One of the biggest online auction houses for collectibles— Heritage— has just announced some big changes for its auction operations including a policy for returns, new fees, and a very significant change in how bidding will end for its auctions.
Anyone who has ever bid in an Internet auction, whether it’s on eBay or BidBay or Yahoo! or any other company, should be aware of these changes and the impact they might have on other companies and their auction operations.
The most significant changes are being applied to when the auctions end. Most auction companies used a “fixed time” to end an auction. This “fixed time” allows for “sniping” — the entering of a last-second bid that does not give other bidders a chance to rethink their top bid and to enter a new offer. Heritage is now extending the ending time for auctions to allow existing bidders time to enter a new, revised, higher bid. In effect, Heritage is eliminating “sniping.”
Here is more of Heritage’s news release about its changes:
First, Heritage is announcing a policy for returns of items bought in its auctions. “Unconditionally allowing returns with no questions asked is a major departure from industry standards, but is designed to benefit both our bidders and consignors,” said Heritage Co-chairman Jim Halperin.
“HeritageCoin.com has enjoyed unmatched growth and success based on the quality of our offerings and our superb full-color images online. Still, bidders know that not being able to personally examine the lots carries a small degree of risk. Our new policy removes all risk of getting stuck with an unwanted item, which means our 40,000 registered Internet bidders will feel even more confident bidding higher prices. This represents a very real effort on our part to raise consumer confidence and provide improved service.”
Many independent online auction sites, including eBay, allow individual sellers to set their own rules on returns. Heritage, while it might act as an agent for consignors, also sells its own inventory online.
HeritageCoin.com customers will now be able to return lots bid on via the Internet, mail, phone or fax for any reason for just an 8-percent return/handling fee (minimum $10), in the following auctions: Exclusively Internet; Amazing Comics Auctions; CurrencyAuction.com; and Bullet Auctions.
Unfortunately, the fee Heritage is charging on returns very much acts as a “restocking fee” and might result in buyers holding on to lots they are not happy with if, perhaps, the 8-percent fee is more than the value of their dissatisfaction.
For example, say you bought a coin that you believe is not worth the $100 bid you made, but because of toning or wear is only worth $95. Faced with the 8-percent return fee, you might hold on to the coin anyway and swallow the $5 loss rather than an $8 loss from the return fee.
It should be pointed out that some online auction sites operated by direct sellers have no-cost returns.
Heritage is also adding some fees for buyers. “Also effective after Jan. 1,” said Bob Korver, director of Heritage Numismatic Auctions, “Heritage will be implementing a 15-percent buyer’s premium in our Exclusively Internet, CurrencyAuction.com and Amazing Comics Auctions. This change will make the 15-percent buyers premium uniform across all of Heritage’s different auctions, so bidders will no longer be confused about terms as they move from auction to auction looking for material.”
Adding fees is rarely good for the consumer, though it might help Heritage lower fees for sellers. However, Heritage is not making any announcement here about cutting fees for sellers (consignors). The 15-percent buyers fee might actually depress prices for some collectibles, because bidders will now have to factor in the auction fee when they place their bids.
In some states, the sales commission (fee) is also figured as part of the final sales price which is subject to the sales tax. This is the case in California; for example, buyers will pay the sales tax (typically 8 percent) on top of the 15-percent buyers fee. So the bottom line is that the 15-percent buyers fee will benefit Heritage and the state taxman.
Now, Heritage’s statement about the time that auctions will end:
“Heritage is also changing the way we close our Internet-only auctions,” said Halperin. “After the auction closes to new bidders (the pre-set time), all previous bidders on each lot will be allowed to continue bidding on that lot until 10 minutes have passed without an increase. This change was implemented in response to the concerns of our Internet bidders about the Internet-wide practice of ‘sniping,’ where a bidder enters a final bid during the last few seconds to win a lot. All prior bidders will now have a reasonable opportunity to respond to any last-minute bidding challenges.”
Heritage believes that the 10-minute extensions will make the auctions more fair, and will result in higher results for sellers. It will also eliminate “sniping,” which can be frustrating.
There can still be sniping, but under the new system it will come in 10-minute intervals, and snipers will have to wait another 10 minutes to see if they still have competition.
Theoretically, if auctions are extended with a bid every 10 minutes, some auctions could last forever.
For the spouses of America who tell their significant others, “I’ll come to bed as soon as the auction ends,” there is this warning: The auction might never end.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9. His “Best Buys” air on KFWB Radio News-98 and his commentary appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
