Twenty-one-year-old Erika Selenak got the shock of her young credit life the other day, when a used car salesman talked her into a catastrophe. It wasn’t the used car she bought— it was the loan she signed for to buy the used car.
The catastrophe was the interest rate she had agreed to— “29.9 percent,” she told me.
At first, she though she had snagged a deal, “because the salesman told me some buyers pay 35 percent,” she said.
While 30 percent is a lot less than 35 percent, and a lot less than the 36 percent that some used car dealers can charge, 29.9 percent is no deal.
Many car dealers, including dealers along Valencia’s “Auto Row” on Creekside, say used car loan rates rarely go higher than 21 percent, even for consumers with a bankruptcy or other severe credit problems. Without such problems, used car loans can even fall into the single digits.
Erika says she was “pressured” into accepting the 29.9 percent because she lacked a credit history, and didn’t know better. Fact is, had she shopped with another car dealer just across the street from the dealership where she bought her car, she would have found that the top rate— even for consumers with credit problems— was 21 percent.
There could be many other consumers like Erika out there, because these days there is little state regulation to protect them. The state’s so-called “usury law” no longer exists, and credit interest rates are all over the road.
The belief that interest rates cannot top 25 percent is a myth, says Herschel Elkins, senior deputy attorney general for consumer affairs. And now that the Federal Reserve has started to raise interest rates, unknowing consumers might be led into believing that much higher rates are normal. They are not.
Consumers should still look for interest rates in the range of 9 percent to 21 percent, according to various used car dealers. But consumers also should not make the mistake of making the interest rate their primary concern when buying a car. The first priority should always be the car itself— check it with your own mechanic for reliability, or be sure it has a warranty and the dealer has a reputation for standing behind that warranty. The next priority should be the price of the car; it does you little good to have a low interest rate on a car that is overpriced. Then comes the interest rate— and that is negotiable, just as the price of the car is negotiable. Shopping around pays.
A lack of shopping around will be a costly lesson for Erika, because after the payments at 29.9 percent are finished, she will have paid double what the sticker price was on the 1993 model car she bought.
Meanwhile, new car buyers might find that dealers have some extra incentive to make a deal now.
Because the Federal Reserve has raised interest rates for a second time, the prime lending rate and other business loan rates have increased, and many car dealers are finding their costs are rising. Most dealers finance the cars on their lots and in their showrooms, and they pay what the industry calls a “flooring” interest rate. With the Fed raising short term rates by one-half percent, the cost of financing those cars has climbed by one-half percent also, giving dealers an extra incentive to make a deal to get the car and its loan off their hands.
Plans to lower auto insurance
Here in California, and nationwide, there have been several unique plans for making auto insurance more affordable and to cut down the high number of uninsured drivers on our roads.
By some estimates, 40 percent of the drivers in California are driving without insurance. In some zip codes, such as 90044 (which is in South-Central Los Angeles), 68 percent of the drivers who live there are said to be uninsured.
Harvey Rosenfield, the consumer advocate who authored Prop 103 to cut auto insurance rates, has been stymied in his efforts to get meaningful reductions in auto insurance in the state, and to have some sort of low-cost policy offered to get more drivers insured.
Now, he is continuing his fight with a new plan that would force the state’s insurance companies to offer low-income drivers with a good record a low-cost policy that would offer basic insurance for as little as $400 a year.
In parts of the state, including the 90044 zip code, the cost for that kind of basic policy can exceed $1,200 a year.
Rosenfield and other consumer advocates say that if the insurance companies go along with the plan, they, and other insured drivers, will save money in the long run. Rosenfield argues that having more drivers even with just basic coverage will lower the incidence of uninsured drivers and will mean lower “uninsured motorists” costs for everyone.
Some state legislators and insurance industry leaders are not convinced. They oppose the measure, saying it would force them to sell insurance that is priced too cheaply.
Meanwhile, another “universal auto insurance plan” seems to have hit a dead end. Under the universal plan, every driver would be covered by a basic policy, with the cost of that basic policy financed by a special tax on each gallon of gasoline.
By one estimate, the special tax would be 5 cents a gallon, and even out-of-state drivers would be covered under the assumption that they would buy gas at least once while in California. Under the plan, you would still have the right to buy additional insurance (as you do now) from your regular insurance company.
The pay-at-the-pump universal plan made sense for low-income drivers because it would actually reflect the number of miles driven. Those who drove more and bought more gas would pay more for insurance, while those who drove little and bought little gas would pay less.
The pay-at-the-pump plan would also eliminate the problem of uninsured drivers— totally.
Too bad it never made it to the California Legislature’s on-ramp or to Washington’s congressional on-ramp . It really was a simple solution to part of a complex problem.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the Money Reporter for KCAL-TV and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
