I received a mailer recently that warned me about the perils of probate.
In touting the merits of a living trust, it asked if I was aware that probate expenses can consume 8 to 10 percent of my total estate and that probate delays can run two to five years.
To determine if probate is really that bad, let’s examine both of these claims.
If you had a probate estate of $250,000— a house, car, bank account, small stocks and miscellaneous items— then this mailer claims that your probate costs could run between $20,000 and $25,000. This assumes, of course, that the named executor would claim his statutory fee— the amount of money to which he would be entitled under the law for his services as executor.
The truth is that most relatives, especially children, who serve as executor waive their statutory fee. It is better to receive money as an inheritance— which is income tax-free — than as a fee— which is subject to income taxes. Even if the fee is claimed, it would be about 2.5 percent, or just slightly over $6,000 for this estate.
The statutory attorney fee is the same as the fee to which the executor is entitled. In California, this can be no more than $6,150 on a $250,000 estate. This omits net income earned during estate administration, which is counted towards computing the fee, so the amount may actually be slightly higher.
It is true that an attorney is entitled to “extraordinary fees” if he does work beyond mere distribution of the assets, such as assisting with the sale of an asset or tax-related work, but it must be a reasonable fee and is subject to the approval of the court. Thus, outrageous probate fees are rare. Accountants’ fees just also be factored in, as well as the costs of probate (filing fee, publication, etc.), but these are very small in relation to the total size of the estate.
The more likely scenario is that a $250,000 estate would cost the beneficiaries about $8,000 (just over 3 percent of the estate), or $14,000 (just over 5.5 percent) if the executor claims his statutory fee. This is a far cry from the scary figure of 8 to 10 percent.
Further, certain assets are not included in a probate estate, such as joint tenancy assets, retirement accounts and life insurance policies, and may other items with a designated beneficiary— who receives the assets by contractual obligation rather than probate administration.
Therefore, it is likely that your actual probate estate is less than the sum total of all your assets. The corresponding probate fee, therefore, is likely to be less than you thought.
The claim that probate delays can run two to five years does not apply to the typical estate. True, there are delays mandated by law, such as the creditors’ claim period, but that is only four months. Unless there are problems with liquidation of assets, tax complications or will contests, the average probate probably lasts nine to 12 months.
If your will is drafted, signed and witnessed properly, and there is no fraud or undue influence associated with the making of the will, the chances of a will contest are remote. Even with a will contest or unusual intervening circumstances, the delay will probably be a lot closer to two years.
While a living trust may be a good idea for you and your family, do not think that every estate merits a trust. A probate is not as bad as advertised, and if a will suits your needs, then do not think that your estate will be consumed by heavy fees and costs. Rather, believe that a court-appointed executor who is supervised by the court will use his fiduciary powers to see that your designated beneficiaries end up with your probate estate.
Ronald E. White has practiced law in the Santa Clarita Valley since 1984. “It’s Your Money” appears Mondays and rotates among SCV financial planning professionals.
