Yes, many of us investors were lolled into a false sense of security as the year 2000 rolled on.
The first 2 1/2 months of the year saw the technology-stock feeding frenzy continue unabated with the Nasdaq Composite rising another 25 percent from the beginning of the year.
We were all getting a little nervous, but what if we had put that nervousness into action back in late 1999 and jumped off the tech-growth bandwagon then? We would have missed a 50-percent rise in the Nasdaq (through March 15) as well as significant upwards moves in the other stock indexes. So we hung on.
We were being told:
• Don’t worry about the Federal Reserve Board’s continuing efforts to slow down the economy by raising short-term interest rates.
Historically, when the Federal Reserve Board increased interest rates, the stock market declined as the economy slowed down. This time, we were told, it will be different— the economy is far too strong and resilient to be slowed down by any significant degree.
• Continued leaps in productivity fueled by the ongoing advances in technology will more than offset increased costs resulting from rising interest rates.
• So what if tech company price-earnings (P/E) ratios were 100 to 200 times earnings while the brick and mortar company P/Es were hovering in the 20 range? This time it will be different. These tech stocks are different animals. Their growth rates of 40 percent to 100 percent per year justify such high P/Es. And that is if they had any earnings at all!
For those tech companies which did not expect to see a profit for several years, a new method of valuation appeared— one based on revenues. Looking back it is hard to believe that respected market analysts were singing that song.
Well, we saw a significant decline in the Nasdaq from the middle of March to the middle of April, then saw a good rally in the Nasdaq through May and June. The same mantras were again being sung.
Then we came to the last four months of the year. September through December brought:
• More and more earnings pre-announcements by corporations saying they were revising downward their earnings forecasts.
• Rising energy prices, coupled with unrest in the Middle East.
• A presidential election that lasted for 1 1/2 months instead of one day.
We were periodically told about Nasdaq trading ranges. In October we were told by the market gurus that the trading range was supposed to stay between 3,600 and 4,000 for the Nasdaq. This means the Nasdaq Composite Index bottom was supposed to be about 3,600. Then it plunged down to the low-3 ,000 range.
In November the market gurus said the trading range now was somewhere between 3,200 and 3,600 for the Nasdaq. Then it plunged to around 2,600.
In December we were told that the trading range was somewhere between 2,500 and 3,200 for the Nasdaq. Then it plunged to around 2,200.
So much for the experts! I wonder what it will take for us to learn that it isn’t really any different this time.
The adage, “Don’t fight the Fed,” turned out to be just as correct this time as it has been each time before when the Federal Reserve Board has raised interest rates in an effort to slow down the economy. The economy does slow down, corporate profits do decline, and stock prices do come down.
Looking forward, now that the Federal Reserve Board is lowering interest rates in an effort to revive the economy, will the opposite be true? Will the economy revive, corporate profits increase, and stock prices increase?
For some thoughts on that, stay tuned for my next column in about four weeks.
Until then, keep this in mind— a quote from the final economic report given by President Clinton on the South Lawn of the White House on Friday: “The message of this final report is clear— the economy remains strong, on a sound foundation, with a bright future.”
And that is supposed to make us feel better?
D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. “It’s Your Money” appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
