This holiday season, collectors have numerous choices for auctions— ranging from a variety of online auctions to traditional live auctions, to a few “bid board” or “silent auctions.”
The online, or Internet, auctions seem to be showing the most growth, but they don’t necessarily offer the best deals because they attract a bigger “universe” of possible bidders. In fact, there are auction sites with names such as Coin-Universe.com that scare you into thinking you could be bidding against collectors across the whole galaxy for that one Indian Head cent you need to finish your collection!
There’s an old saying in the auction business: The best auction to attend is the one in a blinding snow storm that no one else can attend. The Internet has made it possible for everyone to attend an auction, no matter how bad the weather.
Live auctions— the ones you attend in person— give you several other benefits, including the opportunity to “read” the pitch of the bidding among other bidders, and the opportunity when to know the “final bid” and the “last chance” to bid have arrived. With Internet auctions, however, there may be a “closing time,” but you don’t know if another bidder is about to click a higher bid or if another bidder has already established a higher bid with a “bidding robot” or some other automatic bidding system.
Newhall coin dealer Jeff Butler says there are even more benefits to attending a live auction.
“With a live auction or a bid board, the customer also has the opportunity to view the lot up close and personal, and not just a scan or picture,” said Butler, owner of Coins Plus on Lyons Avenue.
Butler’s annual “Year End Open Bid Board” starts Wednesday, Dec. 1, and closes Tuesday evening, Dec. 14. Butler says his bid board, which operates as a “silent auction,” offers coin collectors several advantages.
“First, you get to see the coins,” he said. Each coin is displayed with a bidding card next to it for auction-goers to enter their bids. Bidders also get to view the actual bidding history, so there are no surprises, and bidders can see the increments as they happen.
Coins Plus’ auction is also a local auction, and while it might attract bidders from around the Southern California area, bidders don’t have to fear deep-pocket bidders from Europe or Asia coming in to blow out lots at Sotheby-type prices.
“The bids we get are usually closer to wholesale than retail prices,” said Butler.
The big “Year End Bid Board Auction” is something Butler plans for all year. (He also hosts weekly bid board auctions, where participants can buy and sell their own coins and sports cards.) There will be about 600 rare and collectible coins on the year-end board, ranging from ancient coins from around A.D. 200 to the brand-new 50-State quarters in proof condition made especially for collectors.
The year-end board is also a “no reserve” auction, meaning all lots start with a minimum of 10 cents, but in all likelihood, many of these coins will at least come close to “fair value” in the end.
Among the lots in the auction are Morgan silver dollars from the Carson City, Nevada mint, which are always popular among collectors.
“I have an 1882 Carson City dollar that was originally sold by the General Services Administration back in the 1970s,” Butler said. “At its peak it was worth about $150 and later dropped to $45. I think it’s worth about $80 now.” The coin is in uncirculated condition.
“There is a large selection of ‘horse blanket’ currency,” said Butler. These are the old banknotes that were nicknamed “horseblankets” because of their large size. They were last printed in 1923.
“This ( large-size ) $1 silver certificate from the series of 1923 will probably sell for $40 to $50,” he said.
Even if you don’t bid at this auction, it’s interesting and educational to look at the lots and watch the bidding as it continues over the two-week period. It will give you a good idea about what your own collectibles are worth and might fetch in a sale.
The auction also features a large selection of U.S. gold coins, including $5 and $10 Liberty pieces, as well as copper coins including Indian Head cents in uncirculated condition and obsolete coins such as 2-cent pieces, half-cent pieces, and even 3-cent pieces.
You can see all these coins “up close and personal” at the bid board— something you just can’t do in an Internet auction.
Butler’s auction will also feature some “fractional currency” — paper bills that were denominated as 10 cents, 15 cents and 25 cents. They were printed when the cost of coins was too expensive for the government.
“Most of these are from the Civil War era,” Butler explained, adding that some could sell for as little as $7 each. Once again, you can see them “up close and personal” — and bid on them, too.
The bid board also offers an education to new collectors. Butler is often asked what makes a coin a “proof” or “uncirculated” or a “cameo” or a “doubled die.”
“There are lots of proofs,” Butler said, “which are coins that are issued for collectors by the mint that are struck with a polished die— twice— on special blanks or planchets that are chosen for their high quality.”
There will also be some surprises on the bid board.
One of the lots is a proof set from 1959 that has remained sealed in its government-issued envelope since it was mailed from the mint 40 years ago.
“The attraction of this lot is that no one really knows what special traits this proof set might have. There could be ‘cameo coins’ inside, which bring a much higher premium in the market,” Butler said.
The set will be sold in its sealed envelope. A regular 1959 proof set might be worth as little as $15, Butler explained, but one with a cameo half-dollar or a “deep cameo” half-dollar , and other cameo coins, could be worth thousands of dollars.
Cameo coins are usually some of the first that are stuck with a set of dies at the mint and show deep mirrors and frosted portraits and lettering and numbers. They are extremely rare.
“Oh gosh, I don’t know,” Butler said. “This could sell for $25, and I’m hoping the winner will open it right there so we can all see.”
While the set in the envelope could contain cameo proofs, it also could contain spotted, discolored or “impaired” proofs— which could be worth a lot less than $15. It will be one of the gambles of the auction. And again, it’s something you will never be able to experience over the Internet.
Coins Plus is located at 23332 Lyons Ave. To bid in the auction, you must register in advance. There is no fee to sign up.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
