Internet auction sites continue to grow both in size and in number. These days you can find an auction site to handle just about any transaction. There are even Internet sites that will scour all of the many auction sites on the Web to find the items you want to buy.
Unfortunately, with so many hundreds of thousands of items up for sale, some online sellers have exaggerated what they have for sale, and this really irks knowledgeable buyers.
Recently, on the Internet discussion group rec.collecting.coins, some Internet auction participants listed “things they hate” on Web auctions. These newsgroup members are savvy about numismatics and what they “hate” is when someone tries to pull the wool over their eyes or pass a “slider” (a coin that doesn’t meet the grade or condition that it is supposed to be) by them.
There is a message here: You can’t fool everybody, and if you get caught, you’re going to make somebody angry.
Here is the list of things people hate:
Auctions that begin with something like, “I will begin by telling you that I am not in the business of grading coins.”
What the heck is this? An excuse in advance for trying to sell an over-graded coin? Remember, condition counts a lot towards the value of a coin. For example, a 1960 Washington quarter that is graded as a “gem uncirculated” coin could be worth double what an “uncirculated” coin might be.
Terms such as “estate sale” and “unsearched and original” bank roll are considered to be danger signs for experienced collectors. In the world of numismatics, nothing is “unsearched,” and nothing enters an estate sale without first being checked out by experienced dealers.
Another complaint is about “the words ‘rare’ or ‘scarce’ in the title (when) the coins are really common.”
If you don’t know that an item is rare or scarce, don’t try to pass it off as rare or scarce— that will only anger knowledgeable auction participants. It will also anger new collectors who will be mightily disappointed when they found out they paid a pretty penny for a coin or some other collectible that is not really rare at all.
Experienced auction participants also “hate” auctions that have starting bids (prices) that are in excess of regular retail prices. People go online hoping to get a bargain and not be soaked. The experienced collectors will avoid anything that’s ridiculously priced— they’ll simply wait until a similar item comes up in another auction.
If you, the seller, do not want to part with something unless it reaches a certain minimum bid, then use a “reserve price.”
Don’t advertise that your item is being sold by an IRS trustee or “upon the authority” of the FBI, CIA or justice department. Who are you kidding?
A warning to shill bidders
The Internet discussion groups are still on the hunt for shill bidders, and there is no mercy if they discover that you (the seller) have a second Internet i.d. to increase the bids on your item.
There are various clues of shill bidding. One clue is that the same buyer shows up exclusively in one seller’s auctions. Another clue is that a buyer gets a bid in, minutes after an item is first posted for sale, even though the Web site’s auction index of listings will not show that new auction for hours.
Another clue is that a buyer who shows up as a bidder in one seller’s auctions never ends up as the winner of an auction.
While these clues might indicate a shill, even eBay, the online auction giant, points out that such coincidences are not proof of shill bidding.
The stars of the red-hot coin market
Thanks to the popularity of the new 50-State quarters and the new Sacagawea golden dollar, the coin collecting hobby is red hot again. Many collectors are upgrading and expanding their interests to rare and pricey coins.
If you have an interest in buying the “stars” of the red-hot coin market— the coins that might have the greatest collector interest and the best potential for profit— take a look at a list from David Hall of Collectors Universe in Newport Beach. Hall suggests that these are some of the coins that are proven winners:
Morgan and Peace silver dollars that grade “ mint-state 65” or better. These are coins in uncirculated condition that have very few detracting marks and outstanding strikes, luster and toning.
Unfortunately, for new collectors, it is hard to know what is the difference between an MS-65 coin and an MS-64 coin— but the difference can be, in some cases, thousands of dollars.
Hall also likes pre-1934 U.S. gold coins, again with grades of MS-65 or better. A perfect coin with no damage would grade 70, while an uncirculated coin with some scratches from normal bank handling might grade only a 60 (the minimum for an uncirculated coin).
If you don’t know how to grade coins based on the scale of 1 to 70, don’t try to buy coins based on their grade or condition. Instead, invest time and money in a book about grading coins, and perhaps limit your buying and investing to coins that are graded by professional graders.
Both the Professional Coin Grading Service and the Numismatic Guaranty Corp. are well regarded for properly grading coins, then encapsulating them in tamper-proof plastic “slabs” or holders to protect their authenticity. But be careful with buying so-called “certified coins” because there are many grading services, and experts know that they have different standards that can mislead buyers.
The 2000 Roosevelt dime
The next time you get a Roosevelt dime dated 2000, give it a close look, and then compare it to a dime from 1999 or earlier. You’ll see several differences, including a smaller portrait of FDR and more “room” between the artwork on the coin and the outside rim.
These are not mistakes, but deliberate changes in the look and design of the coin to help it wear better after years in circulation.
The 2000 Lincoln cents were also changed slightly to show more detail in Lincoln’s portrait and more creases and lines in his suit jacket, and more detail in his hair.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Tuesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
