It’s unbelievable, but there really are two-headed quarters out there. There are even two-tailed quarters, and even half dollars with two sides that are the same.
Unfortunately for all of you who think you have found the hottest error coin since 1943 cents were struck on copper blanks instead of steel, these aren’t “mint errors” at all; they were manufactured and are usually sold in magic shops as trick coins.
There are scam artists who try to pass these off as true “error coins,” and there are probably some innocent buyers and sellers of these manufactured two-headed coins, as well. Just be sure you don’t get swept up in one of these sales.
For example, about a week ago, there was an auction on the eBay website for a two-headed quarter.
The coin did not have any third-party authentication, but the seller made some incredible claims including that 2,000 two-headed quarters were minted and that while “1,993 never left the Mint, seven found their way into circulation and I found one.”
The seller said it was “valued at well over $5,000,” and he was starting the bidding at $3,000. The auction ended without a bid— which was the right thing, since the coin was probably not what it was held out to be and probably was worth only a couple of dollars in some trick shop.
Coin experts say such an error from the U.S. Mint is absolutely impossible because of the way coins are minted— an obverse die in one half of the mint press and a reverse die in the other. And even if a mint employee were to make the mistake of loading a press with two obverse dies (one on the top and one on the bottom), how could such a coin escape quality control and security at the mint? Impossible, wouldn’t you say?
I would say impossible as well, except that I was tipped off to a story— a true story— that perhaps has never been made public until now.
It’s a story about one of those famous 1943 cents made out of copper. You know, the coins worth somewhere between $80,000 and $500,000 each, depending who you listen to.
In case you’re not familiar, here’s a brief history lesson:
In 1943 there was a critical shortage of copper because of World War II, so the government elected to mint pennies that year made out of steel. But somehow, several (the exact number is not known) copper cents were minted with the 1943 date.
If you have a 1943 penny that appears to be made out of copper, see if it is attracted to a magnet because if it is, it’s probably a steel 1943 penny that was coated with copper in an attempt to “cash in” on the rarity of the authentic error.
Coin experts say very few 1943 copper cents were minted in error when leftover planchets or blanks for 1942 cents found their way by accident into the mint’s presses.
But I was told— and this was kept strictly hush-hush for years— that one of the 1943 copper cents was intentionally manufactured by a mint employee, then secreted out of the mint. For decades, this particular 1943 copper cent was kept secret in the employee’s bank safe deposit box, only to be discovered after his death by his children.
With the coin was a note, a confession, of the renegade act. The contents of the note were shared with the coin dealer who handled the coin’s sale to the open market, but it was not made public because the dealer and the employee’s heirs feared the coin would be confiscated because of the way it came to be made.
I’m telling this story now maybe hoping, just hoping, that one of these two-headed coins being offered to the public or turning up mysteriously just might be a true product of the mint, and not the product of a skilled craftsman who cut two coins in half and reattached the heads and tails to create magic coins.
But until I see some authentication, perhaps by coin grading experts, I’ll just have to dismiss these two-headed wonders as wonders of the tool shop and someone’s imagination.
By the way, a couple of years ago, my daughter Marisa made what she thought was the “find of a lifetime.” You guessed it: a two-headed quarter she got in change at a store.
While she was convinced it was going to pay for her college education, I could easily see the seam that told the tale of how it was made from two quarters.
Look for the seam
Sometimes seams are hard to see, and then you have to rely on other tests, such as weight or the sound a coin makes when it hits a tabletop.
Let me tell you another story about a U.S. Trade Dollar more than 100 years old.
The coin was put up for sale at a local coin shop, and it drew a lot of attention. But the coin was quickly withdrawn from sale when the dealer pronounced the coin as counterfeit.
He said it made “a funny sound” and demonstrated how it didn’t “ring” when dropped this silver coin onto a countertop in his shop.
I was curious. I thought it was a fine-looking counterfeit, and as I picked it up to examine it, I noticed it also felt lighter than a silver dollar should feel. I examined it closely, bounced it in my hand and said “I think it’s hollow.”
Then I saw it: the fine seam running around the edge of the rim. I turned the coin over, with the seam on the bottom, and tapped the other side. Slowly the coin started to separate.
After a few more taps, the coin opened, with one end held by a fine jeweler’s hinge. It was a carefully and finely manufactured coin made to hold secrets.
Was it the coin that belonged to a spy who moved through the Orient where U.S. Trade Dollars were the principal currency during the 1870s? Perhaps. But inside was the picture of a woman. It was an old photo, perhaps from the 1950s.
The woman in the photo turned out to be the friend of a man who once owned the coin decades ago. He had since died, and his children never knew there was a secret compartment in the coin.
And, oh, about that woman in the picture. She was also supposed to have been a secret. But when the coin came open, this little secret about grandpa and his friend slipped out, too.
The bottom line is, when you manufacture a coin, you also manufacture a little larceny. And the larceny can come with a two-headed coin, a coin out of the wrong metal or a coin meant to hold a secret.
Alan Mendelson of Valencia is the money reporter for KCAL-TV Channel 9 and morning business anchor for KFWB Radio News-98 . His commentary appears in The Signal on Wednesdays and Saturdays, and he appears online daily at www.moredeals.com.
