I know, the expression is really “one thin dime.” But I am really talking about thin quarters.
It seems that from time to time, workers at the U.S. Mint make quarters out of the metal that is supposed to be used for dimes. These quarters on what is called “dime stock” can be worth $100 or more each.
In 1970 many of these thin quarters were accidentally made, but so many are in existence that they are worth only about $35 each now. Still, not bad for a finding the right thin quarter.
Now, it appears that some of the new Statehood quarters may have been made with dime stock and these coins could be worth substantially more than their 1970 quarter-on-dime-stock cousins.
What is this dime stock? Let me explain.
The blanks or planchets used to make dimes and quarters and half dollars are punched out of huge sheets of metal. Each sheet of metal has a certain width to it, which is why dimes are thinner than quarters and quarters are thinner than half dollars.
If the mint worker picks up the wrong sheet of metal to be used for cutting out the blanks or planchets, then the quarters (or dimes or halves) can be made out of the “wrong stock.”
So the bottom line is to check your coins before you spend them. If you have a thin quarter or a thick dime you might have some big money in the palm of your hand.
However, before you run out for a shopping spree because you think you just found a valuable thin quarter, beware there are “counterfeit” or altered coins.
It seems that some “cheats” have dipped coins in acid, to allow the acid the eat away at the coins to make them thinner.
With the possibility of selling a thin coin for a hundred dollars or more, I guess it pays for these crooks to risk the danger of dipping a coin in acid. Don’t you do it; it’s not only dangerous but experience coin dealers can tell when a coin has been treated with acid.
There are things to look for to be sure you don’t have an acid-treated thin coin. Coin dealer Fred Weinberg is an expert on the subject of error coins. He operates a Web site at fredweinberg.com and I urge you to check it out to learn more.
Some of the diagnostics used to check a thin coin for authenticity are:
• First, check the size. Acid treated coins can shrink in diameter as well as width, and placed on top of an authentic coin, the acid-treated coin will have a smaller circumference.
• Check the strike. Acid treated coins will not have the sharp details that you would expect to see on an authentic coin.
• Check the surfaces. Acid treated coins can be damaged if the acid is not applied properly. But “well treated” coins will have normal appearing surfaces, so clever and skillful con artists could pass an acid-treated coin.
• The weight is also a primary test. Coins struck on the wrong “stock” will have a specific weight based on the stock used.
Con artists have been altering coins for years in an attempt to cheat collectors. One of the most common alterations is cutting two coins apart, and putting the parts together to create a two-headed or a two-tailed coin. Sometimes these coins are manufactured for trick coins used by magicians. Sometimes these “magic” coins are accidentally spent and are “discovered” by unsuspecting consumers.
Let me mention, however, that one two-headed Indian Head Cent from the 1800’s has been authenticated as “mint made,” and one two-tailed Washington quarter from the 1960’s has been authenticated as “mint made.” So, don’t dismiss every two-headed or two-tailed coin as a forgery; but at the same time don’t jump for joy that you found a windfall. You must have the coin checked first.
The Statehood quarter series, as you recall, has been rich with “mint errors” including coins that were made with “rotated dies” so that the front and back of the coin both face the same way (they should be reversed). Other errors include die cracks (lines showing up in the coin), and coins that were minted off-center .
If you have any of these errors you should know that values will vary with the degree of the error. Always get several opinions from coin dealers before selling; never sell on the first offer no matter how attractive that amount of money might be.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
