The U.S. Mint has a best seller— actually, five best sellers so far. They are the new quarters honoring the 50 states. They are perhaps the most collected “two bits” pieces ever.
The first five have been released in the mint’s 10-year program. So far, the mint is estimating that 106 million Americans, children and adults, are “actively collecting the 50 state quarters from pocket change.”
Mint Director Philip Diehl says that “in the months ahead, we expect the number of state quarter collectors to reach 160 million.”
The demand for the new quarters is so great that coin dealers report few are actually getting into circulation, and those that do get into circulation quickly are snapped up and taken out. This has created a brisk business for the coin dealers and for sellers of rolls and even bags of the new quarters on Internet auction sites such as eBay.
Coin dealer Jeff Butler admits to paying about 70 cents for some of the quarters honoring Delaware when they were released at the start of 1999. Recently, however, he has not had to pay a premium and has obtained bags of the new coins from the mint and from local banks, including Bank of America.
BofA says it has had a policy of stocking the new quarters for its regular customers.
On eBay, bags of the new quarters have been selling at a substantial premium, with dozens of bids registered for some of the auction lots.
Take, for example, eBay auction #193129429 for a mint-sewn bag of Delaware quarters from the Denver mint. The bag contains 4,000 coins for a face value of $1,000. After only two days of an auction scheduled to last 10 days, the bidding was already up to $1,475. Why?
What makes the coins pricey is that they are still in mint bags— still sewn shut and unexamined by the public for errors.
Errors. That’s the big word in the new state quarters program, because some of the errors being reported can turn a 25-cent piece into a disc worth several hundred dollars.
The mint is stamping out the new quarters at record pace. In fact, the pace has just doubled— and that has resulted in more cracked dies, more mis-stamped coins, and even coins with one side stamped upside-down .
While there might be error coins in the mint-sewn bags— it’s really a gamble— some collectors and speculators are willing to pay big premiums just for the chance to go through the coins one by one.
Don’t have a $1,000 or more to gamble with? Don’t worry. The mint is also selling mini bags with 100 coins of each new quarter. However, the bags are quickly selling out, and they are rapidly skyrocketing in price in the auctions and in the aftermarket.
Take, for example, a $25 face value bag of Connecticut quarters that was on eBay this week. In less than a week of bidding, its price doubled— a 100 percent return. Again, it was the error fever that got the price up so quickly.
Keep in mind that finding an error coin is a long shot, and most errors are so minor that the coin might not be worth more than $1.
Among the minor errors are coins minted with “cracked dies.” These coins will show lines running from the rim to the inside of the coin. It takes patience, good eyes or a magnifying glass to find these.
The major errors are easier to see: things like coins that were struck off-center or coins with filled dies so that numerals in the date are missing.
If you happen to get an original mint-sewn bag from a bank, at no premium, you have nothing to lose but your time as you search for errors. After all, a quarter is a quarter, and you can always spend any quarter that is “normal” and shows no flaw.
And what about the normal quarters? Will they go up in price? Chances are, no.
Just look at the last “commemorative” quarters minted by the U.S. — the Bicentennial quarters of 1976. These coins feature a drummer boy on the reverse and are dated 1776-1976 . They pop up in pocket change from time to time, and that’s where they belong— in pocket change. They are worth 25 cents in circulated condition.
The new 50-State quarters meant for circulation are also likely to be worth only 25 cents each in the future because so many millions are being made.
But if so many millions are being made, why aren’t they circulating freely?
Well, says the mint, that’s because Southern California has to wait a bit longer than the rest of the country for its shipments of new quarters. We have to wait because this side of the country is flush with older quarters, in part because so many quarters enter the banking system through the Las Vegas casinos.
In fact, the Federal Reserve Bank in San Francisco says it is still shipping quarters minted before 1999 to local banks (although the new 50-States quarters are shipped to banks on request).
If you’re not getting the new quarters in your pocket change, it’s not because they are in short supply. It’s because we have so many of the older quarters.
That’s my two bits’ worth this week.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
