If you recycle your beer cans for three cents each, or even a nickel each, you might be— as the recycling commercial says— throwing it all away. Because some beer cans can be worth big bucks. Very big bucks. Just ask Bob Davis of Valencia, who is a card-carrying member of the Beer Can Collectors of America. No kidding.
“It all started when I drank beer in college,” Davis said.
He has outgrown putting cans of Bud, Schlitz and Coors on his bookcases. Now he treasures his cans of Esslinger from the 1930s, which can be worth as much as several hundred dollars each. And that’s without the beer.
Davis says some Esslinger beer cans in high-grade condition, without rust or dings or dents, can be worth as much as several thousand dollars.
“Some of the most collectible beer cans now are Rosalie. One of these cans sold on eBay for about $10,500,” he said. “It is the Mona Lisa of beer cans.”
Other collectible brew containers are Clipper Ale, Gold Age and several of the small breweries from the early days, he says. The early days go back to 1935 when beer was first put into cans.
Davis has these tips for beer can collectors:
First, decide what you can afford. “You can go out and get a 50-year-old can for five bucks if condition doesn’t matter much to you,” he said, “but if you want a pristine can, be prepared to pay a barrel-full . A pristine example of a non-mass-produced small brewery can could cost hundreds or even thousands.”
Second, decide what you want to collect. Davis specializes in “cone top” beer cans, which are cans produced from 1935 to about 1955 and are shaped like oil cans. Other can shapes include the regular flat top, quart size, and other cans in various sizes.
Third, decide on a sub-category , such as a particular brewery or regional breweries. There are breweries from upstate New York, and breweries from Pennsylvania, and even collectible cans from breweries in Southern California.
“What got me interested in Esslinger is that it’s from Philadelphia,” Davis said. “I’m from near there and it has the coolest logo.” The logo, or symbol of the brewery, is a cartoon waiter carrying a tray of beer.
Other collectible beer cans include instructions for how to use a beer-can opener. “Cans with instructions give you a hint of the age of the can,” Davis said.
During World War II all the cans were made in military green so they could be shipped to troops in the field.
“They have the company logos, but the drab green is cool,” Davis said.
But Davis also cautions that some so-called collectible cans aren’t worth much if anything now.
“Billy Beer,” named after President Carter’s brother, and “JR Beer,” after J.R. Ewing of the TV show “Dallas,” can be bought by the case now, Davis said, and for pennies per can.
“There are just too many of them, because everybody hoarded them for the celebrity status. That’s why they’re not worth anything now.”
How to check prices
It’s not too difficult to check some beer can prices, if you know where to look. Start with the eBay online auction site. Recently, eBay had listed 700 items for sale in its category called “Collectibles, Breweriana, Cans.” One seller had a beer can collection with more than 2000 cans up for auction, and there were 27 bids after five days of bidding. The top bid on that auction, with five days to go, was at $250. But the auction indicated that the reserve price had not yet been reached.
Flea markets and antique shows are also good ways to check the value of your cans.
There are also clubs to belong to and collector price guides available at some bookstores.
There are also individual Web sites that provide information, such as Breweriana.com and LarwoodLimited.com. And you can also contact such groups as the American Breweriana Association at Post Office Box 11157, Pueblo, Colo., 81001.
The Beer Can Collectors of America has a Web site at www.bcca.com .
Modern cans
“Today’s modern cans are not worth the metal they’re made with,” said Davis. “Collectors want hard, uncrushable steel cans, the ones they used before World War II, when beer was beer and men were men nd ‘light beer’ was something hanging in a bar.”
Sometimes special “collector edition” cans are issued to commemorate a team winning a championship, “but even these are in such mass quantities they probably won’t go up in value,” he said.
By the way, Davis still drinks an occasional beer, but never out of the old cans.
“They’re too valuable. And maybe too rusty,” he said.
Davis also points out that beer cans are the ultimate in “one man’s trash being another man’s treasure.” It was a collectible that was never meant to be: They were supposed to be trashed or recycled.
“Thank God they didn’t have cash-back recycling during the Great Depression,” Davis said.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Tuesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
