If you're looking to buy rare coins or limited edition art prints this holiday season, make sure you understand the significance of "first strikes" for rare coins, and the insignificance of "first pulls" for limited edition prints in artwork such as lithographs and silk-screens.
In coins, first strikes, or coins that are struck when the mint's dies are fresh and new, can be better coins with more detail and with a mirrored look. These coins are highly desired by collectors who may call them "proof-like" or describe their images as "frosty."
Coins that are struck after the dies are worn may lack the detail of earlier strikes. In the 1920s, for example, government mints tended to use the same dies for long periods, resulting in very weak strikes and a lack of detail on certain coins. Today, coins minted in the 1920s, especially Lincoln cents that have "full strikes" or sharp details in the portrait and in the wheat ears on the reverse, can command a high premium.
The story is different with artwork, such as limited edition prints, lithographs and silk-screen pieces. Unlike coins which are minted by the millions, these artworks are usually printed or "pulled" by the dozens or even a hundred or so. While coins minted with worn dies will lack detail, art prints are rarely made with lithographic plates or silk screens that have worn out.
When you buy limited edition prints, your eyes will be drawn to the signature of the artist and the number of the print. For example, the piece might be numbered 1/100, indicating the print is the first of an edition of 100.
But that number does not mean the print was indeed the first printed. It is common for many artists to print or "pull" a full edition of 100 pieces or more, and then after the "pulling" is complete, to number the pieces.
In reality, the artist and his assistants rarely number the prints in order. In fact, the last piece "pulled" off the plate or the screens might be numbered "1," and the first might be numbered "100."
In art galleries, many sales people will tell you that a piece numbered "1" is worth more than a piece with a later number. Hogwash. All pieces are valued the same, regardless of the number. What is more important is the total number of prints pulled. Don't let any art dealer pressure you into thinking a lower number is more valuable, because it isn't.
By the way, there are several ways that artists and art publishers can "play with numbers." A limited edition print could have several editions: there could be a normal edition say of 100 prints, and then there could be an edition for "export," and then there could be an edition on special paper (usually rice paper). Each of these editions would have a different set of numbers.
For example the regular edition could have the number "1/100," while the export edition (for South America) could have the number "SA 1/100" and the edition on the special paper could be numbered in Roman numerals as "I/XX" (or 1 out of 20). Remember, the number of the total edition is what counts.
Salvador Dali was well known for having many editions of his lithographs — regular editions, plus editions for South America (SA plus a number), plus deluxe editions with special paper using Roman numerals or the letters AP or EA to indicate an artist's proof.
Beware galleries that tell you artists' proofs are much more valuable than regular edition prints. Yes, they can be more valuable, but not much more valuable. Generally, the artist's proof is printed on a special paper that might cost $50 or $100 more, and that is what the selling price should be — $50 or $100 more.
If you are interested in joining the art market, shop around and ask questions.
* * *
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 News. His commentary appears in The Signal on Saturdays and online daily at www.moneyreporter.com .
