Even if you collect coins or stamps “just for the fun of it,” at some point you’re going to want to know how much your collection is worth.
There are different sources for prices and values, but unfortunately, each source is likely to have a different price or a different value. This is mainly because there is no central marketplace for collectibles, unlike the stock market which has “universal prices” that can be checked on exchanges anywhere in the world.
In reality, any coin or stamp or trading card could have a different value depending on where it is up for sale. For example, Dan Marino football-trading cards are likely to have a higher value in Miami, the hometown of Marino’s Dolphins football team, than they would in Los Angeles. This is logical, since Los Angeles may not be populated by Dolphins fans and in fact doesn’t seem to have enough fans even to have a pro football team.
There are also different price guides, some published by companies that buy and sell collectibles. These can have a “slanted look” at buy and sell prices. There are also magazines that survey dealers, shows and collectors. Then there are the Web sites.
The bottom line for any collector is not to rush to judgment on a price when buying or selling, but to survey the market carefully and know the true value before entering into a transaction.
New Scott catalogue
There are certain guides that can be your “first look” at values. In the U.S. stamp market, that first look is the Scott Catalogue.
The new 2001 edition of the “Scott Specialized Catalogue of U.S. Stamps” has just been released, and the publishers report that more than 15,500 value changes were recorded. The publishers also report, “The market for good-quality U.S. stamps continues to roar and the trend has started to branch out into many areas that were previously napping.”
The new catalogue lists different varieties of “gums” used on the back of stamps. The catalogue now lists, in addition to “dull gum” and “shiny gum,” a new “ low-gloss gum.”
I know what you’re thinking— you never knew collectors cared about such things.
Alphabet stamps rise
Every few years, whenever the Postal Service hikes stamp prices, there is a short period of time when “alphabet stamps” are sold to the public while the new-value stamps are printed.
Back in 1994, a “G” stamp was issued. Well, if you happen to have saved a block of “G” stamps with the plate printing number in the margin (a plate block) your stamps would be worth $75 now. The new Scott catalogue raised that value from $35 a year ago.
The new Scott Catalogue is $38.
A coin pricing service
Heritage Rare Coin Galleries of Dallas is offering a free Internet system for getting rare-coin values and for storing an inventory of your coin collection. The “My Collection” listing and pricing service is available through www.HeritageCoin.com .
“My Collection lets numismatists quickly set up a password-protected , private record of what they own, buy or sell, and tracks the current market value of the collection,” says the company.
“The prices are based on actual trading ranges from Heritage’s massive database. My Collection also includes instant access to a database of Heritage auction records so collectors can observe the history of their coins’ values for the past 10 years,” said Paul Minshull, Heritage’s chief operating officer.
Condition counts
You must use caution whenever you try to price or value your collection. In the industry of coins, stamps and trading cards— just like in antique furniture and crafts— condition counts. There may be a fine difference between a coin that is graded “gem uncirculated” or “choice uncirculated,” but the difference between those two grades could mean hundreds or even thousands of dollars for certain coins.
In the trading-card industry, collectors place certain values on the condition of corners, the width of borders, the vibrancy of colors in the printing, and whether or not a stick of gum left an impression or some residue on a card.
With stamps, condition is more than whether a stamp was used, but what condition the perforations are in.
And now you might have to know a new factor: Was that “low gloss gum” on the back?
Bush, Gore newspaper headlines
You may have heard political commentators talking about early editions of newspapers that reported the wrong “winner” in the presidential election, and newspaper editions that had to be pulled from newsstands because of the changing vote count.
Be careful about buying such papers as “collectibles.” They might be collectible but they might never be “valuable” because too many copies may be in the hands of collectors and speculators now.
Remember, rarity as well as novelty and demand are the factors that make a collectible “valuable.” If everyone saves “wrong headline” newspapers, the odds are they will never be worth much.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Tuesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com .
