these sold for $3,675 when new. Rolex Submariners that sold new for as much as $6,000 are priced at $4,700. Movado watches are priced at 30 percent below their original prices.
Not all old watches are collectible or valuable. We’ve all heard stories about old Mickey Mouse watches that are worth hundreds of dollars, but true collectible watches must be in great shape, and must be authentic: There are modern-day copies of many choice watch designs. Some flea markets are filled with knock-offs or copies.
On the eBay online auction site, a Movado watch with a retail value of about $1,200 failed to get even a starting bid of $375 after nine days of a 10-day auction.
“Nothing goes up right away,” warned Christopher Froian, owner of Valencia Time Center. “About two years ago the Rolex Submariner was selling for about $3,700 to $4,000 new, and they were not in great demand. Then Rolex restricted shipping, so instead of dealers getting 10 they would get one, and prices went through the roof.”
A new Rolex Submariner is now $6,025 in his shop. Froian expects another factory price hike in about a year.
Froian is paying from $4,000 to $5,000 each for used watches with the gold two-tone finish, and he’s paying $3,000 for the stainless steel models.
“Rolex is the hottest collectible watch on the market now,” he says, “because very few get them, they are in demand, and the factory controls the supply.”
Different-model Rolexes from 10 years ago have probably doubled in value now if they are in good shape, he said.
“If they paid $1,500 for a stainless steel Rolex 10 years ago, they can fetch anywhere from $2,500 to $3,000 now,” Froian said.
You see, time is money.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Tuesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
