“If I had spare cash, I’d buy stocks now.”
— President Richard M. Nixon
April 28, 1970
...The market declined significantly from 1970 to 1975. The end of the decade saw the market up only 4.8 percent for the entire 10-year stretch.
Let’s see. That would be less than 1/2 percent per year. The 1973-74 stock market crash saw many stocks plunge more than 50 percent in value.
“Long term, the outlook for a rising market hasn’t changed.”
— Shoji Amada, pension fund manager
Feb. 26, 1990
(After a correction lowered the Nikkei index to 33321)
...The Nikkei index proceeded to fall to 14309 by Aug. 18, 1992.
Many financial gurus believe that our 1990s stock boom exhibits a number of similarities to the 1960s market in the U.S. and the 1980s stock market in Japan:
• Historically high stock price/earnings ratios were evident at the end of the booms. The Japanese stock market saw an average P/E ratio of 60 times earnings. Some stocks had P/E ratios of up 200 times earnings.
• A New Paradigm. The 1960s saw electronic companies become the darlings of Wall Street. Instead of “.com” at the end of a company’s name, it was “-onics” and “-tron.”
• Many of those high-flying companies had very high earning growth rate projections... which were never attained.
Today we can see much the same that we witnessed here in the U.S. during the 1960s and in Japan during the 1980s. We now have the S&P 500 Stock Index at an historically high P/E of 31 times trailing earnings. We have the same talk of this being a “new era” as preceded previous major stock market declines.
Kind of makes one nervous, doesn’t it?
But here are the reasons to remain bullish:
• Profits have grown steadily from 1992 to present. We haven’t had any excessive inflationary spikes in earnings over that period.
• Stocks are now seen as being a less risky investment. In the past, a greater return premium— as compared to quality bonds, for example— was demanded from stocks due to their perceived higher risk exposure. That return premium has recently dropped, allowing P/E ratios to rise dramatically and still be seen as acceptable to investors.
• Interest rates are still relatively low— especially on 30-year Treasury bonds— even after the Federal Reserve Board’s most recent rate hike.
• We are still at the frontier for technology, and we still have a long way to go.
• Advances in productivity resulting in more business efficiency are still being achieved.
• Even if the market is overvalued, historically that has not signaled that we are on the verge of a bear market. It takes other events to trigger the bear market, such as declining earnings, rising interest rates coupled with inflation, or war.
With no war imminent and earnings outlooks excellent, the greatest cause for concern right now is rising interest rates. We will have to closely monitor the Federal Reserve Board. If it should raise interest rates too fast so that the economy is choked into a recession, we will have serious problems in the market.
D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. To receive Mr. Norton’s newsletter with more investment advice, contact him through The Signal at 259-1234 ext. 237 or [email protected] . “It’s Your Money” normally appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
